Live data from Hacker News

Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

facebook.com

51–60 of 90 posts

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#51
post #40
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ok, but uhmm, I was asking about recent developments in Istanbul, not islamization. btw abortion is forbidden in Poland, so is drinking on the street, and we have religion at primary school as well as other sorts of political and social influence by the church. and yeah, I know about how Turkey is leaning towards an islamic state and Ataturk is probably rolling in his grave, but your particular examples are not that…

But this is not about Istanbul. It is not about a park or a shopping mall, you hear about Istanbul because that’s where 1/4 of the country lives in there are protests in Ankara Izmir Eskisehir Adana etc. > but your particular examples are not that radical to be honest. Every time I head that I like to remind people that Iran in the 70s was not much different than your average European country [1]. https://www.google.…

>Every time I head that I like to remind people that Iran in the 70s was not much different than your average European country [1].

Exactly. And even Kabul in Afghanistan was a very modern town and somewhat of a hippy mecca in the 1960s, with women in miniskirts, alcohol, etc.

I've spent a good bit of time in Turkey in the past 15 years. Modern Turks who don't wish to live under strict Islamic rule are very much on guard, since they know exactly where Erdogan and his type want the country to be (hint: it looks a lot closer to Iran than France). And while I criticized them for being "undemocratic" when I first visited Turkey in 1998, I wasn't the one who was going to have to permanently live under a strict Islamic government if Erdogan succeeded (and he was thwarted the first time). But comparing Turkey now to Turkey back then, he is succeeding now, little by little. And once his "reforms" are in place, there will be no going back.

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#52
post #41
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Forcing Religion on children: No I mean Imams acting as guidance counsellors. Children refusing to take religion classes not given their grade cards. Restrictions on TV: You do not /can not threaten to cancel a TV show as a prime minister because the show portrait a Ottoman sultan in a way he did not like (I do not watch tv I don't know the exact details but that’s basically what he said.) Still not a single governme…

Imams acting as guidance counsellors: If there is a demand, I see no problems. No body is forcing people to do that. Edit: Also it would be nice for Imams to give some consultation they are virtually doing nothing. Your second sentence sounds like a stupid rumor. Good citation please. Again, To me whole minister of religion can go away (which was founded by Ataturk). TV: Well blame press for their cowardliness. Threa…

I'll begin by saying I do not believe in a personal god. Well Imams as guidance counsellors are extremely dangerous because unlike Christianity Islam never had the enlightenment period it is still stuck in middle ages. That's why you have people getting stoned in 2013 or girls getting gang raped and then executed for blasphemy search wikipedia for references. This is line of thinking these kids will be guided to and when you have 80k mosques vs 60k schools it will get out of hand really fast. Just the other day there was a protest where people literally kissed each other they were attacked by by people telling them this a muslim country and them, the religious youth won't let that.

You can not go to court that’s the problem. Checkout today’s papers for Turkey sabah vatan zaman etc. You don't need to know Turkish you won't see a single picture of the riots. Here is the cover of one of the biggest sabah [1].

[1]https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/94205...

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#53
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it s like a scene from Avatar. Turks are revolting to stop the killing of 75 year old trees, police reacts violently and protests turn against the government. Trees are leading the people..

And protesters are destroying stuff around. Fantastic.

No protestor is doing any harm around. These are Civil disguised cops trying to make reason for their aggression. Been there seen it.

By the way I can't believe we still have blind believers in RTE's virtual democracy.

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#54
post #53
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And protesters are destroying stuff around. Fantastic.

No protestor is doing any harm around. These are Civil disguised cops trying to make reason for their aggression. Been there seen it. By the way I can't believe we still have blind believers in RTE's virtual democracy.

Sure. They burn stuff for warming up. http://www.radikal.com.tr/turkiye/izmir_yangin_yeri-1135843

Assuming you know Turkish:

"...Gediz Üniversitesi'nin Çankaya Yerleşkesi binasının camlarını kıran ardından Şair Eşref Bulvarı üzerindeki Mc Donald binasını da taş yağmuruna tutan eylemciler, Talatpaşa üzerindeki Sevinç Pastanesi'nin önündeki yolu kapattı."

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#55
post #54
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No protestor is doing any harm around. These are Civil disguised cops trying to make reason for their aggression. Been there seen it. By the way I can't believe we still have blind believers in RTE's virtual democracy.

Sure. They burn stuff for warming up. http://www.radikal.com.tr/turkiye/izmir_yangin_yeri-1135843 Assuming you know Turkish: "...Gediz Üniversitesi'nin Çankaya Yerleşkesi binasının camlarını kıran ardından Şair Eşref Bulvarı üzerindeki Mc Donald binasını da taş yağmuruna tutan eylemciler, Talatpaşa üzerindeki Sevinç Pastanesi'nin önündeki yolu kapattı."

These fires are barricading against cops. Police is trying to kill. Using unbelievable force and still you say having some garbage fires are looting?

By the way I say I have seen civil cops looting and protesters preventing them. But sure main stream media is the best news source.

Edit:

I believe these are also protesters trying to kill wounded cops? https://twitter.com/Kadirkaymakci/status/340791432891748352/...

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#56
That were all empty teargas cans, https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BLn89fZCIAA0Gwd.jpg doing this, http://pbs.twimg.com/media/BLevznnCQAEOR1j.jpg and made in http://pbs.twimg.com/media/BLnx94jCIAE8yQ9.jpg

This man is pronounced dead, but maybe he survived with major injuries. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbRgMqkSvRg

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#57
post #55
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure. They burn stuff for warming up. http://www.radikal.com.tr/turkiye/izmir_yangin_yeri-1135843 Assuming you know Turkish: "...Gediz Üniversitesi'nin Çankaya Yerleşkesi binasının camlarını kıran ardından Şair Eşref Bulvarı üzerindeki Mc Donald binasını da taş yağmuruna tutan eylemciler, Talatpaşa üzerindeki Sevinç Pastanesi'nin önündeki yolu kapattı."

These fires are barricading against cops. Police is trying to kill. Using unbelievable force and still you say having some garbage fires are looting? By the way I say I have seen civil cops looting and protesters preventing them. But sure main stream media is the best news source. Edit: I believe these are also protesters trying to kill wounded cops? https://twitter.com/Kadirkaymakci/status/340791432891748352/...

Conspiracy assertions like "trying to kill us" and "civil cops looting" make me no longer want to continue this thread.

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#58
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a side question, but we're going very soon on a 2 week holiday in Kemer, is there any real danger for tourists? Not that I don't agree with what you're doing, but I'm traveling with a 3 year old and there's not enough information on this from news media.

It could be extremely dangerous. The sun is very hot in Antalya. You should at least make sure your 3 year old has sun cream and maybe a hat to keep the sun off them. If it gets too hot I would suggest you try a Turkish ice cream called Mado (similar to Italian gelato), or maybe a cool drink. Also be warned that the 3 year old might get a lot of attention and people may give him sweets or soft drinks, particularly ic…

Mado is not an ice cream type, but merely a chain which sells ice cream. They usually do a good job do, you should try the ice cream.

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#59

I'm Turkish. Let me try to shed some light on what's going on. What started as a small protest to prevent the demolishing of a park to build a mall on it turned into full-blown riots after some stunning displays of brutality by the police. The commentators are saying that the Turks had lots of pent-up anger over the years and this allowed them to let it all out. The result is the largest series of riots Turkey has se…

This is a side question, but we're going very soon on a 2 week holiday in Kemer, is there any real danger for tourists? Not that I don't agree with what you're doing, but I'm traveling with a 3 year old and there's not enough information on this from news media.

There would be absolutely no danger -- Kemer is a wonderful touristy spot far far away from any stress/problem/riots. I'm sure you'll have a great time!

Re: Thousands of Istanbul citizens walking to protest government

#60
post #52
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imams acting as guidance counsellors: If there is a demand, I see no problems. No body is forcing people to do that. Edit: Also it would be nice for Imams to give some consultation they are virtually doing nothing. Your second sentence sounds like a stupid rumor. Good citation please. Again, To me whole minister of religion can go away (which was founded by Ataturk). TV: Well blame press for their cowardliness. Threa…

I'll begin by saying I do not believe in a personal god. Well Imams as guidance counsellors are extremely dangerous because unlike Christianity Islam never had the enlightenment period it is still stuck in middle ages. That's why you have people getting stoned in 2013 or girls getting gang raped and then executed for blasphemy search wikipedia for references. This is line of thinking these kids will be guided to and…

Haven't you diverted the subject completely? You basically say you see islam as a big threat so people must be stopped doing anything according to it. I am just not in your way of thinking here and debate has become harder and harder.

About the press, I will tell again. Mass media is a business. Some goes with Government, some goes with opposition. People like to read-watch whatever satisfies their own bias/beliefs. Other newspapers you probably like to read (Vatan, Cumhuriyet etc) is no better than examples you gave. Whining does not change this fact.

Also, C'mon. I see plenty of coverage in all newspapers.

Post reply on HN