Live data from Hacker News

iOS 7: Catch me if you can

allenpike.com

21–30 of 131 posts

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#21

I don't care about 3d or blur or other eye candy. I'd happily trade all that crap off for the battery life of my old Nokia 1100.

The 3D and blur aren't what's draining your battery. The big ass LTE radio sucking down videos, music, and photos is what's doing it. That and the huge, brilliant LCD screen staring at you.

Optimizing battery life by getting rid of animations and graphical effects would be extremely penny-wise, pound-foolish.

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#22
post #10
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd rephrase that as ios7 was clearly made to catch up with android 4 and holo, but maybe that's just me. there's nothing revolutionary in ios7 shown so far. that said, I can't wait for Apple to sue Android over the things they just stole from them.

There is some "flat" design that is similar to Android, but the similarities are fairly superficial and not what the article was addressing.

And it is not even flat. Apple talks about three things regarding new design: depth, deference and clarity. Nothing about flatness, on the contrary, it's about establishing visual hierarchy via layers. Also, even bigger part will be not in the static appearance but in subtle motions when interacting, thanks to UIKit Dynamics.

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#23

I don't care about 3d or blur or other eye candy. I'd happily trade all that crap off for the battery life of my old Nokia 1100.

The 3D and blur aren't what's draining your battery. The big ass LTE radio sucking down videos, music, and photos is what's doing it. That and the huge, brilliant LCD screen staring at you. Optimizing battery life by getting rid of animations and graphical effects would be extremely penny-wise, pound-foolish.

[deleted]

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#25

I don't care about 3d or blur or other eye candy. I'd happily trade all that crap off for the battery life of my old Nokia 1100.

In time. I think the battery life vs. computing power tradeoff took a turn in 2007 because batteries were finally robust enough to handle a bright screen for a reasonable amount of time.

Ideally I would like a device which has a battery which, when bought, will last the lifetime of the product.

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#26
> The 3D, the blur, the compositing – all of them are disabled or degraded on the [iPhone 4's] A4.

I hadn't heard that before, and it's quite interesting. Does anyone know if previous iOS versions have similar feature segmentation, other than the obvious (and perhaps artificial) ones like Siri and 3d maps?

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#27
"Try copying this assholes"

Seriously? I can't get over there are iOS fanboys out there still with their heads so far in the sand.

Along with more characterizations of web development that are a decade out of date... sigh. (And anyone who doesn't understand what I mean should watch the Shadow DOM and Polymers presentations from this year's Google IO. They really need to put the Sandbox on a public url for a quick impressive demo...)

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#28
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is some "flat" design that is similar to Android, but the similarities are fairly superficial and not what the article was addressing.

And it is not even flat. Apple talks about three things regarding new design: depth, deference and clarity. Nothing about flatness, on the contrary, it's about establishing visual hierarchy via layers. Also, even bigger part will be not in the static appearance but in subtle motions when interacting, thanks to UIKit Dynamics.

> Nothing about flatness, on the contrary, it's about establishing visual hierarchy via layers.

This is exactly what the Android design is about as well.

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#29
Nice to see a non-negative analysis of iOS7. Not having tested it myself, I hadn't realized that iOS7 was actually pushing the boundaries of what's possible with modern hardware. My previous impression was that, if anything, it was a simplification of sorts and that seemed a dubious direction. Thanks for pointing this out!

Re: iOS 7: Catch me if you can

#30
post #8

This is assuming that everyone is chasing the same level of perfection as apple. If the web can provide a "good enough" interface will the bulk of developers go to the extra effort of native apps? Currently things like games are (largely) not good enough on mobile web and so the issue is forced, but building a native app for a nicer blur effect? Probably not.

I'd argue that bulk of developers are already doing native. The thing is, extra effort is required to replicate with web technologies even simple things that native SDKs offer. If everything you know is HTML, JS, CSS then yes, learning iOS or Android SDK will require some effort but it is worth it. Even the best webapps still feel subpar on iOS6, on iOS 7 they will feel very clumsy.
Post reply on HN