Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

windowslatest.com

221–230 of 686 posts

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#221
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a valid comparison. Up until this (theoretical) machine, the playing field wasn't equal. Windows laptops in general couldn't really compare in many aspects with Macs since M1 (outside of gaming), batteries were horrible due to bad efficiency, performance wasn't amazing even with the best SKUs, and the distance between the vendor and Microsoft was always impacting different aspects of the finished product. Ev…

> Up until this (theoretical) machine, A little earlier than that. With Intel's Lunar Lake / Panther Lake, x86 laptops are again in the same ballpark as a Mac efficiency-wise. There are reputable reviews where people are getting 16-20 hours of battery life out of them doing real work, in both Windows & Linux. M5 is probably still better, but at least the x86 machines don't embarrass themselves any more.

They still run a bit hotter and louder.

Outside of that though, there's still hit and miss quality on the PC OEM side of things. 1080p screens are still the default for a ton of models, even higher end ones, and the OEMs keep missing the point of why people prefer Apple hardware.

Several are coming out with 8GB machines now at macbook Neo price points with....1920x1200 screens, probably a low quality panel, and questionable trackpad. Again, missing the entire point of the Neo.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#222
I'm on my third Surface Pro (an 11 this time) and basically love it. Tablet form factor, lightweight, multitouch, with a real desktop OS (I mean not ipad's iOS). Decent battery life. True, it's not perfect: slow to wake, the touchpad stops working once in a while & needs to be reset. Missing a GPS chip. But it runs Adobe, Resolve, Chrome of course, msys2, and Linux (WSL2) quite well. I love the absolutely gorgeous HiDPI screen. The software emulator system is a little weird (arm64/arm64EC/arm64X, with no true universal x64/arm64 binary) for software developers, but it basically works fine from a user perspective. I say all this as someone whose daily driver is an Arm M1 Macbook Pro, also nice but not a tablet and quite heavier. I don't use a dock, just a simple USBC hub with a magnetic USBC connector.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#223

> It’s well known that the Surface trackpads are among the best in the industry, surpassing even MacBooks in several aspects What aspects are these?

solid glass haptic trackpad instead of a clicky, mechanical piece of junk one?

The only MacBook sold with a mechanical trackpad in the past eight years is the MacBook Neo.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#224

The biggest problem here is the operating system. If they could fix that, this might be enticing.

If they put Linux on it I'd buy it, but with Windows 11, no thanks.

I bought the Snapdragon Elite X over a year ago based on the promises of Qualcomm to bring solid Linux drivers at some point. Fast forward to today, Linux for that SoC is still a hot mess.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#225
post #207
post #196

I get that they're pushing AI really hard, but the article bearing so many of the hallmarks of being AI-generated almost feels crass, like there are no humans at the company who feel strongly enough about this device to author 5-6 enthusiastic paragraphs about its features, they had to outsource to something that can somewhat convincingly mimic enthusiasm. Yet I'm supposed to care...

It's also shockingly twitter-nerd-coded. "The cure for token anxiety", it advertises. To be honest it's hard to see why anyone would buy this product so maybe they decided to take a wild swing with the marketing. The only use is people who really, really, want to run models locally vs getting a much cheaper and higher performance result from a cloud host.

Higher performance, I agree, but cheaper?

I didn’t check how much this costs, but if you use AI locally a lot, it’s going to be amortised pretty quickly. Burning 100$ a month on tokens has become insanely easy. I remember when it was unimaginable for me…

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#227

My experience with Surfaces and, particularly, the Surface Book and its accompanying dock were such that I'd have to be paid to use one again. For example, the dock would get its own updates silently and brick itself randomly and the proprietary magnetic connector between the dock and the computer was prone to a poor connection. I remember many occasions trying to work and my screens just randomly blinking in and out…

Counter-point the Surface Studio was one of the best PCs for drafting and design we've ever owned.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#228

Who is the target market for this? As an Apple user who can’t make iPad OS work I am always tempted by the surface but.. Every time I contemplate the surface (I like the hardware / concept) it seems the software I might want to use doesn’t support arm..

> the software I might want to use doesn’t support arm Doesn't Windows come with something like Apple's Rosetta to do on the fly translation? I expect it wouldn't work with games, but most other kinds of software should work. Rosetta worked quite well for Apple so I would expect Microsoft could do something similar.

Yes, its called prism, supposedly Microsoft is making improvements to it also specifically to go along with this release.

It's not as good as Rosetta 2 was, but its still pretty good.

Problem is not everything runs through emulation though. There's still a lot of edge cases for super old enterprise crap.

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#229

My experience with Surfaces and, particularly, the Surface Book and its accompanying dock were such that I'd have to be paid to use one again. For example, the dock would get its own updates silently and brick itself randomly and the proprietary magnetic connector between the dock and the computer was prone to a poor connection. I remember many occasions trying to work and my screens just randomly blinking in and out…

My absolute favorite fact about the Surface is that if the battery runs out, the Surface Dock power is unable to bootstrap it. You have to plug in a charger Not sure if that's still the case but truly astonishing https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/surface/surface-dock/tro...

there is a hidden paperclip button you can unlock it with

Re: Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra

#230

My experience with Surfaces and, particularly, the Surface Book and its accompanying dock were such that I'd have to be paid to use one again. For example, the dock would get its own updates silently and brick itself randomly and the proprietary magnetic connector between the dock and the computer was prone to a poor connection. I remember many occasions trying to work and my screens just randomly blinking in and out…

Counter-point the Surface Studio was one of the best PCs for drafting and design we've ever owned.

and love the 3:2 monitor aspect ratio
Post reply on HN