Live data from Hacker News

Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

reclaimthenet.org

71–80 of 313 posts

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#71
post #41

I've heard there's a service called PirateBay that offers movies free of DRM. Maybe people considering being Sony customers in the future should give it a try.

The Pirate Bay is considered one of the worst pirate sites now. Of course, if you can find what you want, then you can, but any piracy community will recommend against it due to nonexistent moderation (eg. against viruses), poor navigation, and lack of uploads due to them not issuing new uploader accounts for several years now.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#72
post #51

Wait, people trusted a corporation and got screwed?!? Why, that's...unheard of!(My wife, bless her, has "purchased" dozens of movies on amazon. I warned her that when the amazon wind changes, she may regret those purchases. I got the look.)

I understand where you are going with this, but it also feels incorrect to me to blame people innocently "buying" media from a $corporation. What are people to do if they want to stay on the non-pirate/legal side of this but also prevent being royally F-ed?

There's no overlap. Just pirate.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#74

I really hope this leads to a class action that sets precedence, but I won't hold my breath or even consider whether that's even possible.

Class actions are usually not very effective. Each affected individual will receive $0.03 and the company will pay 0.5% of the money it made from this maneuver. What actually works is the opposite, mass small claims lawsuits for refunds, because that way the cost of handling those cases is much higher for the company than for the individual.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#76
post #50

Ending the production of physical discs too. Ripe for disruption.

No legal disruption is possible - these are the terms content holders insist on. Illegal disruption already happened and you already have access to it, but you're not using it because you don't want to break the law.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#77
post #66
post #6

It should be illegal to have others purchase what you as a company only licensed and therefore aren’t legally allowed to sell.

If buying is not owning, piracy is not theft.

Piracy was never theft.

It was a copyright violation. Which, I don't give one fuck about.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#79

We need some kind of modern equivalent to the old proposed Digital Media Consumer's Rights Act but which protects people's rights to digital media they buy. These should never be sold and then taken away with no compensation like this. We need a law that forces companies to treat digital files the same as a physical purchase. They can't take it away and have to allow people to resell and loan out as well. And in case…

They’ll be begging for it when they recreate the very piracy problem they were fleeing, but far worse.

Re: Sony Deletes 551 Movies PlayStation Owners Paid For

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's copyright infringement. They do not have the rights to distribute the movies.

Neither does Sony (anymore), apparently. They still sold them.

and redefined the terms of "sold" in their contract to mean "rent, with a one-time fee"

it is more immoral to sell something you can't legally "sell" (permanently and irrevocably transfer ownership of a product), than to pirate that content (which has no level of expected payment)

Post reply on HN