Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

github.com

201–210 of 418 posts

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On what basis are you assuming that Anthropic committed greater copyright theft than Meta, OpenAI, and Google (not to mention many lesser-known options)?

Legally speaking they were found to have by a court and the others weren’t

When did that happen? Did they admit guilt in the big settlement, or was there a different case?

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#202
post #194
post #98

I'm really struggling to understand how Anthropic is benefited by not allowing this. Its bad PR for no good reason. The only thing I can figure is that Claude Code is hemorrhaging money, they're too afraid to actually enforce reasonable token limits, and the only thing that's keeping it from totally bankrupting the company tomorrow is: controlling the harness and having the harness dynamically route toward Haiku or S…

This is analogous to when Google launched Gmail with 1GB of storage and then a bunch of third-party apps cropped up that took advantage of it to use it as a generic online file storage drive. There was GMailFS[0] and Gmail Drive[1] - this is before S3, dropbox, and a time where web hosting would give you ~10MB or so of space. Google updated their ToS and shut down accounts using their service in ways they weren't int…

> Google have more cash to burn in the AI race so can be more forgiving today in how their codex plans are used.

Even despite the larger cash pile to burn, Google is in the middle of their own controversy around what many feel is a rug-pull around how Gemini "AI credits" work and are priced.

See:

https://www.theregister.com/2026/03/12/users_protest_as_goog...

https://old.reddit.com/r/google_antigravity/comments/1rv4cec...

etc

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can use OpenCode programmatically, thus turning that $200/mo Claude Code account into a very cheap Opus 4.6 API service. I don't think there's anything really to it past that.

you can also use Claude Code programmatically with the `prompt` parameter in the cli.

Or the Python or Typescript Agent SDK libraries: https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/agent-sdk/overview

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#205
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does Anthropic care how the tokens are consumed?

Same reason movie theaters care about you not bringing your own snacks

You pay for snacks in the cinema and they lose money if you buy elsewhere. Where does Anthropic lose money when I use OpenCode?

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unironically, you should. In a more just world, laws would mandate service providers not obstruct third party clients.

The pricing would also be different.

Yes, content providers would have to compete with each other on price and library, and client providers could compete on UX and privacy.

Re: Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode

#207
post #98

I'm really struggling to understand how Anthropic is benefited by not allowing this. Its bad PR for no good reason. The only thing I can figure is that Claude Code is hemorrhaging money, they're too afraid to actually enforce reasonable token limits, and the only thing that's keeping it from totally bankrupting the company tomorrow is: controlling the harness and having the harness dynamically route toward Haiku or S…

My guess is that the telemetry data they can collect from interacting with claude code is the "secret sauce" behind a lot of the improvements we're seeing with coding models right now. Look at cursors Composer-2 release today. Clicking "accept" during plan mode, committing changes and pushing to a remote repo, etc. is a really strong reward signal. Can't collect telemetry from applications you don't control.

You mean their tool (I use it daily) is so bad despite all the data they collect?
Post reply on HN