Live data from Hacker News

US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

bits.enigma.io

71–80 of 132 posts

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#71
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're right, I was a rank off. That being said, a Colonel is often still in charge of a couple thousand people.

I disagree. I worked with plenty of AF Col's in the 5-sided-puzzle-palace that managed offices with 15-30 folks. They worked alongside a GS-13 to GS-15 types.

[deleted]

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

sure! we actually posted a link to the raw CSV before we pushed this in the beginning of the shutdown: https://twitter.com/enigma_io/status/385166410063691776

Maybe I've lost something in all the details, how is this list compiled? I was born in DC and grew up in the area, as such I know a lot of current federal employees who should be on a 2012 list. I grepped for a handful of names of folks I know personally and so far found only one. (For privacy reasons I will not share the names of non-matches here.) Update: Ok, I've found two now. Still many more non-matches than mat…

The data is from this dataset:

http://php.app.com/fed_employees11/search.php

...obtained by Asbury Park Press via a FOIA. It doesn’t include FBI, CIA, Defense Department, or IRS employees, or employees involved in security work, nuclear materials or national security matters.

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#73
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not judging one way or another, but is privacy not something the Swedish people are interested in?

If you were Swedish you might not consider it private information. Being from the US I do, but I don't consider my age private. It's difficult to say where a culture should draw the line, in an objective way.

How is that a privacy concern in the US if you find the salaries of over a million people on a government website? I find that a bit disturbing.

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#76
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

sure! we actually posted a link to the raw CSV before we pushed this in the beginning of the shutdown: https://twitter.com/enigma_io/status/385166410063691776

Very cool, thanks! Already having some fun: Location with highest average salary among stations with >25 federal employees: Islip, NY - 496 employees $43,162 min $140,781 avg $179,700 max

That looks like Brookhaven National Lab.

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#77

for anyone who's interested, i generated a link to this sorted by the base salary (descending): https://bits.enigma.io/s/t/8b6aa881e02d8c2b851a3d5140c263f4 and here's a link to a full export (csv): https://s3.amazonaws.com/enigma-data-export/shutdown/enigma-...

Where is the president and his aids?

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#78
post #36

You could probably make some amazing visualizations of this data. In Sweden, all the tax records are public information. You can literally look up how much your neighbor makes in a year. So each year after tax season, the tabloids all print up huge lists of "the richest people in YOUR neighborhood!". I've always been disappointed that with all this data, they've never gone beyond that and visualized the data geograph…

I'm not judging one way or another, but is privacy not something the Swedish people are interested in?

You can use a house or lifestyle metric to determine who is richer or poorer. A house or your lifestyle is about as public as it gets.

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#79
post #46
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you're talking about a public library catering to homeless people and children, a "librarian" is typically an educated professional, usually with an advanced degree, who has enough subject matter expertise to efficiently help researchers find relevant materials.

What an ignorant thing to say. Public libraries do more than cater to homeless people and children. They also employee the advanced degree educated professional librarians you are talking about too.

But they are correct a librarian is a professional just the same as an engineer

Re: US Federal Employee Salaries (2012)

#80
post #34

Similar data, but still mostly limited to higher pay levels and by government department is available for the UK ( see for example: http://data.gov.uk/dataset/staff-organograms-and-pay-departm... ) a side note: It is generally accepted that the US government pays the highest salaries compared to other government agencies worldwide. This is the reason why the U.N. uses the US government scales and pays as their base (…

My understanding is that US government salaries are high because the US private sector pays so well for comparable positions. The US is in the peculiar business of competing with itself, in a sense, or at least with its own economic model.

Private vs. public isn't such a teeth-gnashing, nail-biting dilemma for many other countries, who generally seem to do a better job of mentally separating the two sectors. The general agreement in other countries is that public = stable job, lower pay, higher "public service" calling; private = higher salary, less stability, etc.

Of course, this isn't taking into account countries like China -- where a government position is the best route into cushy, lucrative gigs in the private sector, and in fact, that's often the entire point. (To some degree, this is also the case in the US, at least at the higher levels of public service.) But I digress.

Post reply on HN