Live data from Hacker News

South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

discuss.privacyguides.net

141–150 of 177 posts

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#141

Looks like South Korea is taking a page out of its northern neighbour's book. Will this impact software exported out of Korea? I can't imagine Samsung will gain any popularity if their phones come prepackaged with AI censorship tools. It massively backfired when Apple planned to do it on iPhones.

My Samsung has "Galaxy AI" all over it, it's just an S23.

I've tried to use it out of curiosity and it rejects a lot of my image edits as inappropriate (violence) so the foundation is set.

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#142
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not intellectually lazy, it's being intellectually tired. Both parties only every get anything done in this country when it comes to voting to restrict our rights. Ideologically, I'm slightly right leaning. My primary value is individual rights are more important. But if I could, I would vote for Ron Wyden(D) despite the fact that I disagree with many of his positions, he's still one of the few that has a spine…

I can understand it's tiring. But, as someone who was born in totalitarian regime - you still have plenty opportunities to change things in the U.S. Many U.S. states have direct democracy, which is unique in vast majority of the world. You still have free media. You can influence primaries of the two parties. I don't think people are "protest" voting. You're the one protest voting - by not voting at all. You should a…

Oh, I still vote. I feel that if I don't, then I have no right to complain. no matter how unhappy I am with the candidates.

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#143
post #52
post #5

[flagged]

I’m Korean too, but people forget that the right wing has also enforced censorship. Personally, I think the Korean right wing cries out for freedom, but in reality their ideology is rooted in the anti-communist thought of the anti-communist liberal era. I myself have somewhat negative feelings toward communism, but the so-called 'right-wing' regime in Korea is really just nostalgia for dictatorship. The current Korea…

> the right wing has also enforced censorship

Not familiar with Korean politics, but both left and right are immensely pro-censorship here in America. For the most part, the only thing that's saving us (at least so far) is that they can't agree on what to censor.

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>The problem is that using an AI censorship tool requires purchasing a solution from a specific vendor. This smells of corruption.

It's essentially a takedown of Korean imageboards and forums where political memes, especially of the current president, is very popular. They are fully aware that these operators will not be able to afford the hardware and sustain their public squares by requiring a ridiculous ordinance targeting them. I see GP is downplaying this very fact that its the "norm" in Korea and I can tell you that it's not. Korea has enj…

Why not just host them outside of Korea then?

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#145

The catholic church fought the printing press for hundreds of years. Lets see how long our rulers fight the internet.

The printing press was very much an invention /not/ at the disposal of the citizens. It analogizes poorly to the Internet.

Best to revisit your ideas pf which leaflets were popular, and who was making them in the 1500s

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#146

Something missing as cultural context is that deepfake, involuntary "porn", and all sorts of abuse of personal image, are a rampant and omnipresent problem in Korea. Many things are great here, but the sexual landscape when it comes to men versus women and kids, is nasty. You can't really apply a Western mindset to this without understanding just how messed up some of that stuff is. So whatever you think of the mecha…

> It's going to sound cliché but it leans on harmony and the group where the Western one leans on the individual.

I associate "harmony" with voluntary cooperation and joy, not machines preemptively gagging people. A good exercise is to imagine what this would look like transplanted into non-tech terms: it is illegal to operate a bar, restaurant, book shop, art studio, or even to gather in medium-to-large groups of people, without a government assigned censor empowered to listen in and silence people.

Does that still look "harmonious"?

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#148

Something missing as cultural context is that deepfake, involuntary "porn", and all sorts of abuse of personal image, are a rampant and omnipresent problem in Korea. Many things are great here, but the sexual landscape when it comes to men versus women and kids, is nasty. You can't really apply a Western mindset to this without understanding just how messed up some of that stuff is. So whatever you think of the mecha…

> It's going to sound cliché but it leans on harmony and the group where the Western one leans on the individual. I associate "harmony" with voluntary cooperation and joy, not machines preemptively gagging people. A good exercise is to imagine what this would look like transplanted into non-tech terms: it is illegal to operate a bar, restaurant, book shop, art studio, or even to gather in medium-to-large groups of pe…

You are thinking in Western terms. In East Asian Confucian societies, "harmony" means following the rules to keep the social hierarchy in place. Staying quiet and not disrupting the status quo is more important than your sense of personal freedom.

From our Western point of view, it is very much not voluntary and joyful.

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#149
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

CMS here not referring to content management system?

You're right. I need to explain that the bulletin board systems and forum systems are built primarily around a specific CMS. Sorry about that.

No, you need to explain what CMS stands for. Your three consecutive non-answers are making you look like you aren't a real person.

Re: South Korean forums will need to scan every images with AI censorship tools

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's interesting. I didn't know any other country in East Asia that showed this level of restrictive policy that sets up a cascade of problematic tooling and technologies. Japanese Internet was pretty bad in the 2010s, but this was all self-inflicted done by the private sector. The government had very little do with it. And even then, ActiveX controls were very rare. My main pain point with online banking was ugly…

The paper card 2FA seems better than SMS 2FA or an app 2FA if you're relatively sure your physical security is good. The card shouldn't cost money or could cost 50 yen which would be more than enough to cover printing it. You're not vulnerable to SMS interception or phone malware. You're also not forced into Google's or Apple's walled gardens.

There are plenty of TOTP 2FA apps that work across different platforms, open source ones too, it's just a couple dozen LoC for the core functionality.
Post reply on HN