Live data from Hacker News

Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

reuters.com

521–530 of 661 posts

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#521

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yea he only runs one of the biggest technology companies in the world.

what does "runs" actually mean? zoom calls from his private Hawai island to a bunch of buddies other C-level execs?

It means he has a controlling share over the money and all the power.

This thread is bizarre.

He can run the day to day string pulling however he wants, he is literally the one with all the power.

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#522

Who cares what Zuckerberg says about AI agents? He is a PHP developer from the early '00s who got lucky with Facebook. He's not an AI scientist or an AI researcher. What authority does he have to speak on the future of AI agents? Morale at his company is at an ATL, and that says more about his leadership skills he'd better off focusing on, otherwise the agents might replace him soon.

Be honest, in the counterfactual where he had said that "AI" agents are the next industrial revolution and there is no future for human skills and so on -- would you have still valued his opinion as being effectively worthless?

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#523

Who cares what Zuckerberg says about AI agents? He is a PHP developer from the early '00s who got lucky with Facebook. He's not an AI scientist or an AI researcher. What authority does he have to speak on the future of AI agents? Morale at his company is at an ATL, and that says more about his leadership skills he'd better off focusing on, otherwise the agents might replace him soon.

The most correct opinion No disrespect to anyone that worked or works at meta: We can build a better version of his whole platform in 30 mins.

at that scale? They serve an awful lot of requests, so I don't think 30m will cover it.

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#524

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do I write all my code with an agent now? Yes. Can you just give an agent a desired outcome and let it work, unsupervised? Absolutely not. I strongly suspect that developers moving from writing code to managing agents to write code for them is very similar to developers moving into leadership and management roles and managing ICs to write code for them. Some devs just 'get it' and thrive, leading a team really well a…

Absurd. We are beset on all sides with companies declaring agentic coding a failure and here you are stating as a matter of fact some teams “thrive” with this probabilistic expensive approach to approximating working code? All the while concluding with “I have no evidence for any of this”.

are we tho? i don't really see anyone going back to planning and coding by hand, that ship has sailed and it's not coming back. people ditching agentic workflows altogether would be failure, people figuring out it's not a miracle tool and has uses for which it's not as productive is correction.

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#525

Who cares what Zuckerberg says about AI agents? He is a PHP developer from the early '00s who got lucky with Facebook. He's not an AI scientist or an AI researcher. What authority does he have to speak on the future of AI agents? Morale at his company is at an ATL, and that says more about his leadership skills he'd better off focusing on, otherwise the agents might replace him soon.

He's incredibly rich. Americans greatly respect rich people, the richer the more respect. It's apparently a bizarre reinterpretation/misunderstanding of Calvinism.

The respect only goes as far as to listen to what they have to say. We navigate our experience based on the whims of the rich so it helps to know what they are thinking, but it certainly doesn't confer much respect. Most are completely out of touch.

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#526

Who cares what Zuckerberg says about AI agents? He is a PHP developer from the early '00s who got lucky with Facebook. He's not an AI scientist or an AI researcher. What authority does he have to speak on the future of AI agents? Morale at his company is at an ATL, and that says more about his leadership skills he'd better off focusing on, otherwise the agents might replace him soon.

This comment reads so angry only because the OP doesn’t like what they read

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#527
post #321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agentic coding is absolutely not a failure. It's just not the 10x that CEOs really wanted it to be. We learned that some tasks don't really benefit from AI while others do. My team went from 7 people to 2 (went to new teams, no layoffs), and we're doing the same amount if not more work than we used to. Is it more draining and lacking of focused work? Yes. Is it more money for the business? Yes.

Being a "failure" means it fails to meet its success criteria. If you claim 10x and deliver 3x, that is a failure. The 3x may still be impressive or a gamechanger or ..., but it still falls short of its promises.

10x is a marketing gimmick in development, AI and pretty much everywhere

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#529

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't like Zuckerberg whatsoever, but there are plenty of reasons you could potentially care about his opinion: - He could be well-placed to see whether AI agent development is successful since at a high level he oversees much of it, and will be getting detailed metrics and things. - Whether or not his opinion is correct, tech CEOs are notorious trend-chasers, and his opinion could set the tone for other companies.…

Honest question, is there a single successful large investment made by Meta recently ? I just know about the abject failures :)

Maybe the glasses. After other companies have failed, they may have something here.

Re: Zuckerberg says AI agent development going slower than expected

#530

Who cares what Zuckerberg says about AI agents? He is a PHP developer from the early '00s who got lucky with Facebook. He's not an AI scientist or an AI researcher. What authority does he have to speak on the future of AI agents? Morale at his company is at an ATL, and that says more about his leadership skills he'd better off focusing on, otherwise the agents might replace him soon.

He leads a Trillion dollar company that employs a lot of AI scientists and researchers.
Post reply on HN