Live data from Hacker News

Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

bloomberg.com

61–70 of 97 posts

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#61
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a pretty _horrible_ example of the parties coalescing into a single viewpoint, since intentionally defaulting on our debts is an extremist view by any definition. That's like saying "clearly the two parties are basically the same because they both don't support nuking Russia". "Both parties agree not to act like lunatics" is a terrible example of "the parties are merging". A much less bizarre example would be…

This is not an extreme example. The alternative was conditional terms on expanding the debt limit, not defaulting on the debt. The bill passed without any additional restrictions on spending or changes to collection. The national debt is one of the biggest issues in the country right now and both parties are doing little to stop its expansion. As I said in my original comment, the fringe are the ones who are legitima…

The national debt is a problem created by the budget, not by the debt ceiling. Using the threat of not paying debt you've already incurred via the laws you've already passed to try and circumvent the political process is idiotic and harmful. The debt ceiling does not create debt, it should always be raised, it should in fact be eliminated and all debt incurred should simply be paid period.

The place to deal with the debt issue is in budget negotiations, not by refusing to pay bills from past budgets because you didn't agree with past agreements.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#62
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The national debt is one of the biggest issues in the country right now I disagree with this claim. Unfortunately, it is also the claim upon which the rest of your claims are founded, so I'll have to disagree with everything else you said, too.

> I disagree with this claim. Unsupported opinions are pretty meaningless. How is it not one of the biggest issues? The national debt story has been making constant front-page of news for 3+ years now. Anyone who doesn't see the huge long-term significance of the massive debt is exhibiting significant ignorance to economics. The USA is making a serious gamble that the economy will be strong and fast-growing for the n…

> The national debt story has been making constant front-page of news for 3+ years now

So has Justin Beeber; that doesn't validate it. In the news != newsworthy.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#63
post #5

More political theater from Rand Paul. If only he was as transparent to the average voter.

Would a similar suit by Pelosi also be theater to you?

This is theater to me because both parties are complacent. Rand Paul would like you to believe Obama is responsible but most of us know it didn't start with Obama and it won't end with him.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#64

My two minutes of internet research says that this is going to get tossed. A President can't be sued for actions taken as President, but can be sued for personal actions. A Daily Beast article mentions this: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/01/30/can-bachman...

Minor nitpick, a president can be sued, however they have the right to refuse to be sued.

What would that imply for this case then? Assuming President Obama refuses to be sued, does that throw the case out? Or does the case still proceed with the other defendants? Can all the other defendants refuse to be sued as well?

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#65
post #3

Take a look at the comments section if you want to see political tribalism at its best. > I thought Bush orchestrated the Patriot Act... who knew..? > Regardless of your opinion of the surveillance, you gotta see this as a cynical political move. Bet he wouldn't sue a Republican president. Isn't good enough to disagree with Obama - a candidate has to demonstrate outrage with him to gain cred with the base. Everything…

wait until they call Paul a racist.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#67
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The national debt is one of the biggest issues in the country right now I disagree with this claim. Unfortunately, it is also the claim upon which the rest of your claims are founded, so I'll have to disagree with everything else you said, too.

> I disagree with this claim. Unsupported opinions are pretty meaningless. How is it not one of the biggest issues? The national debt story has been making constant front-page of news for 3+ years now. Anyone who doesn't see the huge long-term significance of the massive debt is exhibiting significant ignorance to economics. The USA is making a serious gamble that the economy will be strong and fast-growing for the n…

It is only a big issue if you don't understand the economics.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#68
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you owe your bank 10000 dollars and cant pay you have a problem if you owe your bank 1 million (or in our case 17 trillion)and cant pay they have a problem.

A significant portion of the debt is held by Americans. I don't get your point.

My point is debt isn’t a problem unless there are significant consequences attached to it. You talk of economic understanding but your theory is flawed.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is right vs. left. He wouldn't have done this to a Republican president, do you think he, Rand Paul, would have? Do you know much about Rand Paul? The man's entire political career is based on acting the partisan part. Like it or not, everything literally is partisan politics. No issue in the US rises above partisanship. That's the system we live in, you'll just have to accept that or attempt to change it direct…

If you have the power and opportunity to change a wrong, but do nothing, then you're as culpable as whoever caused the wrong in the first place. In this case we're proving that a wrong occurred by attempting to get retribution for the alleged wrong - whoever is targeted (be they Rep. Dem. Lib.) is inconsequential for the general public, aside from adjusting voting patterns in the future. Once the suit determines culp…

If what you say is true, then every single second of every single day that I'm not spending my time maximizing my benefit to society and others, I'm living in... well, "sin" or whatever moral bad state you would like to call it.

You may choose to live like that, but I prefer to judge myself in a way that doesn't make literally everything I do an immoral act.

Re: Obama Sued by Rand Paul Over Phone Surveillance Program

#70

Very thankful we have a few good men like Rand still in politics.

Please. There is nothing good about Rand. He is just cynically trying to stoke the libertarian base.

I think the desire to not be spied upon without warrant goes beyond the libertarian base.
Post reply on HN