Live data from Hacker News

Today is The Day We Fight Back

thedaywefightback.org

71–80 of 267 posts

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#71
Snowden, the NSA scandals and the subsequent political and media responses are very clear example of our right eroding. But, they are mostly concerned with the US Government and US citizens.

This is a global fight. The perpetrators and the victims are everywhere.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#72
I find it a weirdly ironic that a protest opposing government collection of personal information, such as political affiliation, from opt in data stores on the internet consist of declaring your political affiliation in an opt in data store on the internet.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#74
It is a positive day for the freedom of information and I am happy to support it, make the calls and emails, and tell friends about it.

I also think framing it as a one day campaign where the “fighting” involves passive action at the individual level is not a game winning strategy. It is still a great rallying signal though, and its effects have already gone beyond the single day, and for every person too lazy to change their avatar back, they will carry on for a good while longer in some way.

However, the motivation for the average person to even think about engaging such an overwhelming and invisible force as mass surveillance is very close to zero. For those who are willing, involvement seems to be passive (donating to a more capable organization, hitting a like button, resharing links), bursty (waiting for organized events to rally around), or demoralizing (low visibility of opponent, lack of support from uninterested peers or locals, extremely slow and indirect feedback loop for any action).

For these reasons, I hope that a campaign modeled as a constantly running open source game engine emerges, because that is actually just the bare minimum required for victory - to at least continue playing the game as long as your opponent is playing, no matter whether you are winning or losing at the moment.

A game model will at least make undeniably clear that there exists a thing worth playing for (your personal information perhaps), that there are actual opponents who can and will take this thing from you, and the visibility and mechanics needed for you to take action to protect that thing.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#76
post #34

My little fight back are some instructions on how to provide your own internet services, including encryption. http://freedombone.uk.to/ It's not ideal, of course, but in the short term since there seems to be no political appetite for relinquishment or meaningful reform then technical mitigation strategies - if they can be sufficiently popularised - may help to reduce the harm resulting from mass surveillance. Ultim…

That's a good little installation document. I'm going to give that a go with a raspberry pi when I get home. How up to date are the instructions?

These instructions have been put together recently - mostly in January this year. It's an ongoing effort to include as much useful communications software as possible.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#77

Surely this site has been set up by the NSA to harvest the details of everyone who opposes them...?

Assuming you're not trolling, why would you not assume this about Hacker News as well? This place has practically become a hangout for armchair dissidents, and employees from many large tech companies are known to post here. It would make the perfect honeypot.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#78

As far as I am concerned, fighting back for a day is useless. The NSA is probably going to find they have already lost this battle because we now trust their co-conspirators a lot less. It's the slow, relatively minor pressure over time by billions of people that will change things. But the real danger is with the next battle. I think we are going to see a major showdown over legality of encryption generally within t…

> I think we are going to see a major showdown over legality of encryption generally within the next few years with a push for legally required back-doors ...

History, people. History. This showdown already happened and the intelligence services lost.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#79
post #34

My little fight back are some instructions on how to provide your own internet services, including encryption. http://freedombone.uk.to/ It's not ideal, of course, but in the short term since there seems to be no political appetite for relinquishment or meaningful reform then technical mitigation strategies - if they can be sufficiently popularised - may help to reduce the harm resulting from mass surveillance. Ultim…

This is really, really, well done. It'd be nice with some simple styling, to not make it look too "alpha-geek" to the wider tech sphere. Otherwise, cracking work.

Re: Today is The Day We Fight Back

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a good little installation document. I'm going to give that a go with a raspberry pi when I get home. How up to date are the instructions?

It's not little - it's quite comprehensive. Excellent job done. It's explained quite well in a very enjoyable writing style. I think anyone who knows enough to add a banner to a webpage can work their way through the document. It's a good idea to promote it as an alternative because from the outside at least, it seems freedombox has lost momentum since the privoxy release, even though the idea is sound.

Yes, that's the intention. Anyone with minimal skills should be able to follow the instructions in a straightforward way.

Until such time as FreedomBox or maybe ArkOS are in a more developed condition this is about the best I can manage.

Post reply on HN