Live data from Hacker News

Discovering Sketch

medium.com

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: Discovering Sketch

#41
post #25
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love Sketch, but I don't like Fireworks. I find Fireworks awkward and clunky.

yeah, the UI is not sexy. But the feature set that is being boasted in the article is THE SAME from firewoks around 1999. It was the only place i could get some vector work and still be pixel perfect. Last used photoshop in 2006 and it wasn't even close. ...sadly gimp tries too hard to be a photoshop clone even copying the lame export dialog instead of save as...

How about Inkscape?

Re: Discovering Sketch

#42
post #8

This looks very much like Fireworks. The author mentioned that he won't discuss it since Adobe discontinued it, but the resemblance is uncanny. I never understood why Fireworks wasn't more widely used/praised; I found it to be absolutely perfect for designing web graphics.

I love Sketch, but I don't like Fireworks. I find Fireworks awkward and clunky.

Seems like most designers dismiss Fireworks before even giving it a chance. Once you get over the initial bump it actually feels much nicer to work with than Photoshop.

The only thing really listed in this article that Fireworks hasn't done for years is the retina capabilities.

Fireworks blows sketch out of the water performance wise and also opens layered PSDs/copy and paste support for vectors from Illustrator.

Adobe killing off Fireworks just proves how little they understand the needs of their customers.

Re: Discovering Sketch

#43

Sketch literally gave me the push I needed to go from a non-designing developer to a halfway decent designer. It's really that good. The major negative right now is performance. I used Sketch to design a full iOS app with 7 or 8 screens on a fast mbp and things were seriously crawling. I had to break up separate screens into separate sketch files and even then it was laggy. Sketch team, your product is amazing, but p…

Try Fireworks, I've used it with 40 page documents with no real issues.

Re: Discovering Sketch

#46

Seems to me that this app could implement HTML exporting better than Photoshop does, since it can export CSS already. Is this implemented or on the roadmap?

I hope not. Sketch should stay lean and be easy to make plugins for. Also, typically auto generated HTML sucks.

Re: Discovering Sketch

#48
post #37

I tried it a few weeks ago and after working for about 2 hours on something I realized that Sketch doesn't have any support for color management (switching color profiles etc.). This is a showstopper for me.

Does it need them… as a screen design tool?
Post reply on HN