Earlier quoted context omitted.
Are data centers a new and mysterious technology?
The mad rush to build datacenters at this unprecedented scale is already wreaking havoc on the consumer economy. The needs of everyday people are far more important than the whims of a few trillion dollar tech companies run by billioinaires.
New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
61–70 of 190 posts
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#62Earlier quoted context omitted.
Are data centers a new and mysterious technology?
There's a serious concern that we're in a bubble and many of the pending disruptions to land use and infrastructure might be soon abandoned with no one left to clean up the mess
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#63Earlier quoted context omitted.
There's a serious concern that we're in a bubble and many of the pending disruptions to land use and infrastructure might be soon abandoned with no one left to clean up the mess
What mess? It's a big empty metal box with a heck of an HVAC system and a parking lot sized for industrial use. Just about any less specialized use could be pivoted to at any point during or after construction. These things only become static "messes" or "blighted" because regulation prevents fire sale and pivot to a new use from being viable. Edit: People really seem to be ignoring the sentence prior to this edit. F…
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#64I clicked the article expecting to see some feel-good political grandstanding (I'm a bit cynical these days) but honestly, this seems like a decent approach. Pause approvals for a year giving breathing room for researching the impacts, and hopefully address them.
I don't think anyone here would describe that example as a good-faith policy. I feel the same goes for the NY bill. It's not a sincere attempt to consider the pros and cons, it's just an effort to shut down unpopular projects to appease the electorate. Maybe that's right, but no need to pretend it's anything more.
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#65Populist nonsense like this is all that New York passes. Data Centers have minimal impact, provides some jobs, and New York needs to upgrade their power system and build more power plants anyways.
50k residents of Lake Tahoe need to find a new source of electricity now that their power provider is planning to feed a nearby data center[0].
0: https://fortune.com/2026/05/12/lake-tahoe-data-center-49000-...
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#66I don't get it, nyc wants to add government programs, they obviously need to tax something. Here come massive corps willing to invest a ton of money, just tax them at some reasonable rate and voila, you can now pay for city funded grocery stores or whatever
So by your logic if a massive company came and said they want to setup an oil refinery or coal power plant you'd say they should say yes just because they could get tax revenue? You always have to way the pros and cons of such massive projects. Plus, this isn't a ban it's just a one year moratorium so impact etc can be studied.
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#67[flagged]
To have an equivalent capacity of DCs in space would require such astronomical costs there is 0 chance it would be profitable esp considering how fast GPUs deprecate
How about we start with actually finishing all the datacenters we've started (many if not most are unstarted, paused or outright cancelled)?
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#68Earlier quoted context omitted.
What mess? It's a big empty metal box with a heck of an HVAC system and a parking lot sized for industrial use. Just about any less specialized use could be pivoted to at any point during or after construction. These things only become static "messes" or "blighted" because regulation prevents fire sale and pivot to a new use from being viable. Edit: People really seem to be ignoring the sentence prior to this edit. F…
Or if nobody wants to buy them
Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#69Re: New York just passed a one-year temporary ban on data centers
#70I clicked the article expecting to see some feel-good political grandstanding (I'm a bit cynical these days) but honestly, this seems like a decent approach. Pause approvals for a year giving breathing room for researching the impacts, and hopefully address them.
Are data centers a new and mysterious technology?