Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

talkweb.eu

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

31–40 of 98 posts

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#31

Post by libber »

swalsh wrote: post #25
DanielBMarkham wrote: post #8

You really don't want to mess with the Facebook police. They'll delete your life. I wish I had something more substantive to say here, but the problem is that we give Facebook an extraordinarily huge power in our personal lives. It's not just some random web service.

This makes me remember a thought I was having a while ago. I'm not a fan of regulation on the internet, but there's some regulations i'd really like to see for the purpose of creating a more competitive atmosphere. They're probably too extreme today, but in the future I can see them being necessary as our lives increasingly become more digital. One of them is that all data I create, which is stored, I should have acc…

Sounds like this may interest you - https://www.facebook.com/help/131112897028467/

Facebook wraps up every status update, picture, etc in a .zip file that you can download.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#32

Post by mandeepj »

short_circut wrote: post #24
MojoJolo wrote: post #7

I don't know why Facebook reacted like that. But as I understand, those information are not from Facebook itself. They are from an unknown third party app. Also, anyone who has a knowledge in Facebook API can mine those information by creating a Facebook app. I'm sure those app like "God wants you to know" have more than 1 million Facebook information. By reacting like that, I think Facebook can be considered as guil…

You don't even need to write a facebook app. I have put together scripts in R and Matlab with those capabilities. Its absurdly simple to do using Facebook API and a JSON parser.

Using facebook API you are at the mercy of other's person consent to give you access to their email address and other data. You cannot just put some number to access a profile and get the email address or until you have some preferred access to data from FB itself.

Please let us know if you were working using some other better approach.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#33

Post by DanBC »

libber wrote: post #31
swalsh wrote: post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This makes me remember a thought I was having a while ago. I'm not a fan of regulation on the internet, but there's some regulations i'd really like to see for the purpose of creating a more competitive atmosphere. They're probably too extreme today, but in the future I can see them being necessary as our lives increasingly become more digital. One of them is that all data I create, which is stored, I should have acc…

Sounds like this may interest you - https://www.facebook.com/help/131112897028467/ Facebook wraps up every status update, picture, etc in a .zip file that you can download.

And you can get more data by making a request under data protection laws.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#35

Post by arjn »

1qaz2wsx3edc wrote: post #13
csmattryder wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

20 years old. No Facebook account. I 'deleted my life', and y'know what? Nothing changed. I still have the same friends I talked to before Facebook, still meet up for drinks on their birthdays, still arrange nights out, and still share what's going on in my life. The best thing about no Facebook? I know what information is out there, and nothing personal that Advertising Inc. can buy.

25, no facebook account for over 3 years. Life's better without!

Amen!to that brother (or sister :)

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#36

Post by swalsh »

libber wrote: post #31
swalsh wrote: post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This makes me remember a thought I was having a while ago. I'm not a fan of regulation on the internet, but there's some regulations i'd really like to see for the purpose of creating a more competitive atmosphere. They're probably too extreme today, but in the future I can see them being necessary as our lives increasingly become more digital. One of them is that all data I create, which is stored, I should have acc…

Sounds like this may interest you - https://www.facebook.com/help/131112897028467/ Facebook wraps up every status update, picture, etc in a .zip file that you can download.

I've actually setup a system where I download this zip file once every 3 months.

My main point is that the barrier to entry for making a new social network/reader etc is not one of innovation. Search for instance is hard to compete with because the bar has been set so high. Facebook is impossible to compete with because of its walls. I don't feel this page brings those walls down.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#37

Post by dclusin »

DanBC wrote: post #33
libber wrote: post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like this may interest you - https://www.facebook.com/help/131112897028467/ Facebook wraps up every status update, picture, etc in a .zip file that you can download.

And you can get more data by making a request under data protection laws.

My understanding was that this is only applicable if you are domiciled in the applicable area. Is this not correct? Has anybody tried this?

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#38

Post by jiggy2011 »

swalsh wrote: post #25
DanielBMarkham wrote: post #8

You really don't want to mess with the Facebook police. They'll delete your life. I wish I had something more substantive to say here, but the problem is that we give Facebook an extraordinarily huge power in our personal lives. It's not just some random web service.

This makes me remember a thought I was having a while ago. I'm not a fan of regulation on the internet, but there's some regulations i'd really like to see for the purpose of creating a more competitive atmosphere. They're probably too extreme today, but in the future I can see them being necessary as our lives increasingly become more digital. One of them is that all data I create, which is stored, I should have acc…

There's a few practical problems with creating that kind of legislation though.

How do you decide who has to comply with it? Every time I build a website that collects any data from users at all, do I have to also create an API for accessing that data?

Bigger companies such as FB and Google would most likely just move stuff offshore to get around this anyway.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#39

Post by oharo »

mandeepj wrote: post #34
oharo wrote: post #22

this is so normal. ark torrented all the fb accounts for their yc demo day

Ark only shows publicly available data from the people's profile at fb. If its not public then you cannot get it from ark.

you can find the exact profiles mentioned on demo day on piratebay.

Re: Followup to "I bought more than 1 million Facebook data entries for $5"

#40

Post by obilgic »

Is not that a good thing that fb is taking this issue seriously and going after the people who sell this information?

On the other hand, they are trying to solve this issue secretly, no disclosure. And we dont yet know if they are taking any privacy measures to prevent this kind of data leak.

Post reply on HN