Live data from Hacker News

Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

nbcnews.com

361–370 of 426 posts

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#361

To me the most horrible thing about this is the reaction of government officials. I'd imagine that in a civilized democratic country it would be something along the lines of "Let's make sure there's a fair investigation". That's not what I'm hearing from US.

They’re gloating, they love this. They love being able to spit in the face of the people and tell them that they’re absolutely fine with what’s going on and we should prepare for things to get worse.

[dead]

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#362

This was after the alleged attempted ICE ramming in Oakland last year where shots were fired but thankfully nobody died. I think there was a similar incident in LA. It would be great if there were technology to solve this problem. People perceive cars as deadly weapons and open fire and whether it’s good or not people who think they’re going to get smooshed and have a firearm will tend to use it. I didn’t see the one…

You are trying to find a technical solution to a political problem.

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#364

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One thing that I, and many others, have issue with is the fact that the agents are masked, which makes it hard to hold specific actors accountable. With the way they've been deploying facial recognition against citizens, I feel like using it against ICE agents would just be sousveillance. Especially with the second video, it seems like there should be enough footage of the guy's face to figure it out. Ideally her rel…

> Ideally her relatives could then SUE Ideally a lawsuit? The only sane outcome of this in a civilized society is that the perpetrator stands trial for murder. If that does not happen the already slim distinction between US law enforcement and a paramilitary execution squad loyal to the president will have dissappeared entirely.

Who can bring charges in this instance?

Even if there is a perceived slim chance of success I still think charges should be brought forward. At the very least it might make some of these psychopaths hesitate to do the same. Maybe. And while they are at it maybe an investigation that produces names on who ordered these guys to act so brazen.

If you cant nail the guy who did this go after those who are above in rank. Maybe there's a "paper trail" on giving orders to do such thing?

People have to fight back or this lady definitely wont be the last.

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#365
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

I don't know that pg is involved with HN on a daily basis any more, but he's been publicly condemning this and arguing with people who support the ICE agent.

Garry Tan is the owner of this site, and is a vocal fascist.

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#366

When I first visited the US on business, HR conducted a training where the key point was that if stopped by police when you're in a car, don't get out of the car, they are trained to shoot first and ask questions later. Mid 90s.

Terrible training and horrible advice. Pennsylvania v Mimms requires you to step out of a vehicle upon LEO command. LEO does not need to provide any justification. Also saying they are trained to shoot first and ask questions later is very hyperbolic. Police conduct over 30 million vehicle stops per year without incident.

It makes sense in the Indian context. We get out of the car here almost immediately, so it was important to emphasise the difference.

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#367

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Keep in mind that many so-called "Americans" you see online are thousands of miles from the US, and are paid or otherwise encouraged to pretend otherwise.

That is probably true but there are also plenty of real, confirmed Americans that are doing the exact same thing.

It's known to be true. Witness what happened when Xitter turned on a country-of-origin indication briefly, realized what it was saying about their audience, and then turned it back off in a hurry.

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#368

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First, this has very little to do with any sort of mandate for immigration enforcement. Immigration is being used as a pretext to deploy revanchist terror squads that are attacking all of civil society, as we've seen with the murder of this American citizen mother. And yes, people should have seen this coming when they voted for him. But this is not what he openly campaigned on at all. Second, winning an election doe…

> Then surely you can agree that labeling this regime as unrepentant murderers of American mothers is a good way of building broad opposition from people who might otherwise think it doesn't concern them, yes? No. In fact I think jumping to conclusions, exaggerating, trying to use a tragedy to your advantage, obfuscation, and outright lying to try and manipulate public sentiment is perhaps the WORST way to try and mo…

Someone was murdered with plenty of video footage, it's reasonable to form some preliminary conclusions.

As you're appealing to a general concept of restraint, I presume you have much harsher criticism for the administration, which immediately dropped into pushing bald faced lies [0] and rejecting responsibility for the situation rather than taking even a moment to assess? Would you care to share that criticism here?

The flip side of this refrain of "don't trust your lying eyes" is outright lying by this administration "supported" by narrow video clips that don't tell the whole story. Like a clip of "stop" and the victim trying to drive away is pretty convincing, if you're not shown the other clip where another violent attacker was yelling "move move move".

[0] The basic known facts here are that ICE electively confronted and escalated a situation with an American citizen, did not follow their own mandate or rules of engagement, the woman was shot repeatedly, and then a nearby doctor tried to render emergency aid and was prevented from doing so, correct?

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#369

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're going to do (and are already doing) a lot of damage on the way to their final resting place.

[flagged]

jacquesm is a longstanding member of this community with serious technical chops. He has fabricated his own fucking windmill, among many other awe-inducing projects.

I am an American, and I generally find his political judgements to be spot on, or if I disagree then at the very least enlightening. Frankly given the abjectly moronic siren song narratives too many of my "fellow countrymen" have fallen for, we could use more outside context from allied countries of the western world to steer us through these dark times. Remember when our friends the French tried to stop us from making that horrible Iraq War mistake and the thanks they got was "freedom fries" ?

Meanwhile, you seem to be some kind of fascist-cheerleader who relishes in trolling. All over this thread, you've spared no opportunity to rally support for agents of the state executing an American citizen and mother. I would tell you to get the fuck out of my country, whose values of individual liberty and limited government you clearly have no understanding or appreciation of, before Lady Liberty sticks her torch up your ass. But really you're just sick with social media psychosis, and you need help.

(if you want a breadcrumb you might be able to follow to start to get out, you've said you can see the "media manipulation" by "the left". perhaps you could look for the same type of manipulation by "the right", and then ask yourself who has the power right now)

Re: Minneapolis driver shot and killed by ICE

#370

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

You're more likely to get scolded here for accusing that person of being a shill/troll than to see them get removed for acting exactly like one. That kind of neutral bias is selectively employed to protect right wing takes from getting attacked by more liberal ones. Although, here's pg with a brief moment of insight: https://xcancel.com/paulg/status/2009219891933630925 > hardcore Trump supporters are indistinguishabl…

I'm immediately reminded of this:

---

The moral of the story is: if you’re against witch-hunts, and you promise to found your own little utopian community where witch-hunts will never happen, your new society will end up consisting of approximately three principled civil libertarians and seven zillion witches. It will be a terrible place to live even if witch-hunts are genuinely wrong.

---

https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/01/neutral-vs-conservativ...

Post reply on HN