Live data from Hacker News

An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

anderegg.ca

111–120 of 139 posts

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Adobe and everyone else. Many of those complaints resonated with me outside of Photoshop But as I've said in the past, I think there is a relationship between subscriptions and quality: with a subscription model, feedback signals become decoupled. In the past, if the new version isn't good enough, people won't buy it. Now the calculus is changed to whether the product has become bad enough to un subscribe Potentially…

That’s why I love the Nova.app model. You pay for a year of releases, but if you unsubscribe you keep the latest version when your subscription was active. It’s the best/worst of both worlds!

Same with most (all?) JetBrains products, and for the first 3 years every year gets cheaper!

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#112
post #7

Affinity, mentioned in the article, was acquired by Canva and had its entire UI redone to work just like Photoshop. It's also entirely free with no gotchas.

> It's also entirely free with no gotchas. I'm running Affinity Studio on my Mac. Every time I run it, Little Snitch shows that it is transferring data to many servers, such as serifservices.com, canva.com, onetrust.com, amazonaws.com, sentry.io, .. I've tried to set privacy preferences to maximum, but it hasn't helped. Am I the product? The old Affinity Designer 1 doesn't send any data to servers, so I'm still using…

Does it still work when you block all outgoing connections?

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#113
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know what's worse: that they did that, or that the operating system allowed them to do that. On both macOS and Windows according to my understanding that should require admin rights, normally, not to mention the degree to which Apple made macOS immutable (I'm not familiar with the details, to be honest).

It does require admin rights on Win and will pop up the little admin confirmation message on each edit. I'm dubious of the claim that it was written to unnoticed. I use PS daily and I know it hasn't modified my hosts file, because I have, often, and would have noticed (that, and the obvious admin confirmation dialog).

OP is using Apple so maybe that's why? I use PS weekly and I've never seen it (or anything else) touch my hosts file on Windows. I just verified - nothing beyond my own entries.

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#114
post #108

>I’ve been using Photoshop since the mid-90s. First at school, with Photoshop 3, then through work. I bought my first boxed copy of CS2 in 2005, then upgraded to CS5 in 2010. I subscribed to Photoshop Creative Cloud on day one..... >It turned out that my subscription, which had been going since 2013, I am reading this and I am thinking god I am old. I thought the Creative Cloud was a fairly recent thing. May be 2018?…

>> It turned out that my subscription, which had been going since 2013,

> I am reading this and I am thinking god I am old.

Don't worry, while 13 years seems long enough to make you feel old, you're not old. You'll know you're old when 13 years ago seems recent.

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#115
post #27

> It turned out that my subscription, which had been going since 2013, was on an “Annual Paid Monthly” plan. Even though I was getting billed monthly, I couldn’t actually cancel any time I wanted. I've been wondering for a while what happens if you just block the transactions on your credit card. (Can't test it myself because I'm not an adobe customer and never will be)

They'll send you to collections, probably.

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#116
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I read on Twitter this week that someone made such an interface on top of GIMP. https://github.com/Diolinux/Photogimp

Yeah, there have been similar things before it as well. I was thinking more of a ground up photoshop style editor with GEGL as the backend

Never did understand why gimp's ui isn't a Photoshop clone, or more broadly, why there isn't one canonical Photoshop clone like libreoffice is to Ms office.

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#117
post #23

There have been some good alternatives mentioned in the comments here, like Affinity or Photopea. Does anyone happen to know if there is a similarly good alternative to Lightroom?

Darktable ( https://www.darktable.org/ ) has become very good and continues to be my go-to solution for digital photography.

The delete button is labelled "delete (trash)"

Never change, FOSS UIs

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#118
post #45

A tangent, but for full clean removals of apps in MacOS (because I'm old-school and despite having plenty of GBs of storage, I hate the idea of dregs lying around) I've had success with AppCleaner[0] and Pearcleaner[1]. Pearcleaner is multi-functional; AppCleaner just sits in the background looking for app bundles to appear in the recycle bin. [0] https://appcleaner.macupdate.com/ [1] https://github.com/alienator88/P…

Hazel, the folder watch automation tool, also supports this

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

World would be in a better place if GIMP hadn't ever existed, the existence of GIMP is part of why we don't have an actual viable alternative. Constant claims of "good enough", 20+ years to implement adjustment layers after dismissing their value for many years a team that doesn't really care at all about it. If GIMP had never existed maybe the Blender team or someone else who actually has passion for the problem wou…

> World would be in a better place if GIMP hadn't ever existed, the existence of GIMP is part of why we don't have an actual viable alternative. Wow, that's a wild statement. I think you might be right. Though GIMP was responsible for GTK, which is now a critical part of most linux systems. I wonder where we'd be if not for GTK? Qt everywhere maybe?

> Qt everywhere maybe?

As someone who picked the KDE side decades ago, I have to say that would be for the best.

Re: An Infuriating Goodbye to Photoshop

#120
post #27

> It turned out that my subscription, which had been going since 2013, was on an “Annual Paid Monthly” plan. Even though I was getting billed monthly, I couldn’t actually cancel any time I wanted. I've been wondering for a while what happens if you just block the transactions on your credit card. (Can't test it myself because I'm not an adobe customer and never will be)

They'll send you to collections, probably.

Oh, duh, of course. One of those "how did I not think of that" moments
Post reply on HN