Live data from Hacker News

Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

engadget.com

21–30 of 190 posts

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#24
post #22

Such a pointless release that will only lead to customer confusion. I bet those will be cancelled as soon as the MSFT purchase (finally) closes. Just goes to show why Nokia has been sold off. Sad.

It may be a negotiating tactic. You know, you need us more than we need you.

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#26

Ars Technica [1] put it best. These phones are dead on arrival. This is not the first time Nokia has done something like this. It released a Meego version of the N9, its long-in-development Symbian successor, before immediately abandoning the platform and switching to Windows Phone. This isn't a sign of some deep strategy. It's just standard Nokia platform craziness. 1: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/02/nokia-to…

Well the idea was good the implementation sucks as usual. Android without the play store is not as useful or flexible and you can't compete with other budget phones which do have the play store so you're shooting yourself in the foot.

As log as there's an easy way for end users to put it on it shouldn't be such a big deal though.

What I suspect they are attempting to do is get back into the low budget phone market which they used to rule before they stupidly gave it up voluntarily and the only reason they are using Android is because it's the only one suitable for that hardware however this is not the old low end market they used to know.

Before it used to be acceptable to have only a few crap apps for phones but now even the low budget phones have access to the play store. I wonder if they will make it with this self inflicted handicap.

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#27
post #18
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think they plan making any new S40 phones, so that would make it two OSes.

I counted four. Feature phone OS (ODM), Asha, Windows Phone and Nokia X Platform as they are calling it.

The "featurephone" OS is S40 and it's in both "classic" phones (e.g. 515) and Ashas.... unless there is something I've missed completely. And come to think of it, I haven't heard any confirmation of closing the production of S40 phones, so I guess that'd make it 3.

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#28
Weak specs, no physical buttons, and one of the two missing an SD card. I predict these will not do well.

Edit: Oh, and the interface is awful. The sensible thing would have been to use Android as inspiration to redesign Metro to be less ugly and nonfunctional, not to try and port Metro to Android...

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#29
Weird.

Microsoft intended to handle Android as a non-primary platform. I'm curious if those apps are going to be available on the Google Play Store as well (i hope so).

With this move, they should have update apps on the Android platform.

Also, i'm curious if developers have to change their Android APP UI to fit the new UI from Nokia (could be dangerous for Nokia).

Next, Android users all have a gmail account, now they need to switch to Outlook ? Not exactly user-friendly. Most developers have to change their Authentication also on their app.

Re: Nokia announces the X and X+, its first Android phones

#30

So Microsoft has a Linux distro. Interesting. Anybody care to hazard a guess what the future holds? My take is that this was well in development before the MS/Nokia deal went through (it has gone through, hasn't it?) and Microsoft were not (have not been) able to get it canned. Or, shock, horror, maybe Microsoft are testing the waters - they already make a bunch from Linux patents, maybe they want to see how much the…

>they already make a bunch from Linux patents

I'm interested in how they apparently do this - especially as the Linux development process is open and MS' is secret.

As it was, if they decided to try patent trolling, chances are they'd get crushed by google, Red Hat, even Oracle...

Post reply on HN