Live data from Hacker News

Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

nytimes.com

51–58 of 58 posts

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#51
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I've seen people DJing at parties using two browser windows with Youtube. And ? DJing is about mixing music sources seamlessly, wherever they come from.I wouldnt trust the network during a gig though ,but there is nothing shocking in getting your music from Youtube.

Wilfully playing out pirated, recompressed lossy files and calling yourself a DJ is the height of lameness. If you're going to profit from someone elses work without paying them, try not to make it sound like shit as well.

I doubt anyone DJing stuff from Youtube is getting paid for it.

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#52
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I've seen people DJing at parties using two browser windows with Youtube. And ? DJing is about mixing music sources seamlessly, wherever they come from.I wouldnt trust the network during a gig though ,but there is nothing shocking in getting your music from Youtube.

Wilfully playing out pirated, recompressed lossy files and calling yourself a DJ is the height of lameness. If you're going to profit from someone elses work without paying them, try not to make it sound like shit as well.

I didnt say professional djs.

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#53
The problem I see is that since Soundcloud continues playing after each track, those with ads are going to get some kind of preference in the queue.

This may not be the case, but I am guessing that I am going to start hearing ads even tho I don't typically follow anyone who would put ads on their music.

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How will this affect applications using your API? Roll20, for example, has SoundCloud integration to play music while a game is going on. Will ads play when music is triggered this way? If so, why would anyone continue to use this feature of Roll20?

There's another article here which mentions that specifically. http://bit.ly/oscgu "Carefully-controlled? The ads will only be seen and heard in the US for now, on SoundCloud’s own website and mobile apps – not in tracks embedded elsewhere on the web and/or listened to elsewhere in the world."

Thank you for posting that.

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#55
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey there, I work at SoundCloud. One thing that might not be totally clear in our messaging about this right now is that ads will only play against tracks premier members have chosen to monetise. If you aren't monetising your tracks, your listeners won't be affected.

If so this should really have been made clearer in the press coverage because it is very different from the way I and probably other people understood it. I understand that soundclound would need a way to make money, and what you describe seems like a very reasonable way to proceed. However, a youtube-like or spotify-like ads system would likely be much harder to sell to users.

I guess they haven't made it clear because while this is how it works now, but they don't want to set any expectations of that not changing for the future.

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How will this affect applications using your API? Roll20, for example, has SoundCloud integration to play music while a game is going on. Will ads play when music is triggered this way? If so, why would anyone continue to use this feature of Roll20?

There's another article here which mentions that specifically. http://bit.ly/oscgu "Carefully-controlled? The ads will only be seen and heard in the US for now, on SoundCloud’s own website and mobile apps – not in tracks embedded elsewhere on the web and/or listened to elsewhere in the world."

> for now

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#57
post #22
post #8

I'm not sure this model will work like it did with Youtube. You don't put Youtube on in the background/at a party while friends are over. You sit down and watch a video (hence you're willing to sit through an advertisement). Music streaming that is broken up by advertisements is why people dislike radio and are moving to online services. The reason artists like Soundcloud is it gives a way to distribute music directl…

I'm not sure I agree with the first part of your comment. Spotify already does this, and in my experience plenty of people leave spotify on as background music and/or at a party. My old roommates did this pretty frequently, and while it was annoying at first to hear ads between songs, as long as they're short enough, you eventually just tune them out. If anything I'd say that the youtube style ads that play before yo…

If I was over at my friends' and they'd play ads at me, I'd complain and ask them to put on some real music. They'd ask the same of me.

(though I wouldn't insist, if someone doesn't know how, or just really wants to hear radio with ads, I'm a guest after all)

Re: Popular and Free, SoundCloud Is Now Ready for Ads

#58
post #53

The problem I see is that since Soundcloud continues playing after each track, those with ads are going to get some kind of preference in the queue. This may not be the case, but I am guessing that I am going to start hearing ads even tho I don't typically follow anyone who would put ads on their music.

There's already a song from Red Bull at the TOP of my feed. Bye SoundCloud as you were :(
Post reply on HN