Live data from Hacker News

YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

pocketables.com

21–30 of 113 posts

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#21

Easy fix, wait for the next billing, contact the bank explaining what happened, and block that and future debits. At least in Australia, this shouldn't be a problem.

I'd imagine if you have a card payment reverted to Google and they ban you in return, you're in a world of pain (that you are in the right probably doesn't matter).

The OP is already banned? Whats the issue in cancelling a charge you cannot use?

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#22
500000000th person discovers google is not creating youtube for you, but for them to make cash. Crazy story. Really shocking and definitely not one of the most standard complaints in existence.

Anyways, there's absolutely no such thing as "I can't stop paying for this". Just do a chargeback on your card. It's not a real problem.

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#24
post #4

I assume you have a consumer protection agency. Ping them. Put it in plain words. "I have been paying... they made it impossible to access stuff I paid for and made it impossible to unsubscribe." That's textbook fraud. They'll be fined and give you your money back.

I agree. The answer is regulation that outlines rules of engagement for "free" (you are the product) online services.

Australia is famous for having very strong consumer protection laws for purchased products (physical goods). It has been discussed many times here. How does this work in the digital universe?

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#25

Easy fix, wait for the next billing, contact the bank explaining what happened, and block that and future debits. At least in Australia, this shouldn't be a problem.

Same for uk. Can cancel direct debits from the bank website.

Things like this would probably not be via direct debit though

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#26
post #17

I had a strange and similar interaction with Google recently. I was asked to do the Android developer verification, but then I missed a deadline at some point. Support said that I would need to create a new Google account for all of this. I said this was unacceptable as this was a Google account I had for nearly 25 years and I didn't want to create another. They said tough luck, go make the new account. Luckily, I ha…

Had similar experience. My best guess is that the account never went through the various age verification flows (since it was that old, it predated all that) and ended up being marked for deletion- I suspect that they had a bug (legal or in code) that prevented warning emails to get out. I got lucky to detect it early, since they disabled AI a few weeks before account deletion.

My gmail account still has the "First off, welcome. And thanks for agreeing to help us test Gmail." mail in it from June 2004. The account itself is over 21 years old. I wonder if I'll get forced to age verify myself any time?

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#27

I had a strange and similar interaction with Google recently. I was asked to do the Android developer verification, but then I missed a deadline at some point. Support said that I would need to create a new Google account for all of this. I said this was unacceptable as this was a Google account I had for nearly 25 years and I didn't want to create another. They said tough luck, go make the new account. Luckily, I ha…

I'm surprised you were able to get a person to address your issue.

I thought exactly the same! My question: How/Why were they able to speak to a human (or maybe chat/email)?

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#28
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd imagine if you have a card payment reverted to Google and they ban you in return, you're in a world of pain (that you are in the right probably doesn't matter).

The OP is already banned? Whats the issue in cancelling a charge you cannot use?

Google has a degree of seperation value stored on every account. Once the algorithm determines its been wronged it increases the radius so expect your household members and work colleagues accounts to be at risk when you try this.

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm surprised you were able to get a person to address your issue.

I thought exactly the same! My question: How/Why were they able to speak to a human (or maybe chat/email)?

Last year our bakery business got blocked from Google Maps. Reason: Your business is not eligible...

Yep, apparently a brick and mortar bakery isn't eligible for Google Maps. Obviously bogus. I appealed over and over again, rereading the rules, watching every dumb YouTube video, fixing every minor imagined transgression I could think of and each time just got another BS automated "your business is not eligible...".

Pretty much gave up them my partner decided to try one more time. In Vietnamese.

We had both been trying, she in Vietnamese, me in English, but this time she tried it at about 10:30pm local time and apparently it got routed to a bored Vietnamese speaker in the California help center, who fixed it immediately.

So it is possible but it'll take some weird combination of luck and timing.

Re: YouTube locked my accounts and I can't cancel my subscription

#30
Literally had a similar experience with X today.

Was browsing when all of a sudden my account got suspended for no apparent reason. This was a premium account too, and I had last posted a tweet last year. I would maybe comment here and there once a week.

Ok cool you suspended my account. But when I tried to access my billing details to cancel the premuim sub, I got a "Something went wrong" error.

All these big tech companies have the same billing issues after bans/suspensions. Once they decide you're persona non grata, they don't give a f about cancelling your billing.

Post reply on HN