Live data from Hacker News

Let's call a murder a murder

daringfireball.net

171–180 of 236 posts

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#171
post #116
post #11

And it's flagged, of course. Will somebody vouch for this? I know what you're thinking. This doesn't encourage curiosity! This is politics! Same old, same old. HN! Come on, how myopic must you be to not see that a working democracy is a condition sine qua non of your dear curiosity. You see what's happening in Iran, right? Well, they don't! Put your glasses on, HN, you're not seeing shit.

It's crazy to me that "no politics" arguments are still getting flung around. This is so far beyond political at this point. Citizens being murdered by masked men with total immunity? What the fuck has our country come to. He already has talked about cancelling the election. What happens when he declares a state of emergency to cancel the 2026 midterms - is that political? Are we allowed to discuss it? The effective…

[dead]

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#173
post #163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this situation is very tragic, and I wish it had not happened. The reason I am taking this stance, is because I think that, unless they are fine with becoming a martyr, people should not go and mess with government officers in the streets. Yeah, I know: “victim blaming”, but there is a difference between officers descending upon a blameless victim vs. you going out looking to make trouble with authority. Even…

What if the instructions they give you would be to submit to them while they assaulted you, sexually or physically? Are you supposed to comply and then challenge them in court later? That is a thing that happens. Rarely, I suppose, and #notallpolice and all that, but the idea that we should live in a country where everyone just has to "comply" with the instructions or be murdered is ridiculous.

Yeah, at some point every rule will run into its exception and you will have to think on your feet about which of your bad options you should take.

Cops do need to be severely punished for abuse of authority, nothing I said so far contradicts that.

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#174
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My baseline (as an outside observer) is still that they are too stupid and uncoordinated to do a facist take-over. But that a significant possibility even exists that there will be a facist take-over is awful. (The main ingredient for a facist take-over is control over the military and media and he is not creating many loyalists in either)

Mussolini was not the brightest bulb in the tanning bed, but it worked for him.

He served in the military, though. Idk if he obviously was not loyal to anyone like Trump is, I'd guess not.

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That’s interesting, because I’m actually also frightened. But the thing that scares me is how quick everyone wants to jump to conclusions as long as it supports their existing world view.

It's not about a world view. It is about watching a video and seeing what is happening. Unless you mean "world view" is my knowledge about how cars and guns work.

I watched the video and I saw Renee attempt to hit the ICE agent with her car. After doing that, lethal force is unfortunately on the table. The officer doesn’t have time after that to wait and see if she is going to try to kill him again or not.

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#177
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a frame in the YouTube video I linked where the officer is right in front of the car, the car wheel is still turned toward the driver window (so if no steering is done it would run over the officer, moreover it is directed to where the officer ends up in the end), and the front wheels with a skid starts pulling the car forward in that direction. In fact, the car goes toward the officer for about 15 frames of…

Lets assume you are right. How do you justify the 2nd and 3rd shot from the side window? Very curious how your mind works.

I haven't seen 2nd and 3rd shots from the side window. What video and what time code?

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#178
post #71

[flagged]

As Wikipedia points out "Footage from three camera angles indicates Good’s vehicle is turning past and away from the agent, not accelerating toward him, when he fires three shots through the windshield, killing her as she drives by." Recently home doorbell video released also shows the same thing from a fourth angle. There are several videos, so "the video" is unhelpful. The NYT breakdown of several videos, or the Re…

A fifth angle: Video from the shooter's handheld camera synchronized with the best other video: https://bsky.app/profile/ragnarokx.bsky.social/post/3mbz7pt4...

Re: Let's call a murder a murder

#179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not about a world view. It is about watching a video and seeing what is happening. Unless you mean "world view" is my knowledge about how cars and guns work.

I watched the video and I saw Renee attempt to hit the ICE agent with her car. After doing that, lethal force is unfortunately on the table. The officer doesn’t have time after that to wait and see if she is going to try to kill him again or not.

How is she going to try to kill him again? Drive away then come back to ram?
Post reply on HN