Live data from Hacker News

I Stopped “Creating Content”

refactoringenglish.com

81–90 of 249 posts

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are all kinds of people out there generating meaningful content on their own terms that will never get picked up by the algorithm. I hate the content mills as much as anyone else, but the fact is that they exist because internet economy rewards them. The entire ecosystem incentivizes the soulless "goo" you describe over the meaningful work people are doing. Ice T said it best: "Don't hate the player, hate the g…

You don't need to do that as an activity. You can earn money doing something more useful.

Entertaining people is useful! In my opinion, it is probably one of the most ethical ways to make money. I think game development is in that category too. It is a very pure field where you are giving a consumer something they enjoy and seek out.

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#84
When I hear people use the generic word "content" it grinds my gears. It lacks any sort of deep meaning, and feels insulting when applied to genuine work that real humans poured their sweat, time, energy and passion into creating and perfecting.

There's slop, and there's masterpiece. In which would you rather invest your time? (Either creating or 'consuming'?)

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#85
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Truly curious - why did you choose to work at a content farm?

Money Why would you work for Insurance, Defense, military, Amazon, killing kittens R Us. Money.

Defense and Military you can want to work there for such nebulous ideas such as serving your nation, protecting your loved ones, security, etc. This would require you to actually believe in said abstract concepts like nationalism, community, family, culture, or truth, so that you actually want to defend your homeland though. This is easier to believe for me than the innumerable start ups that were making the world a better place via ad placement click through rates.

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#86
post #8
post #4

I feel that all the terms mentioned are useful in specific contexts. Web traffic brings visitors to your resource. If they read your blog, they become readers. If they use your products, they become users. When someone buys something from you, they become a customer.

OP here. Thanks for reading! > I feel that all the terms mentioned are useful in specific contexts. Web traffic brings visitors to your resource. If they read your blog, they become readers. If they use your products, they become users. When someone buys something from you, they become a customer. I'll respectfully disagree. I think those terms make sense if you're talking in general terms, but if you're an individua…

Even more concrete, IMHO: "People find my comics through Google search. Some of them become fans and subscribe."

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#87

after discovering most of my content has been scraped thousands of times, I don't have any willingness to continue posting my blog. Well, yes, I was expecting that (you know.. by publishing content on the net, everyone could read it -- and profit off!). I've some content for some months, including some analysis. I wish somebody could motivate me to publish them anyway.

Would you feel the same way about creating open source software that had been forked 1,000's of times and used without your knowledge? Are you interested in living in a world where everyone only does things if they feel they can directly capture the majority of the value created?

There's a whole world of software that people are expected to pay for, one way or another. Some programmers choose to release their work for free. And some people use the paid software without paying. We call those people "pirates".

Are you interested in living in a world where nobody can make a living off of their creative work?

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#88

You “create content” if what you’re after is just money, and “content” is this malleable goo you have to produce and shove it down the algorithm so that it gets “traffic”, another form of goo that gets “funneled” and “converted” into money. In other words, it loses all (human) meaning. So yes, if you care at all, you shouldn’t “create content”. You should be writing essays, recording tutorials, training, music, conve…

I agree with everything except the last sentence. Humans are not rational agents, doubly so when it comes to money and spending. There are many communities where charging even a nominal fee for your work leads to backlash due to built up expectations of free contribution.

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#89

When I hear people use the generic word "content" it grinds my gears. It lacks any sort of deep meaning, and feels insulting when applied to genuine work that real humans poured their sweat, time, energy and passion into creating and perfecting. There's slop, and there's masterpiece. In which would you rather invest your time? (Either creating or 'consuming'?)

It's one level of abstraction below "enrichment"

Re: I Stopped “Creating Content”

#90

I think it helps to draw a clear boundary between what is "content" and what is "art", since they ultimately serve different purposes and have vastly different factors that go into their creation. To me, "content" is anything created with the goal of maximizing consumption, whereas "art" is an attempt to express or give form to some kind of idea or emotion. The lines blur when you get to things like film, where those…

What about really good information? Instructions? Guides?
Post reply on HN