Live data from Hacker News

All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

valleynewslive.com

71–80 of 278 posts

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#72
post #6

What alerts are they getting so often anyway? It's a little town of 25k people. I can understand the benefit of being able to track coming and going and criminal activity etc but there is no oversight and it is already being abused. Keeping this data within the municipality and requiring bureaucracy to coordinate with others might be the best solution I've heard, since it prevents dragnets and builds in auditing as p…

Small towns don't want people spying on them. Small towns also are prime targets for pushing over with your federal approvals to force them into giving you their tax money in the name of "safety". Someone got paid.

[flagged]

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#74
post #23

Curious about the official YCombinator stance on this extremely unpopular YCombinator-backed startup (unpopular here at HN anyway).

If you've read anything Garry Tan has said, you wouldn't be curious.

Care to enlighten us?

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#76

Coincidentally, ran into a YouTube short testing how to cut down steel poles quickly yesterday, with battery powered tools. Sawzall, 1m 15s, circular saw 1m, circular saw like 20s. https://youtube.com/shorts/aAc3Kq0bFPs Yet to see anyone describe what to do once they are down. They for sure have all manners of wicked battery backed up trackers etc, I'm sure. (This would be highly illegal to do and you should not do i…

not exactly right. the first is an abrasive disc. that's the right guy for steel, but doesn't work great in aluminum because its very sticky and melty. the third is a metal skill saw blade. I really wouldn't use this with steel at all, but you definitely want to cut aluminum and not grind it. the tool I would normally use for this is a portable bandsaw, with speed control that you would set high for Al and low for steel, probably pretty close to the skill saw.

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#77

it is bad to see theft of physical property as a good thing

It wasn't private property. It belonged to the people and the people decided they didn't want it. It's bad to see people being forced to break the law to retain their freedom, but it's a good thing that folks are still willing to fight for it.

Good point. It's public money that funded it. Just like drug research. We should be demanding ownership over the fruits of our tax dollars

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#79

So one of the public-private backdoors to erode citizen's rights is being undermined. Such a shame.

[flagged]

It's a network of nation wide cameras tracking movement, which can include foot traffic from people's phones. You're giving police and a private company a lot of power with that sort of data. There was a case of a sheriff in Texas town using a nation wide search to find a woman who had an abortion using Flock cameras after claiming it was used for a missing person case.

This because Texas has a hard on for trying to prosecute women who have abortions.

Re: All of Winona Police Department's Flock cameras cut down and stolen

#80
post #3

> Each camera is valued at approximately $3,000, putting the total loss at roughly $24,000. That cost falls directly on the Winona Police Department’s budget. Only if they replace them...

If you own a $20,000 car and I steal it, is your loss not $20k? (excluding depreciation etc)

Sure, if we're talking about total "wealth". Towns might put the cameras on their balance sheet (unless they're just leased in some way), but I strongly doubt that any towns are selling their flock cameras.

Moreover, the quote was about budget - it only hits the budget if they replace them. Likewise, if someone steals your car, it only hits your budget if you replace it or otherwise incur other expenses (taxi, etc). If you shrug because you have 4 other cars, or just walk and bike most of the time, its not really hitting your budget.

Post reply on HN