Live data from Hacker News

Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

koenvangilst.nl

131–140 of 144 posts

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#131

But all this was in the training data no? https://github.com/Nuno1123/chaser https://github.com/tee-lab/collective-responses-of-flocking-... https://shoze.itch.io/sheep-game https://store.steampowered.com/app/3006280/Sheepherds/ https://ameiswhattodo.itch.io/sheepy

Oh wow, this is just a straight ripoff of that last one isn’t it?

I feel like this is a recurring theme. Someone posts about one shotting something and then it’s revealed that you could also have one-shot it buy git cloning the repo it’s based off of

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#132

I think it’s impressive that an LLM can take you to a local maxima in one-shot. But once you start maintaining it, improving it and fixing bugs, you’ll eventually need to rip it apart and put it back together again while understanding how it all works. This is why I think the better approach isn’t to one-shot but to have the architecture in your head and build it up piece by piece, with the AI accelerating the code w…

Exactly this! People think the one shot gets them to 95% complete on an implementation of their vision. Issue is, it actually gets you the AIs vision adjacent to what you want, and coercing that into the actual implementation you want is now 95% of the work.

This is really no different from working with humans. A visionary founder has to spend tremendous effort to get their engineers to will a vision into existence. This will be the key skill with AI.

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#133

My Belgian Tervuren and I have a basic herding title and about 4 years of herding experience. The sheep movement is excellent. You could make it even more realistic by having them favor lusher areas and by having one occasionally bolt spastically (hard mode?) A handler mode where you play as a human and shout commands at the dog could be cool too!

> My Belgian Tervuren and I have a basic herding title and about 4 years of herding experience.

Do you happen to have any videos of a Tervuren doing actual herding work or competing in herding trials?

I was apparently under the wrong impression that Tervurens are no longer bred for herding. My girlfriend just told me that there are still dedicated herding lines, but when I started looking into it, I could hardly find any footage. Compared to the thousands of videos of Border Collies working stock, there seems to be very little material available.

I'd also be interested to hear more about what your dogs are like. Are they from a specialized herding line?

Do you see them as being closer to the typical working Malinois - very intense, high-drive dogs with a strong prey focus - or more like a blend of the classic German Shepherd and Border Collie traits?

The latter type, at least in my experience, can make excellent everyday companions as long as their owners know what they're doing and provide enough mental and physical stimulation.

The reason I'm asking is that I've been considering getting another Malinois. I used to own a fourth-hand Belgian Shepherd who eventually turned into a reasonably good everyday companion, but it was a long and sometimes difficult road. There were also certain situations where he could never really be trusted.

He also had a habit of finishing arguments that my Pointer started in a very Malinois-like fashion, while my Pointer was generally too stupid(and proud) to learn anything from that experience.

Feel free to write a wall of text if you feel like it.

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#135

(Exaggerated:) Guy who would never pay 20€ to another dev for such a game, pays same amount for AI. Applause to Anthropic: mission accomplished!

There's always been a premium paid for custom work, though. OP just paid off-the-rack prices for a custom-made suit.

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#136

But all this was in the training data no? https://github.com/Nuno1123/chaser https://github.com/tee-lab/collective-responses-of-flocking-... https://shoze.itch.io/sheep-game https://store.steampowered.com/app/3006280/Sheepherds/ https://ameiswhattodo.itch.io/sheepy

Oh wow, this is just a straight ripoff of that last one isn’t it? I feel like this is a recurring theme. Someone posts about one shotting something and then it’s revealed that you could also have one-shot it buy git cloning the repo it’s based off of

The real point of these posts is karma farming. Posting a good one shot is worth at least a hundred or so upvotes. People need to recognize this for what it is and ignore these kind of things.

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#137
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel like prior to GenAI, you’d have had to reckon with the true originality of your idea in some form as you did the research. Creatives having to confront their own unoriginality is such a thing it itself is reflected in countless pieces of media. So it’s interesting to me that the creator here didn’t encounter the tens of physically published versions, or the hundreds of them shipped to digital app stores, or al…

> the creator here didn’t encounter the tens of physically published versions The simplest counterargument: since there are already tens of similar games out there, why didn't the previous authors, supposedly grass-fed genuine checkmark blood-through-their-veins humans didn't notice the other 9-8-7-6-5... games, and still released their own version? Maybe because it was still that they wanted the game out there? Mayb…

How is the theft of all human knowledge and the destruction of any way of having a meaningful existence a huge accomplishment?

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#138
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel like prior to GenAI, you’d have had to reckon with the true originality of your idea in some form as you did the research. Creatives having to confront their own unoriginality is such a thing it itself is reflected in countless pieces of media. So it’s interesting to me that the creator here didn’t encounter the tens of physically published versions, or the hundreds of them shipped to digital app stores, or al…

i had a boss. before he was my boss, he was a friend. he took me under his wing, musically speaking. he showed me new music. told me what gear he was interested in. we went to some gigs. he used to say “the best artists have the biggest record collections”. they’ve done their research. they developed taste . they’ve been in that battle with the unoriginality demon. they’re still in that battle with the unoriginality…

Amen!

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh wow, this is just a straight ripoff of that last one isn’t it? I feel like this is a recurring theme. Someone posts about one shotting something and then it’s revealed that you could also have one-shot it buy git cloning the repo it’s based off of

The real point of these posts is karma farming. Posting a good one shot is worth at least a hundred or so upvotes. People need to recognize this for what it is and ignore these kind of things.

What can I buy with all of my karma?

Re: Shepherd's Dog: A Game by Fable

#140
post #35

Looks kinda like "Sheepherds" which came out recently. However as others have pointed out the idea is a common one, probably because many people are exposed to sheep and sheep dogs and farming. Which further reinforces a previous point I made that all human work is derivative and barely anything actually original. But that's why it doesn't matter! Make that game/app/website that someone else has made before, make you…

I’m sure I saw a blog post about this same mechanic being made by llms back a year or so ago too

Well it was the same person at least

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43360648 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43298945

Post reply on HN