Live data from Hacker News

China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

bloomberg.com

41–50 of 63 posts

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

china is basically doing exactly what the US did to come to economic power and people are shocked, shocked! to see it. people really, truly, honesty believe the last 200 years of US and European ascent didn't happen, as if the world sprang forth fully formed in 1997. the vast majority of people haven't spent 5 minutes really thinking about how this stuff works. a lot of this double-standard is inextricably tied to ra…

Who did the US steal the transistor, cell phone, modern operating system, microprocessor, router and Internet from? Did the US steal all the oil in Titusville (which instigated a massive economic boom) from Britain? How about all the chemistry work and exploration work that the US did to make oil useful and plentiful? Standard Oil had one of the most advanced R&D labs on the planet. I guess all the advanced technolog…

The US is known to have used ECHELON for industrial espionage. This was for aerospace.

While avoiding hyperbole of the parent comment let's not imagine that any country is immune from industrial espionage and industrial corruption. (The UK which has relatively little political corruption has some astounding examples of industrial corruption.)

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#42

I grow weary of reading these "hacking," "cyberspy," etc articles. They always read like a plot of a bad action movie (Hackers, Swordfish, etc) rather than what people who actually work in the sector (IT, Security, even programming) have to deal with day to day. Just once, I'd love to read an article that talks in specifics, like how they got in (e.g. via exploit XYZ), how they spread (e.g. via hole in network policy…

There is virtually no distinction between the government and these private companies where national security is concerned, hence the term "military-industrial complex".

National security is a profit machine.

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#43
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who did the US steal the transistor, cell phone, modern operating system, microprocessor, router and Internet from? Did the US steal all the oil in Titusville (which instigated a massive economic boom) from Britain? How about all the chemistry work and exploration work that the US did to make oil useful and plentiful? Standard Oil had one of the most advanced R&D labs on the planet. I guess all the advanced technolog…

The US is known to have used ECHELON for industrial espionage. This was for aerospace. While avoiding hyperbole of the parent comment let's not imagine that any country is immune from industrial espionage and industrial corruption. (The UK which has relatively little political corruption has some astounding examples of industrial corruption.)

Astounding example #1:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Yamamah_arms_deal

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#44
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who did the US steal the transistor, cell phone, modern operating system, microprocessor, router and Internet from? Did the US steal all the oil in Titusville (which instigated a massive economic boom) from Britain? How about all the chemistry work and exploration work that the US did to make oil useful and plentiful? Standard Oil had one of the most advanced R&D labs on the planet. I guess all the advanced technolog…

The US is known to have used ECHELON for industrial espionage. This was for aerospace. While avoiding hyperbole of the parent comment let's not imagine that any country is immune from industrial espionage and industrial corruption. (The UK which has relatively little political corruption has some astounding examples of industrial corruption.)

I wasn't aware that ECHELON existed in 1850 or 1920 or 1947.

The parent claimed the US primarily stole technology to fuel its way to economic power. The facts do not support that.

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#45
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who did the US steal the transistor, cell phone, modern operating system, microprocessor, router and Internet from? Did the US steal all the oil in Titusville (which instigated a massive economic boom) from Britain? How about all the chemistry work and exploration work that the US did to make oil useful and plentiful? Standard Oil had one of the most advanced R&D labs on the planet. I guess all the advanced technolog…

The US is known to have used ECHELON for industrial espionage. This was for aerospace. While avoiding hyperbole of the parent comment let's not imagine that any country is immune from industrial espionage and industrial corruption. (The UK which has relatively little political corruption has some astounding examples of industrial corruption.)

I believe most of that industrial espionage was done to counter the effect of European companies paying bribes.

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#46
post #11

The only thing as breathtaking as the amount of information the Chinese military has stolen is how dysfunctional their military is. Here [1] is an excellent article about corruption in the Chinese military. The Chinese government is a bizarre mix of authoritarianism, greed, patronage and nationalism, and it has no clear structure. The military is no different. It doesn't matter how much technology they have; as long…

Or you could add this little bookmarklet to clear the lightbox: http://blog.mclemon.cz/hiding-foreign-policys-social-media-p...

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#47

I grow weary of reading these "hacking," "cyberspy," etc articles. They always read like a plot of a bad action movie (Hackers, Swordfish, etc) rather than what people who actually work in the sector (IT, Security, even programming) have to deal with day to day. Just once, I'd love to read an article that talks in specifics, like how they got in (e.g. via exploit XYZ), how they spread (e.g. via hole in network policy…

Seriously, does anyone of you reading this here ever use the word 'cyber'?

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#48

I grow weary of reading these "hacking," "cyberspy," etc articles. They always read like a plot of a bad action movie (Hackers, Swordfish, etc) rather than what people who actually work in the sector (IT, Security, even programming) have to deal with day to day. Just once, I'd love to read an article that talks in specifics, like how they got in (e.g. via exploit XYZ), how they spread (e.g. via hole in network policy…

Check out Mikko Hypponen's company weblog (http://www.f-secure.com/weblog/), they have a lot of posts on different cybersecurity related incidents and go into detail about them. I find it is far more fascinating to read then a lot of the news media coverage.

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#49
post #47

I grow weary of reading these "hacking," "cyberspy," etc articles. They always read like a plot of a bad action movie (Hackers, Swordfish, etc) rather than what people who actually work in the sector (IT, Security, even programming) have to deal with day to day. Just once, I'd love to read an article that talks in specifics, like how they got in (e.g. via exploit XYZ), how they spread (e.g. via hole in network policy…

Seriously, does anyone of you reading this here ever use the word 'cyber'?

I do. Cyberman, Cyberleader, Cyberweapon, Cybermat - all integral components of my lexicon.

Re: China Cyberspies Outwit U.S. Stealing Military Secrets

#50

I grow weary of reading these "hacking," "cyberspy," etc articles. They always read like a plot of a bad action movie (Hackers, Swordfish, etc) rather than what people who actually work in the sector (IT, Security, even programming) have to deal with day to day. Just once, I'd love to read an article that talks in specifics, like how they got in (e.g. via exploit XYZ), how they spread (e.g. via hole in network policy…

They're here to ease the passing of specific US legislation in aid of the military industrial complex. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5642408 I really wish people would stop posting them.

That aspect often escape people. If this was too serious they probably wouldn't be writing articles about it, as that just tells others (say enemies) more information. This is looking like buttering up for a contract or new legislation.
Post reply on HN