Live data from Hacker News

Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

ir.teslamotors.com

31–40 of 51 posts

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#31
post #10

TSLA is up on the news - have a look at the end of today's graph: https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ATSLA&ei=vSGIUe...

As someone who bought several thousand shares at $17/share when it went IPO, its hard not to be excited for TSLA.

Heck, I bought 100 shares when it was at $40 and even I feel incredibly lucky!

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who bought several thousand shares at $17/share when it went IPO, its hard not to be excited for TSLA.

Heck, I bought 100 shares when it was at $40 and even I feel incredibly lucky!

Tesla shares are the only reason this is on the front page here.

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#33
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think he was trying to argue that "good" is subjective. That Ferrari/Porsche aren't necessarily good, as it depends on what you value. If you value simplicity and reliability, perhaps you would view Toyota/Honda as superior.

Actually, Porsche has been #2 in reliability (J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Survey) for two years running (behind Toyota's Lexus brand), #4 in 2011, and was the leader in 2010. However, to be perfectly fair, your average Porsche sees far fewer miles per year than a bread-and-butter mid-size sedan.

They're perfectly usable as daily drivers.

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#34
post #27
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you are being a bit unfair. Gearbox wise, they were on the edge of what they knew, but had to keep up with the competition, and well, pointless fashion. It was an optional extra that customers didn't have to have. That gearbox is not typical of the engineering at AML. Yeah, they should have not released it with out more R&D, but equally, the gearbox is not representative of the whole package. Bodyflex wise, o…

>Electrics. Ahhhh, never a good thing on Astons!! Nonsense, and it's also why this hire makes so much sense. In addition to the engine, underneath the hood is an incredibly powerful electromagnet that's an extraordinary example of their engineering prowess. It's the opposite polarity of the ones installed in each dealership's service garage, which is why they always end up back at their service department.

I had to read that three times, but the payoff was worth it. Thanks.

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#36
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Electrics. Ahhhh, never a good thing on Astons!! Nonsense, and it's also why this hire makes so much sense. In addition to the engine, underneath the hood is an incredibly powerful electromagnet that's an extraordinary example of their engineering prowess. It's the opposite polarity of the ones installed in each dealership's service garage, which is why they always end up back at their service department.

I had to read that three times, but the payoff was worth it. Thanks.

Aston-Martin's developed manufacturable monopoles!?

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#37
post #16
post #3

As someone who's anything but a greasemonkey, how good are Aston Martin from an engineering standpoint compared to the competition?

So here's the thing - they're not actually that good. Let me preface this by saying that a) my perspective isn't a normal consumer one -- my business has put tens of thousands of miles on various Aston Martin models (we rent them) and b) the last model I've dealt with extensively is an '06 DB9, so things may have changed a lot in the past few years. But that being said, despite being IMHO the most gorgeous cars on th…

Please at least slightly pimp your business, it sounds awesome. (Is it Gotham Dream Cars? that's the only place I know of which rents multiple Aston-Martins in the US)

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#38
post #16
post #3

As someone who's anything but a greasemonkey, how good are Aston Martin from an engineering standpoint compared to the competition?

So here's the thing - they're not actually that good. Let me preface this by saying that a) my perspective isn't a normal consumer one -- my business has put tens of thousands of miles on various Aston Martin models (we rent them) and b) the last model I've dealt with extensively is an '06 DB9, so things may have changed a lot in the past few years. But that being said, despite being IMHO the most gorgeous cars on th…

> NOW - that all being said, I'm not going to make any judgment about this guy and his work at Tesla and what this means about that. There is far too much that goes into the production of a car to make any real judgment call about things to come -- Astons could have been beautifully engineered and then ruined with bad supplier decisions, that were outside this guy's control. Etc. etc.

One encouraging thing: with the Roadster, Tesla took a Lotus chassis and made something magnificent out of it with brand new drivetrain technology. They based a car on a Lotus, who hasn't made a reliable car... ever? (they're wonderful cars in their way, but sorry, it's true) From what you're saying, perhaps it's sort of similar to Aston.

If it's an ability to turn sketchy-but-brilliant British design into great cars that's needed, they seem to have it.

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#39
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So here's the thing - they're not actually that good. Let me preface this by saying that a) my perspective isn't a normal consumer one -- my business has put tens of thousands of miles on various Aston Martin models (we rent them) and b) the last model I've dealt with extensively is an '06 DB9, so things may have changed a lot in the past few years. But that being said, despite being IMHO the most gorgeous cars on th…

> NOW - that all being said, I'm not going to make any judgment about this guy and his work at Tesla and what this means about that. There is far too much that goes into the production of a car to make any real judgment call about things to come -- Astons could have been beautifully engineered and then ruined with bad supplier decisions, that were outside this guy's control. Etc. etc. One encouraging thing: with the…

>Lotus, who hasn't made a reliable car... ever?

The US-spec Elise/Exiges were powered by a fairly mundane Toyota engine. Body panel costs aside, it's a cheap, reliable, unpractical, and great vehicle.

Re: Tesla Hires Aston Martin's Vehicle Engineering Leader

#40
post #28
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Were they any fun to drive? After Ford bought Aston, I always assumed the cars would feel like souped-up Tauruses with Connolly leather interiors, but I've never actually sat behind the wheel of an Aston.

Absolutely. Quality issues aside, they're spectacular cars and very emotional experiences. Watch this video and tell me it doesn't get your blood pumping ;) http://www.astonmartin.com/cars/vanquish/video#1

rubish
Post reply on HN