Live data from Hacker News

Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

fivethirtyeight.com

71–80 of 141 posts

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#71

Much of what we are seeing is the effect of our insane visa and immigration policies. The traditional entrepreneurial spirit of the United States was driven by the culture of immigrants. Over 40% of the companies on the Fortune 500 were founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. These were once disruptive startups. Now we make it very difficult for talented and intelligent people to become permanent residen…

Has the number of people becoming U.S. permanent residents or naturalized citizens actually declined, relative to the times those Fortune 500 companies were founded? As far as I can tell, it hasn't: somewhere around 1 million new permanent residencies are granted per year in the 2010s, versus ~250,000 in 1960, which is actually about twice as many relative to population (~0.3% of population annually now, up from ~0.1…

Most green cards today are family-based instead of employment or skill based. Family is a golden word in America, according to the Godfather: "But don't ever take sides with anyone against the Family again." In addition, there are many diversity (lottery), refugee, and asylum green cards.

It's funny while America is hated, and some other countries are touted to have better systems and will soon take over America's leadership, tons of people are voting for America with their feet, and crying for green cards.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#72

Much of what we are seeing is the effect of our insane visa and immigration policies. The traditional entrepreneurial spirit of the United States was driven by the culture of immigrants. Over 40% of the companies on the Fortune 500 were founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. These were once disruptive startups. Now we make it very difficult for talented and intelligent people to become permanent residen…

We have 7-20 million illegal immigrants in the USA out of 313 million total residents. How difficult can it really be to stay?

It's not that hard to stay, but it's very hard to get access to capital, credit and legal resources. The necessity to get paid off the books imposes a ceiling on earning ability.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#73
post #28

As a Professor of entrepreneurship at NYU's engineering school (that VC Fred Wilson called a jewel -- http://avc.com/2014/03/the-value-of-an-engineering-degree ), I can summarize the problem in one phrase many of my students said when describing their goals after graduation: "... but I have to get a job at a big company to sponsor my visa." They're brilliant, motivated, and capable, but almost none are citizens. To s…

And under H1B building a company on the side is illegal because of all the rules forbidding to work for another company.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#74

I think the author of the article went looking for stats to support a title. Corporate America has been disrupted however I think this article was looking for financial failure versus adapting to the market pressures. The corporations below have faced massive disruption: Kodak, HP, GM, Ford, JC Penney, Sears, McDonalds, Radio Shack, Circuit City, Best Buy, Borders, Barnes&Noble, IBM, Microsoft, Xerox, and Target have…

Who disrupted McDonalds?

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agree entirely. This is a perfect write up of the situation at hand. > but one sector that isn't being targeted is the (disintegrating) middle class. So, what (if anything) can we do to fix this? Is there anything a regular person can do or work on to help the (disintegrating) middle class?

I would suggest joining unions and encouraging others to join them. With all the nonsense coming out of Google, Microsoft and others regarding wage warfare against their own employees I'm shocked that developers haven't unionized.

There's way too much libertarianism, if not outright objectivism, in this industry for just about any kind of organized labor to exist.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#76
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agree entirely. This is a perfect write up of the situation at hand. > but one sector that isn't being targeted is the (disintegrating) middle class. So, what (if anything) can we do to fix this? Is there anything a regular person can do or work on to help the (disintegrating) middle class?

I am thinking of favoring remote work. That way employees won't have to spent the largest part of their salary in expensive rents, and for the employer it's advantageous at he can pay a bit lower than the market rate (and still make his employees happy). That's a simple measure new startups could adopt, and I keep being surprised YC companies are not looking for remote people.

I'm also surprised we don't see more remote work in the more computational bits of academia, but there's still a widespread view that remote work is bad for team cohesion and serendipitous collaboration.

Were one cynically inclined, one might wonder if remote work is unpopular because it lets people bypass some of the status-signalling systems that tend to develop within organisations.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#77
post #24

I have another suggestion for the decline in startup rates: health care and college expenses. The historically "prime" years for entrepreneurship are in one's late 30's to early 50's, years when one typically has a family in need of healthcare, college tuition, and hopefully retirement at some point down the line. In the 70's and 80's someone could leave the security of their big company, get relatively affordable pr…

I dunno, state schools are still pretty cheap. My sister's tuition with room and board is $10k per year. If you are someone smart enough to be an entrepreneur in your late 30s, you should have a corporate job paying 150k+ and can save all 4 years worth in a matter of months with a bit of determination. And health care, while expensive, isn't as big of a deal as most people make it out to be. Get a high deductible pla…

considering that 250k for a couple puts a person in the top 2% in the nation, its not as easy as you make it sound to pull off 'just getting a 150k salary job'.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#78
post #28

As a Professor of entrepreneurship at NYU's engineering school (that VC Fred Wilson called a jewel -- http://avc.com/2014/03/the-value-of-an-engineering-degree ), I can summarize the problem in one phrase many of my students said when describing their goals after graduation: "... but I have to get a job at a big company to sponsor my visa." They're brilliant, motivated, and capable, but almost none are citizens. To s…

I know i'm going to be slaughtered in downvotes, but have the top schools ever considered admitting more citizens?

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#79
post #32
post #24

I have another suggestion for the decline in startup rates: health care and college expenses. The historically "prime" years for entrepreneurship are in one's late 30's to early 50's, years when one typically has a family in need of healthcare, college tuition, and hopefully retirement at some point down the line. In the 70's and 80's someone could leave the security of their big company, get relatively affordable pr…

You nailed it. I also add that the government (probably varies allot by state) makes it very difficult to hire employees. My wife and I hired a nanny a few years ago, doing everything by the book regarding taxes and insurance. Still got fined twice for some infantile amount owed on something, even after three calls to the state office resulted in three separate amounts of what we owed. I'll NEVER take on an employee…

Sounds like a great business opportunity for a SaaS app that nails the details of nanny accounting in all fifty states.

Re: Corporate America Hasn’t Been Disrupted

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would suggest joining unions and encouraging others to join them. With all the nonsense coming out of Google, Microsoft and others regarding wage warfare against their own employees I'm shocked that developers haven't unionized.

There's way too much libertarianism, if not outright objectivism, in this industry for just about any kind of organized labor to exist.

Honestly, it's hard to organize people for any type of movement that are in the top 10-20% of incomes in the country. Yes, we may all be getting screwed, but we're still making bank compared to most.
Post reply on HN