Live data from Hacker News

The problem with Android is choice

sixrevisions.com

51–60 of 67 posts

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#51
post #30
post #8

To present Android's Intents as some disadvantage must be pure ignorance.

To pretend that for the majority this isn't annoying is disingenuous.

Have you used Android? It's really not that annoying.

It's actually one of the best things Android has over iPhones right now.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#52
post #22
post #3

FTA: I think many who extol Android’s flexibility fall into the tinkerer category, including some tech bloggers. [...] That’s fun for them; but they’ve made the mistake of not understanding how their motivation differs from the rest of us. The problem with usability nuts and Apple nuts is that they fall into the "one perfect solution exists" category. That's fun for them, as they like their uniform devices just fine…

>The problem with usability nuts and Apple nuts is that they fall into the "one perfect solution exists" category. The problem with pointing out any real or perceived flaw in Android is that you are immediately branded as "apple nut" or "trapped in a walled garden" or " An enemy of open source" or some other nonsense >That's fun for them, as they like their uniform devices just fine and get to write whiny blog posts…

Good grief. It was sarcasm. I was pointing out that the same prose can be used in the other direction with only minimal changes in the logic. Generally that makes for good evidence that the logic is basically flawed and that the "argument" being presented is just an opinion.

And yes: this blogger surely has much better content in other posts, and surely the same nonsense exists on the other side. But this post was only nonsense in one direction.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#53
For the context of this article I think there's a distinction to be made when it comes to choice and flexibility. Sure, when you go to buy an Android you're forced to choose. But when it comes to using an Android device a lot of decisions are made by default you just have the option/flexibility to change the behavior (ie there's a default keyboard but you can swap it out if you'd like). Ultimately I think the flexibility is a good thing, day to day with my Android tablet I don't feel bombarded with choices yet if there's something I don't like about it I'm more likely to be able to fix it then with iOS.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#54
post #33
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Considering how many people end up with it by default because it's the cheap (or free) option would suggest otherwise...

That's the real key, it's popular because it's cheap, imagine trying to claim Chevy makes a better car than BMW because more people buy Chevy.

I don't know anybody who has a "cheap" Android phone. They are all SGS4, HTC One, etc. which are around the same price as the iPhone.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#56
post #51
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To pretend that for the majority this isn't annoying is disingenuous.

Have you used Android? It's really not that annoying. It's actually one of the best things Android has over iPhones right now.

I have a Nexus 4. Had a Nexus S. I find it irritating, in a papercut kind of way.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#57
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the real key, it's popular because it's cheap, imagine trying to claim Chevy makes a better car than BMW because more people buy Chevy.

I don't know anybody who has a "cheap" Android phone. They are all SGS4, HTC One, etc. which are around the same price as the iPhone.

These phones represent a fraction of the overall android market, almost 1/3 of android phones are much cheaper devices still running 2.2/2.3, etc.

edit: Revised most to 1/3.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#58
post #46
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>There are a lot of things wrong with Android, and the sooner the community talks about them, the greater the chance Android has of becoming what you all want it to be That could take a while. Just remember back a few years when Android 1.x was out against the iPhone. Oh how the fandroids were gushing just how awesome their android is compared to the iPhone and when met with the clearly shortcomings of Android, they…

> You know, back then, iPhone has always had a smooth UI. Guess you never experienced an iPhone 2G or 3G on iOS 4. You'd press an icon and 5 seconds later something would happen. Was a complete disaster... http://www.zdnet.com/blog/mobile-gadgeteer/apple-should-advi...

Not the same. You are comparing a new OS on old hardware. The (rather abrupt) OP was comparing a new OS on new hardware. This is similar to my experience with Android.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#59
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know anybody who has a "cheap" Android phone. They are all SGS4, HTC One, etc. which are around the same price as the iPhone.

These phones represent a fraction of the overall android market, almost 1/3 of android phones are much cheaper devices still running 2.2/2.3, etc. edit: Revised most to 1/3.

That's not true though.

http://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#60
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These phones represent a fraction of the overall android market, almost 1/3 of android phones are much cheaper devices still running 2.2/2.3, etc. edit: Revised most to 1/3.

That's not true though. http://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html

Fixed that for you, 1/3 of android devices are still trapped <= 2.3
Post reply on HN