Live data from Hacker News

AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

nelson.cloud

291–300 of 493 posts

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#291

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The most important thing to keep in mind, when considering AI images for helping to illustrate or explain the actual content, is that AI-generated images have a big trust problem. Take a look at the Google Image Search results for 'Engine Diagram' https://www.google.com/search?q=Engine+Diagram&tbm=isch In the first row I get two correct-looking diagrams, then a load of AI-generated ones. Three cylinder heads for four…

To be fair, the problems you describe existed before AI, though I concede it has gotten worse. What baffles me is why anyone would think it a good idea to post and host these images? What’s that upside?

> the problems you describe existed before AI

No, the problem of mass-produced, outright wrong, educational graphics flooding image-search results did not exist before 2023.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#292

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The most important thing to keep in mind, when considering AI images for helping to illustrate or explain the actual content, is that AI-generated images have a big trust problem. Take a look at the Google Image Search results for 'Engine Diagram' https://www.google.com/search?q=Engine+Diagram&tbm=isch In the first row I get two correct-looking diagrams, then a load of AI-generated ones. Three cylinder heads for four…

Diagram-wise I had better luck in telling it to make a text version for diagram generator, not only AI edits tend to be more correct, it's easier to fix any errors too. As a bonus you can then prompt AI to validate whether the diagram matches article and vice versa, I've caught some small bugs like that when we migrated our docs

> you can then prompt AI to validate whether the diagram matches article and vice versa

No repro with Nano Banana with an infographic prompt.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#293

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you use the definition of "creative" in that someone creates, sure, you can make your argument. Most people, however, include a level of imagination and effort in their qualifications of whether something is creative. An AI prompt does not meet the bar of "creativity" for most people. Curating AI slop similarly does not meet this bar. Your personal bar may well be on the floor, but that is not representative of mo…

Yeah I just don't think there is anything special about "art" and I don't think there is some specific definition for what art is. People create that's art. You can put different amounts of time and effort into it but I think it's just as lacking in imagination or respect for human creativity to distill this down to he worst case. If somebody spends hours prompting various resources and curating it, is that then "slo…

To summarize, this is a "you" problem. Just because YOU do not think there's anything special about art, it does not mean there isn't. Your lack of respect for art does not undermine the thing itself. You cannot have your GenAI products included with "art" simply because you want to. You aren't entitled to having your prompt outputs held in the same esteem.

> If somebody spends hours prompting various resources and curating it, is that then "slop"?

In my opinion, yes. Some people may disagree with the term "slop" in this case, but that does not step it all the way up to "art". It can still be non-slop, non-art.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#294
I write a blog and have always avoided AI images for exactly the reasons cited here. AI images feel like a more cynical version of stock imagery, for some reason. I think it's actually too bad because in a lot of cases AI images would actually be really great to include and a lot more evocative... but there's just no way to do it that doesn't inspire revulsion.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#295
post #211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you don't care about the images then don't have images.

Or just have a podcast so that you don't have the option to have images.

It bothers my brain when a longtime followed podcast changes their cover image. You conditioned my brain for years to a certain image and pattern and now you change it? How dare you!

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#297

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one ever said they didn't want images, this is a non-sequiturs

> Some people have decided to offload image-creation to machines because what they care about is the text.

Thank you for providing the text that reaffirms my statement. If you have the time to copy and past someone else's text, you should take the time to actually read it

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#300
Fair enough. I dislike word-expansion AI text so I get it. When I write on my blog, part of it is as memory like a diary for myself and I find that I can create these images that help remember the scene well. As much as I'd like people to read my blog, I get that they have preferences, and if many decide against then that's their prerogative.

Here are two examples with AI images from Nano Banana:

https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-04-20/Drops_of_Wat...

https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-07-23/Sixtless_in_...

I think I'll probably keep doing what I'm doing there.

Post reply on HN