Live data from Hacker News

Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

desertant.com

81–90 of 107 posts

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#81
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only reason my chair manufacturer would be entitled to the proceeds of my success whilst I was in their chair is if I hadn't already paid them for the work they put into making the chair for me. Even then, why would my success with their product have anything to do with how much they can charge me for their labour? What other things work like that outside of the modern tech world? Seriously, look around you, pick…

If they charged for the weights up front, then your critique would simply reverse.

What, why?

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#82
post #10

This is a cool way of approaching AI models. I'm a big fan of local LLMs, local specific models like this should be even more powerful. > Every model is free up to 100k monthly active devices. No tokens, no logins. I dunno about the business model though. Cloud LLM billing makes sense: you're getting another computer to do work with each request, and using their compute via their gateway that they bill you. These loc…

> If I'm happy with the weights you've given me, and I'm not using your compute for inference and not wanting or needing any updates off you, why should you continue getting money off me and my customers? Because they own the IP and they get to decide the terms of how it’s licensed. This is like a company taking open source software, saying they like the code the community has given them, and asking why they should c…

> Because they own the IP and they get to decide the terms of how it’s licensed.

Well, the laws that society decide what is legal in terms of buying and selling.

People, somewhat unfortunately, are starting to act as if "licenses" are some kind of natural, pre-existing part of the world.

The fact that they exist at all is because we invented them, and we can easily uninvent them.

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#83
> Ranks a transcript's best non-overlapping moments: each clip gets scored and ranked. Build strong selections or unique editing features to pick the best sentences in video or audio recordings.

This is very impressive for a 248MB model. I wonder how good the results are, as an LLM 10x the size is still quite bad at that.

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#84
post #10

This is a cool way of approaching AI models. I'm a big fan of local LLMs, local specific models like this should be even more powerful. > Every model is free up to 100k monthly active devices. No tokens, no logins. I dunno about the business model though. Cloud LLM billing makes sense: you're getting another computer to do work with each request, and using their compute via their gateway that they bill you. These loc…

> If I'm happy with the weights you've given me, and I'm not using your compute for inference and not wanting or needing any updates off you, why should you continue getting money off me and my customers?

What do you mean by "continue" if you haven't paid anything yet at that point?

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#85
post #10

This is a cool way of approaching AI models. I'm a big fan of local LLMs, local specific models like this should be even more powerful. > Every model is free up to 100k monthly active devices. No tokens, no logins. I dunno about the business model though. Cloud LLM billing makes sense: you're getting another computer to do work with each request, and using their compute via their gateway that they bill you. These loc…

> These local models are like old school software. They're producing the weights, and then giving them to people. If I'm happy with the weights you've given me, and I'm not using your compute for inference and not wanting or needing any updates off you, why should you continue getting money off me and my customers?

You are, presumably, making copies of their software for your customers. So I guess the real question here is, should copyright exist? For software?

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#86
post #56
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If I'm happy with the weights you've given me, and I'm not using your compute for inference and not wanting or needing any updates off you, why should you continue getting money off me and my customers? I definitely understand the appeal of the desire to “buy it once”, but I think there are a few issues: - almost no software is static. Look at a package like python Requests and even though it does the simplest thin…

I think the issues you're describing are all modern internet software issues. I'd guess you're possibly a bit younger than me, or maybe forgotten how software worked before about 2010. - All compiled software is static. New versions are released. I'm happy to pay for new versions/features if I want/need them. But if the version I have is working offline, it doesn't need security updates, and if it does what I need, i…

> - All compiled software is static. New versions are released. I'm happy to pay for new versions/features if I want/need them. But if the version I have is working offline, it doesn't need security updates, and if it does what I need, it doesn't need new features. Same applies if I'm building software for others, if the library does what I need for my software for my customers and I need nothing more off the dev, why should I keep paying the dev?

Who is allowed to make copies of the library?

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#87
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Analogy doesn't apply to this case, as you are paying for the chair upfront but not paying for the model weights upfront.

The only reason my chair manufacturer would be entitled to the proceeds of my success whilst I was in their chair is if I hadn't already paid them for the work they put into making the chair for me. Even then, why would my success with their product have anything to do with how much they can charge me for their labour? What other things work like that outside of the modern tech world? Seriously, look around you, pick…

> look around you, pick a thing, imagine a world where the price you paid for that thing hinged on your personal individual success with that thing

YCombinator. Unreal Engine. CryEngine. FMOD. Steam, App stores in general. Qt.

+ 90% of enterprise software that charges per seat / user.

You could argue that most of these provide ongoing services, but that will also be the case if you license one of their models commercially, contracts come with strings attached both ways.

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#88
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Analogy doesn't apply to this case, as you are paying for the chair upfront but not paying for the model weights upfront.

The only reason my chair manufacturer would be entitled to the proceeds of my success whilst I was in their chair is if I hadn't already paid them for the work they put into making the chair for me. Even then, why would my success with their product have anything to do with how much they can charge me for their labour? What other things work like that outside of the modern tech world? Seriously, look around you, pick…

[deleted]

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#89
post #61
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I buy I chair I don't pay a share of my income to the furniture shop when I get rich. I would buy another chair at some point too, maybe fancier one (or the same). Because chairs are commodity. I do however pay taxes to the government based on my income because it keeps doing ongoing maintenance on everything . Everyone wants to be paid forever for something they produced once is some kind of a mind virus. Make…

> When I buy I chair You should, sitting on that chair got you in the zone where you made it rich. /s

Right, right. Maybe correct posture gave me exact edge over the competition I would have missed otherwise.

Re: Desert Ant Labs: local, fast models that run on device

#90
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OCR on steroids. Our Schemer model will soon be available (free form text to structured JSON). Once that lands, we want to jump into image to JSON.

But Schemer will be text-only, correct? Once image support drops this could be a cool addition to https://struktur.sh . Will it be on OpenRouter too or will all inference have to be self-managed? I’m thinking about server-side use cases, where budgets are low, so small models shine. edit: ah I saw mainly iOS for now. But an integration would be possible on macOS then, right?

Schemer is text only. But we're working on sort like models for images to data too.

We aim to make all our models available cross-platform. There's a subset currently only iOS/macOS, because they take some more effort to port over to Android and web.

Check out the CLI for easy experimentation: https://github.com/Desert-Ant-Labs/desert-ant-cli#desert-ant...

Post reply on HN