Live data from Hacker News

One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

iamnotaprogrammer.com

51–60 of 87 posts

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#51
post #45

I love the Gmail iPhone app. In particular, I love that it lets me change the "from" address, similarly to how the gmail.com site lets me do that. Neither Mail.app nor Sparrow made it easy to change the from. I have a few different email addresses that all get forwarded to my gmail account. Finally my mobile mail problem -- being able to select my from -- is solved. If anyone from Google is reading this, thank you!

In Mail.app on iOS you just have to tap the 'From' address and choose a different one. What am I missing?

Not exactly.

To send from a different 'From' in Mail.app, first you need to connect your iPhone to additional email accounts (Settings->Mail). Then these addresses will show up in your 'From' drop down.

But then you end up with multiple inboxes in your Mail.app. Which is messy, fills up storage, and hurts my brain -- since I never need to check my other inboxes (because all my email addresses forward to the same Gmail account).

With the Gmail iPhone app, I just need to prove once (in gmail.com) that I have access to whatever 'From' addresss I want. Then I can select them in the Gmail app.

Note: I admit that the viewport issues discussed in the blog post are indeed an annoyance that I hope Google fixes soon. But I prefer Gmail app to Mail.app nonetheless.

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#53
post #52

Gmail app, both iOS and Android is full of fail. Too much "clean design" - aka, flat featureless grey on white boxes with icons that mean very little. I hate this new 'minimal' design craze.

Google Apps on my Android always were always one of the worst.

Google Maps - resource hungry, always doing something in the background, slow .. replaced them with much better, unfortunately local, alternative

Google Play - two examples: doesn't prevent phone from losing network so I have to play with the phone in order to download updates; listing my applications always takes about half a minute.. even if I did the same task 5 seconds ago

Google+ - basically unusable, unbearably slow, doing stuff in background all the time, crashed whole system few times

The truth is I don't have the most modern phone, but it isn't the slowest either (it's single core 900MHz w/ 512MB ram). It's running on the latest available android for that device (the device was sold less then a year ago, it's from 2010). Can't imagine how those apps run on older/slower phones.

Side note: Another multi-billion dollar company that can't seem to produce working android application is facebook. That is the single worst application that I have ever used (some were worse (google+), but I can't really talk about "usage" with them). It's getting slowly better, but it's still a crap. Twitter on the other hand is great.

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#54
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i don't know about that. i often get html-emails from companies which don't fit the screen. sometimes i can align it by adjusting to the left... shouldn't have to.

The new Gmail update included Pinch-to-Zoom. Check it out in the Settings. Works perfectly, solves this problem quite nicely.

Tip: after zooming in, double-tap the text to reflow it.

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#55
post #53
post #52

Gmail app, both iOS and Android is full of fail. Too much "clean design" - aka, flat featureless grey on white boxes with icons that mean very little. I hate this new 'minimal' design craze.

Google Apps on my Android always were always one of the worst. Google Maps - resource hungry, always doing something in the background, slow .. replaced them with much better, unfortunately local, alternative Google Play - two examples: doesn't prevent phone from losing network so I have to play with the phone in order to download updates; listing my applications always takes about half a minute.. even if I did the s…

Agreed. I use K9 instead of Gmail. Better in every single way.

What do you use instead of Maps?

I don't use Google+ or Facebook. Thank god for disabling applications. (I'm referring to the ones that are locked to your phone and cannot be uninstalled).

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#56
post #53
post #52

Gmail app, both iOS and Android is full of fail. Too much "clean design" - aka, flat featureless grey on white boxes with icons that mean very little. I hate this new 'minimal' design craze.

Google Apps on my Android always were always one of the worst. Google Maps - resource hungry, always doing something in the background, slow .. replaced them with much better, unfortunately local, alternative Google Play - two examples: doesn't prevent phone from losing network so I have to play with the phone in order to download updates; listing my applications always takes about half a minute.. even if I did the s…

Maps doing stuff in background? That's the location service being used by another app, commonly weather apps.

As for G+/Talk, disable sync or sign out of Talk.

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#57
I love the app, but there is one thing I'd change to perfect it, because I'm a heavy label user:

When choosing a label, there's no immediate visual feedback to show which label you've selected. This might not sound critical, but using a finger on a moving train can lead to inaccurate pressing! Compare that to the web interface: select a label, and there's immediate feedback saying "this conversation has been moved to/labelled "whatever_the_label_is".

I'd like to either see my selection invert, or a confirmation similar to the web interface.

(And agree with the OP: taking up valuable screen space with a thick border is inefficient).

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#58
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Mail.app on iOS you just have to tap the 'From' address and choose a different one. What am I missing?

Not exactly. To send from a different 'From' in Mail.app, first you need to connect your iPhone to additional email accounts (Settings->Mail). Then these addresses will show up in your 'From' drop down. But then you end up with multiple inboxes in your Mail.app. Which is messy, fills up storage, and hurts my brain -- since I never need to check my other inboxes (because all my email addresses forward to the same Gmai…

To send from different mail addresses in Mail.app for iOS with only one inbox, you can add your additional mail addresses to your default mail address in the mail configuration by separating them with commas:

default@example.com, additional1@example.com, additional2@example.com, etc.

The same trick works for the OS X version of Mail.app

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#59
post #45

I love the Gmail iPhone app. In particular, I love that it lets me change the "from" address, similarly to how the gmail.com site lets me do that. Neither Mail.app nor Sparrow made it easy to change the from. I have a few different email addresses that all get forwarded to my gmail account. Finally my mobile mail problem -- being able to select my from -- is solved. If anyone from Google is reading this, thank you!

I love in particular that the list is sorted in an alphabetical order. It is not exclusive to the Gmail.app for iOS but in the web GUI, it wasn't available a few months ago. If you added an additional mail addresse, the order within your address list sometimes even changed.

I would of course still prefer if I could define the list order (as in Mail.app for iOS and OS X) but an alphabetical order is still better than a more or less random order … :)

Re: One reason Gmail for iOS still sucks

#60
post #12

I've been pretty happy using Mail with GMail set up as an Exchange host in order to get push. I am glad that Google is putting effort into their client. I couldn't figure out how to get the new Gmail to do a real delete instead of an archive.

Speaking of ActiveSync/Exchange, is it possible to use Gmail on the Mac this way?

IMAP works but there's always the 'too many simultaneous connections' issue since Gmail IMAP is limited to 10 simultaneous connections within a certain time frame and you easily reach this number of connections if you access Gmail from 3-4 devices …

Post reply on HN