Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

anthropic.com

71–80 of 197 posts

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#71

Couple years ago the West was complaining about surveillance and scoring system of citizens in China (or was making fun of it) Seems like US wants to get ahead on this and be #1 Also Sam Altman will love this idea, because he already tried it with Worldcoin

Well, the powers-that-be saw how a society that doesn't allow a lot of open criticism works in the form of China. The massive returns on investment, the near-permanent ruling class in the form of party cadres, etc. Then they decided they want that for themselves.

If you do business with totalitarian societies that aren't made to liberalize, you too will become a totalitarian society.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#72

More signal that the open-weight models should be our destiny as an industry. These proprietary models are being used to usher in more surveillance and gatekeeping across the industry.

Someone should start a nonprofit company focused on developing Open AI. I bet we could even get some sensible billionaires to help the effort.

Maybe one of those trillionaires could help for a bit before leaving to make his own AI model, too.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have a home server that runs Qwen3.6-35B-A3B through llama.cpp with Open WebUI for the user facing interface. My teen isn't super interested in AI, but whenever they do feel curious they have their own account they can use on our home network. As far as chatting goes local models are more than capable for handling standard chat questions, doing research, helping troubleshoot problems etc. In fact it was an agent po…

What is an "ephemeral" model in this context?

Just running it through `llama-cli` so that there's absolutely no persistent state related to the chat (and least I believe this to be the case).

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#74

More signal that the open-weight models should be our destiny as an industry. These proprietary models are being used to usher in more surveillance and gatekeeping across the industry.

I’m curious (and please forgive my ignorance if it’s obvious), are open weight models practically feasible? I mean from a financial and sustainability standpoint, assuming they’re equally powerful as their proprietary counterparts. I guess I’m trying to understand the economics of it.

There is an understandable gap between the capabilities of closed models and those of open models. The current difference is primarily expressed in the cost of hardware necessary to sufficiently run a exactly comparable model. A single higher end graphics card running on your average gaming computer, is capable of running small to medium models that compare with those of their lab-born counterparts in the small-medium range. But the heavyweight models are still outside the realm of possibility for all but the most well-funded individual.

However, I would highly suggest more people experiment with these smaller models. They are incredibly capable in many ways that many people dont realize.

The perceived capabilities of the larger models are also much less the result of the model having more parameters/training cycles, but rather that they are being run through well-made harnesses, something which the open-source community is rapidly approaching with near-peer solutions of their own.

In short, much of the gap between between open-weight models and the larger proprietary models can be considered more of an issue of perception and not an issue of capability. There is a fundamental gap economically, but not so much in capability. The open source community is rapidly closing the gap on these larger labs, especially thanks to the amazing research being freely given openly by well funded chinese labs.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#75

Couple years ago the West was complaining about surveillance and scoring system of citizens in China (or was making fun of it) Seems like US wants to get ahead on this and be #1 Also Sam Altman will love this idea, because he already tried it with Worldcoin

It's a little bold to assume that 15% of the US population means the entire US wants this. We founded this country against unwarranted government interference in our personal lives, it's why the fourth and fifth amendment exist.

You could say the same about China, where only 7% of people can vote. In the US, 72% of people can vote.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#76
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Either way I don't think this will end well for humanity.

How could it not? I get the whole fear of AI making robots and going anti-human, but after using the tech for a few months now that seems too absurd.

It's would probably just burn more gas and make the climate even worse. Some assholes will get richer in the process.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#77
post #53

US regulations on AI is going to make it more and more difficult for EU/UK/everyone else to access these model providers. At this point it's completely outgrageous that the EU, UK, or even Canada can't put forth the funding to develop their own local AI model industry.

We'll talk to China

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#78
post #59

More signal that the open-weight models should be our destiny as an industry. These proprietary models are being used to usher in more surveillance and gatekeeping across the industry.

I'm happy to give my identity to Anthropic and crush my competition with irrational fear about privacy and personal data. This is a serious competitive advantage and a moat.

Is this satire? I really can't tell.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#79
post #59

More signal that the open-weight models should be our destiny as an industry. These proprietary models are being used to usher in more surveillance and gatekeeping across the industry.

I'm happy to give my identity to Anthropic and crush my competition with irrational fear about privacy and personal data. This is a serious competitive advantage and a moat.

>This is a serious competitive advantage

Given they have laughable uptime and I have yet to find a useful project mostly written by claude... I doubt it.

Re: Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity

#80
post #53

US regulations on AI is going to make it more and more difficult for EU/UK/everyone else to access these model providers. At this point it's completely outgrageous that the EU, UK, or even Canada can't put forth the funding to develop their own local AI model industry.

It's not that they can't, it's that it's

1) not a priority

2) expensive as hell

The amounts of capital sunk into AI model creation and service is truly mind-boggling. It also comes with the implication that it'll recoup investment by slashing jobs. For better or worse, those are hard sells in the countries you mentioned.

Post reply on HN