Live data from Hacker News

From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

ai.meta.com

61–70 of 104 posts

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#62
post #44
post #29

[stub for offtopicness] p.s. come on you guys - this is not what HN is for. You may not owe $megacorp better but you owe this community better if you're participating here.

@dang How is this offtopic? Meta has shown remarkable disregard to users' and employees' privacy. Why should that not come up when discussing an entirely new dystopian technology that allows them to invade privacy at scale?

The topic is research into brain-wave decoding.

To take some specific piece of research going on in one corner of $BigCorp, and tar it with the brush of general sentiment about $BigCorp, is a classic example of generic tangent: where the topic goes from something specific-and-more-interesting, to something generic-and-more-indignant. We've learned over the years that this is exactly the wrong direction for HN threads to head in. Note this, from https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html:

"Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents."

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#63
post #29

[stub for offtopicness] p.s. come on you guys - this is not what HN is for. You may not owe $megacorp better but you owe this community better if you're participating here.

[flagged]

Ok, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#64

Please see my bio for the full rant. The key take-away is: > While we missed the boat on Internet tracking, there is still time to avoid sailing through the final frontier of neural tracking. > Thanks to the BCI, we will soon be offered the trade of our privacy for the convenience of password-free login and faster typing. Next, there will be a quick TSA neural scan prior to boarding...

I'm not sure whether to be worried or not and I am not talking about whatever you wrote but for your own sake , it seems to be extremely paranoid style of writing

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#65

Please see my bio for the full rant. The key take-away is: > While we missed the boat on Internet tracking, there is still time to avoid sailing through the final frontier of neural tracking. > Thanks to the BCI, we will soon be offered the trade of our privacy for the convenience of password-free login and faster typing. Next, there will be a quick TSA neural scan prior to boarding...

This is the most pessimistic take on this tech here. You can view anything with the same lens.

The way to not get the most pessimistic outcome is to work for a better one, and to do that you have to first recognize the danger

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#67

Please see my bio for the full rant. The key take-away is: > While we missed the boat on Internet tracking, there is still time to avoid sailing through the final frontier of neural tracking. > Thanks to the BCI, we will soon be offered the trade of our privacy for the convenience of password-free login and faster typing. Next, there will be a quick TSA neural scan prior to boarding...

I'm not sure whether to be worried or not and I am not talking about whatever you wrote but for your own sake , it seems to be extremely paranoid style of writing

It is impossible not to sound like a kook when discussing this topic.

I think anyone in 1995, who was accurately predicting our current state of privacy would have sounded like a paranoid lunatic as well.

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#68

Please see my bio for the full rant. The key take-away is: > While we missed the boat on Internet tracking, there is still time to avoid sailing through the final frontier of neural tracking. > Thanks to the BCI, we will soon be offered the trade of our privacy for the convenience of password-free login and faster typing. Next, there will be a quick TSA neural scan prior to boarding...

This is the most pessimistic take on this tech here. You can view anything with the same lens.

I’m trying to not be snarky here, but it is difficult to have an optimistic take about an advertising company working on mind reading technology. At some point we have to call a spade a spade, I think.

Re: From brain waves to words: a new path to communication without surgery

#70
post #66

Are they trying to infer characters/words from brain waves? I would have thought the brain is thinking in concepts rather than actual words

no contradiction, both can be true, you think in concepts, then verbalize, which is what they capture
Post reply on HN