Live data from Hacker News

Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

ft.com

91–100 of 414 posts

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#91
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would be very strange for Apple’s legal department to send out formal letters filled with claims on a lark.

Not really, just slowing down a potential competitor could still be worth it.

I don't think they would consider OpenAI a potential competitor, unless OpenAI has trade secrets of Apple.

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people think that being the exclusive supplier of iOS based devices is a “monopoly”.

McDonald's is the exclusive supplier of Big Macs and McNuggets. They're a monopoly.

One sells Big Macs... the other Mac minis... there must be a connection.

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#94
post #20
post #12

Predictions on who wins? Does Apple actually have a winnable case or are they just throwing a wrench in things?

Oh the irony if Apple can get a larger OpenAI stake than Microsoft.

I don’t think Cupertino will settle for stock. I think they’ll demand cash and an agreement that OpenAI abandon or reboot their hardware project. In the meantime, Apple gets an open kimono into everything OpenAI has planned.

This could actually be the fuckup that kills OpenAI as an independent company. The threat of a cash judgement gums up not only an IPO, but also debt-based fundraising. (We equity guys are idiots, so we’ll probably keep writing cheques until the market turns.)

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The accusations are incredibly clear/defined (and serious!) and have a very simple burden of proof. These things either happened or they didn’t, and they have material evidence or they don’t. It’s incredibly unlikely that they filed such big, concrete accusations without concrete proof to back them up. And while I am far from an Apple fan boy, yes a lot of big corporations file frivolous lawsuits but Apple typically…

They also have a new CEO at the helm.

Effective Sept 1

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#96
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ha ha. Worked at Apple for over two decades—would not have stayed at a company I thought was evil for that long. A bully at times? I wouldn't argue with that.

What about the kids they intentionally get driven to suicide by keeping the blue bubbles for no other reason than child indoctrination due to bullying from other kids.

These are quite heavy accusations. Do you have a source for your claim that this was the intention?

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#97
post #44

Apple must have hard evidence on this. I can’t believe they would take it this far without already knowing they are going to win. If they have to fire a huge chunk of their hardware employees it’s going to throw their IPO plans into chaos.

This is John Ternus having a beef with Tang Tan. It’s widely known they both competed for the role of CEO. Tim Cook would never have started this. It shows a level of pettiness and arrogance which I never expected to see from Apple. I can’t put myself in the mind of John, but he clearly hated Tang. From outside and with a parent’s perspective this looks like my kids throwing a tantrum. John must be thinking he is the…

The alleged crime sounded childish. Appeal to rule of law, enforced by the court system is necessary for a fair business enviornment.

Sending the notification letters is probably petty though.

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#98

FT frames this as some aggressive escalation tactic, but document retention letters are extremely standard practice. At this point they're basically a formality, as any former Apple employee at OpenAI really ought to know by now that they could get dragged into this. Hold letters can be aggressive if you send them before you've even filed a complaint, but if anything, Apple is late to the party with these.

Something similar happened to me when I left Microsoft for Apple (I moved from the Visual Studio team to the Xcode team). MS spent six months trying to prove I'd taken "industry secrets" with me. I hadn't. The entire thing felt like a personal attack and was extremely stressful.

It sounds like, in this case, Apple has hard proof that documents were stolen.

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people think that being the exclusive supplier of iOS based devices is a “monopoly”.

McDonald's is the exclusive supplier of Big Macs and McNuggets. They're a monopoly.

And they’re the exclusive fast food partner of Monopoly… so they have a Monopoly monopoly?

Re: Apple targets dozens of OpenAI employees with legal letters

#100
Everybody wants a platform but nobody wants to spend what it takes to make a platform. That includes things like Windows Phone, Fire Phone, all the glasses, Humane, etc.

As much as everybody hates on OpenAI for chaotic management, they did buy Jony Ive and are presumably giving him everything he wants to build a platform for them. Even though it probably only buys them a 20% chance of success, they haven't doomed the project by underestimating what it takes budget-wise.

And they blew it. Maybe they blew it by not realizing that even long time Apple employees could get arrogant about security. Or maybe it was a loose ethical environment in general. Whatever is it the root or the problem, they set billions of dollars on fire maybe tens of billions, by being unnecessarily cute about Apple proprietary information when they could've been above reproach. They had the resources to hire all the right people with the right knowledge and probably already had them on board.

Post reply on HN