Live data from Hacker News

Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

rtx.com

71–80 of 104 posts

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_air_turbine

Would imagine these are significantly more useful on heavier and faster aircraft - surely the weight and whatnot to retract move them is less worth it for smaller planes ?

They are commonly used on small single-engine fighter jets as well. They typically cannot be retracted once deployed, and free-fall using their own mass, so there is no actuation system weight to account for.

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hybrid cars are mostly parallel hybrids. Only the Chevy Volt comes to mind as a serial hybrid.

Chevy Volt was still a parallel hybrid. The gasoline engine was used for driving the wheels for highway cruise because it was more efficient. I think the range extender version of the BMW i3 was a pure serial hybrid though

Honda's recent hybrids (CR-V, Civic, Accord) are like this too. Mostly series, but the engine can directly drive the wheels via a single overdrive gear for better cruising efficiency.

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#75
post #4

I think there are startups making a similar sort of engine for general aviation. It's good to see that there is development of the same idea for commercial aviation. This isn't like a hybrid car. It's a parallel hybrid, where the gas engine is just big enough for efficient cruise at altitude, and the electric motor/generator provides extra power for takeoff and ascent (or go-around power), and then charges slowly dur…

>This isn't like a hybrid car. It's a parallel hybrid, where the gas engine is just big enough for efficient cruise at altitude, and the electric motor/generator provides extra power for takeoff and ascent (or go-around power), and then charges slowly during cruise if needed. Isn't that exactly what hybrid cars (e.g. Prius) are? Extremely efficient gas engine for highway cruising, but insufficient for acceleration, w…

IDK if anyone really answered -this- question properly, so I will.

> Isn't that exactly what hybrid cars (e.g. Prius) are? Extremely efficient gas engine for highway cruising, but insufficient for acceleration, which is aided by electric motors?

Well, it kinda depends. Where Hybrids get the biggest MPG boost is in city driving. The stop and go traffic lets you use Regen braking and go quite some time without the engine kicking back on while still moving forward.

I still don't understand Honda's system enough to speak well on it, but I can speak to THS because it seems to be the cheapest to do and is most proven on the road.

The general parameters for a THS type system on a Toyota Prius or Rav4, or a Ford Maverick/Fusion/Escape is a 2.0L or 2.5L (at least in modern US examples) engine paired to a simple planetary gearset containing a power split device. It is a single speed (At least in the cheap configurations, however that simplicity is possibly close enough to be viable for air usage vs a reduction gear.) That's part of why they tend to have fairly large engines, the valve timing magic gives them at least a bit more HP to not be too bad on the highway.

> but insufficient for acceleration

Going back to the modern cases, the engine is typically sized large enough to give some acceleration even on the highway. Not always great but usually enough.

At least as far as the non-plug-in hybrids, the 0-35MPH can be surprisingly peppy.

The bigger magic (again, at least as far as THS) is it makes it easy to just run the engine at the 'most optimal RPM' for certain tasks, excess energy gets piped to the battery or back out through the system, this does also help reliability tho, because you can then design the reliability of the engine around certain RPM ranges...

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#76

1300 HP electric engine power, now that's an achievement. I do wonder if prop engines can act as "windmills" (similar to turbine engines, which often in accidents still have been found to provide a bit of hydraulic power), which means regenerative braking could be used instead of speedbrakes.

There are times where the intent is to rapidly shed energy and systems/procedures designed for that (spoilers, speed breaks, slipping the aircraft). I suspect though that implementing any kind of efficient regenerative capability during these times will be something that is developed later/as an afterthought initially. That being said dismissing the idea out of hand is probably wrong. If this system is used during takeoff and climb and would be needed for landing/go around then I imagine they would want minimum energy levels in the batteries so there is probably going to be some system to tap the generator to give them an ability to have minimum energy for landing. Why tap the generator if you can scavenge along the way or just build in robbing power from the prop as the connection to get that power. This system probably naturally beefs up the generator substantially on these aircraft to give them essentially this exact capability. Hmmm.. as I type, the more I think it may happen very quickly honestly. But I'm not an aerospace engineer so this is all a guess!

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#77
post #41

This is very clever: instead of focusing on electric only flight, just make the existing engine fly in the most efficient window while the electric engine buffers the flight profile. Like a big-boy prius.

I kind of wonder how the orders of magnitude work out for solar and wing area.

Solar cells are actually quite thin and could be almost like paint on the wings of aircraft. I wonder if the energy generated vs required is even ballpark. There is plenty of sun at 30,000 feet during the day.

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#78
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No it’s not. The majority of power comes from the engine. It drives the electric motor mechanically, using it as a transmission. It is not just charging the battery.

Sorry, I meant in the low speed, high acceleration regime (maybe easily confounded with takeoff?). There the engine will turn one motor to generate electricity, which will then power the second motor, like a series hybrid.

No, that's just wrong: at no point is (say) a Toyota Hybrid burning gas to generate electricity to immediately turn another motor that actually moves the wheels.

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#79
post #77
post #41

This is very clever: instead of focusing on electric only flight, just make the existing engine fly in the most efficient window while the electric engine buffers the flight profile. Like a big-boy prius.

I kind of wonder how the orders of magnitude work out for solar and wing area. Solar cells are actually quite thin and could be almost like paint on the wings of aircraft. I wonder if the energy generated vs required is even ballpark. There is plenty of sun at 30,000 feet during the day.

Man this is a middle-schooler level napkin math question.

Take a Boeing 777, it has a wingspan of about 60 meters, and I'll ballpark an average upper wing chord of about 7 meters, for a total upper flat area of about 420 square meters.

High quality modern but standard single sided solar panels can do about 220 watts per square meter is full sunlight (around 22% efficiency tested at a 1000w/m^2 irradiance).

So that is 92,400 watts at full power.

92kW is less than the peak power of a Nissan Leaf. 92kW is 123 horsepower.

The two GE turbofans of a 777 are generating something like 40-50 MW of shaft power during cruise. MW.... megawatts. 50-60,000 horsepower.

Plastering the wing surface of a commercial plane with solar panels would make up less than a quarter of a percent of the total power it uses to produce thrust at cruise, at best case with them fully-lit.

Fully solar sailplanes do exist (NASA's Helios prototypes are an example) but that isn't anything close to a 'normal' aircraft with any appreciable payload/passengers.

So, no need to wonder.

Re: Hybrid-Electric Aicraft Engine Targeting 30% Fuel Efficiency

#80
post #77
post #41

This is very clever: instead of focusing on electric only flight, just make the existing engine fly in the most efficient window while the electric engine buffers the flight profile. Like a big-boy prius.

I kind of wonder how the orders of magnitude work out for solar and wing area. Solar cells are actually quite thin and could be almost like paint on the wings of aircraft. I wonder if the energy generated vs required is even ballpark. There is plenty of sun at 30,000 feet during the day.

Aptera for airplanes would be cool. I doubt you could generate enough power in-flight, but maybe after sitting outside for a few days
Post reply on HN