Live data from Hacker News

Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

apple.com

381–390 of 778 posts

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#382

Airtag is the reason of why I stil have my favourite hand luggage. I had just sat down on the train from Zurich to Basel. Suddenly, someone sat down in front of me. He looked suspicious, but I didn't pay much attention. Just before the train departed, he picked up what I thought were his belongings and left. Twenty minutes later, already on the way to Basel, I looked toward where I had left my suitcase. It was gone.…

My local police would literally laugh at me if I made that call.

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#383
Apple's Find My helps thieves more than it helps the owners:

When I was on a walk with my friend, my iPhone constantly nagged me about "AIRPODS ARE MOVING WITH YOU!!!1!" and it showed me the EXACT complete route on the map.. I didn't even ask for it!

When I lost my AirPods (which are ridiculously easy to remove from your iCloud account and Find My: just hold down the pairing button for 30 seconds), it just showed me a vague radius and "Last seen around here 12 hours ago" not even a exact time.

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#385
post #318

Unfortunately the anti-stalking features have made Airtag mostly useless for theft prevention. You have less than an hour to retrieve your item before the tag alerts the thief they are being tracked. I've seen it trigger as quickly as 30 minutes.

How useful is a GPS position for theft prevention? IME cops are not interested in doing more than filing a report after a theft, even if you have a live GPS location of the item for them. Do you try and go get it yourself?

i can speak to this as i had my motorcycle stolen on NYE last year in Santa Monica with an airtag in it. the Santa Monica police said “smart, but it’s in LA so we can’t help you get it. tell the LAPD.”. it took me seven hours of calls to the LAPD while personally hunting down my bike in the shadiest areas of LA, and being a block away from getting it myself, did they come. so yes, if you’re in LA, you basically get it yourself.

in my case, the damage was so much i wish i had just left it stolen and taken the bigger insurance payout.

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#386
post #325
post #322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What happens after that? It goes dark? Or it just alerts the thief (stalker victim)?

It sends alerts to the thief's iPhone or Android (if you have Apple's Tracker Detect Android app) that they are being tracked within 30 to 60 minutes. It also enables the beeping so the thief can find and remove the Airtag. If the Airtag can't reach the thief's phone, it starts chirping by itself within an 8-24 hour window.

Do you have more info about this? Never heard it before

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#387

Airtag is the reason of why I stil have my favourite hand luggage. I had just sat down on the train from Zurich to Basel. Suddenly, someone sat down in front of me. He looked suspicious, but I didn't pay much attention. Just before the train departed, he picked up what I thought were his belongings and left. Twenty minutes later, already on the way to Basel, I looked toward where I had left my suitcase. It was gone.…

I need to applaud the efficiency and moxie of the Zurich / Swiss police service. In America, the UK, Canada, etc they'd tell you to fill out a report that nobody would ever read, and also advise you it's probably unsafe to go pick it up yourself.

[flagged]

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, Tile I believe is the only third party service that exists. All other trackers either plug into "Apple Find My" or "Android Find My Device" network. There's finally starting to be a few devices that can do both, but they're rare, so make sure you get the right one when buying. But they take 10s to setup and it's very smooth.

Any names or recs on the ones that can do both? Can they do both simultaneously?

I haven't used it, but the verge recommended the pebblebee clip5: https://pebblebee.com/products/clip-5

(or the card 5 for wallets)

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#389
post #332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have only seen the Google side, just a single time when one of my Chipolos threw an alert on my passenger's Samsung. My Chipolo certainly still works. There are [cheap] tags being sold that are compatible with both Apple Find My and Google's Find Hub . I would rather have a dual-network device than Apple's improved model. Would it be so difficult for Apple to put a hole in the Airtag so it could be directly attache…

Do these tags need to be configured on both networks to support both protocols? If I own an Android device and configure it there, will Apple devices still find the tag? How does that work?

The Chipolos that I have purchased appear on my phone when first presented, then do not offer to pair to other users' Find Hubs unless I deregister.

I imagine that Airtag functionality is disabled when Find Hub configures these tags.

I have heard in the commentary here that Chipolo is now making dual-network devices, but only one can be active at a time.

Apple has a larger and more sensitive network, so uses requiring tracking quality would lean that way.

I would prefer to find a tag that can be provisioned on both networks. I don't know if any actually work that way.

I'd also like a tag that would let me take it apart and disable the speaker. For my car, that seems appropriate, if I can also find a placement location which is extremely difficult to access.

Edit: Google is saying that "they generally require switching between networks rather than operating on both simultaneously."

Re: Apple introduces new AirTag with longer range and improved findability

#390

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not your fault for leaving your property in your car. Wild to say that.

not "fault" in the sense of legal or ethical blame, but "fault" in the sense of stupid vs. smart thing to do

But it’s not a stupid thing to do either - if anything, normalizing crime sounds not optimal.
Post reply on HN