Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic, please make a new Slack

fivetran.com

121–130 of 264 posts

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#121
post #114
post #11

This is just crazy. Lets ask the power company to build some trains for us. They transport electricity, they _must_ know about transporting people. They can power the lines themselves! If this was so easy, teams wouldn't suck, matrix would be everywhere, and discord would be replaced already by the furries (as much as stoat is trying).

Wasn't Slack a gaming company that accidentally became a chat company?

You're thinking of Discord

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#122

Use Zulip. The migration out of Slack is actually quite easy and preserves all messages, files, etc. Even the user migration is straightforward, keeping Google or whoever as the identity provider if you prefer.

Zulip is not even close to Slack. It keeps crashing.

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, I have so much less patience for "this should exist" posts. In 2026, you could argue that this blog post should have come with a link to the repo.

I don't want everybody with an idea making a repo. It's already hard enough to filter out the slop in github that I'm reluctant about using anything built in the past year.

I hear you, but it's not like the quality bar on Github was super high before AI

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#125
post #114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wasn't Slack a gaming company that accidentally became a chat company?

You're thinking of Discord

No, I'm not. The company that became the Slack corporation was originally a game studio : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slack_(software)#History

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#126
post #31

So why can't we vibecode a new slack with claude?

It's a good test, no doubt. Many engineers are convinced that SaaS is practically dead, since all companies can vibecode their way to a lesser dependence on external (and paid!) software.

You have a funny way of spelling stock analysis.

This take fundamentally misunderstands just about every aspect of running a successful software company. Today SAAS companies make 10x what the AI companies make in revenue. In 2 years time, this will still be true. In 5 years time, this will still be true. In 10 years time, this will still be true...etc...

The amount of time writing new code is a rounding error on the costs of a software business. Losing customers to bugs, downtime and other costs having to do with maintenance are far higher. Optimizing new code writing time at the expense of everything else is just foolish and only something that someone who has never run a software business could believe.

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#128
post #71
post #11

This is just crazy. Lets ask the power company to build some trains for us. They transport electricity, they _must_ know about transporting people. They can power the lines themselves! If this was so easy, teams wouldn't suck, matrix would be everywhere, and discord would be replaced already by the furries (as much as stoat is trying).

The title is the issue. They're just asking for group chats with Claude

And other people as well, at which point they have basically recreated slack.

Re: Anthropic, please make a new Slack

#130
Remember Web 2.0? If not, check Wikipedia. The idea was that everyone could create mashup web apps to do anything thanks to open standards and free APIs. Where did that dream go? Do you think private companies are going to give everyone their data and functionality for free?

And what is so different about today’s dream of “agents” accessing private company data and functionality?

It is a lovely dream that I would be very happy to see. What can we do differently this time around?

Post reply on HN