Live data from Hacker News

OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

theverge.com

781–790 of 960 posts

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#781

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Every so often I try out a GPT model for coding again, and manage to get tricked by the very sparse conversation style into thinking it's great for a couple of days (when it says nothing and then finishes producing code with a 'I did x, y and z' with no stupid 'you're absolutely' right sucking up and it works, it feels very good). But I always realize it's just smoke and mirrors - the actual quality of the code and t…

NME at all - 5.1 codex has been the best by far.

NME = "not my experience" I presume.

JFC TLA OD...

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#783
post #617

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is misleading. They had 4.5 which was a new scaled up training run. It was a huge model and only served to pro users, but the biggest models are always used as teacher models for smaller models. Thats how you do distillation. It would be stupid to not use the biggest model you have in distillation and a waste since they have the weights. The would have taken some time to calculate the efficiency gains of pretrai…

My understanding of 4.5 was that it was released long, long after the initial training run finished. It also had an older cutoff date than the newer 4o models

Cutoff dates seem to be Oct 2024 for GPT-4.5, and Jan 2025 for the Gemini models.

It kind of explains a coding issue I had with tradingview who update their pinescript thing quite frequently. ChatGPT seemed to have issues with v4 vs v5.

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#784

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But ChatGPT is an insane brand I mean, so was netscape.

Maybe, I was too young to remember that.

What's up with the flock of downvotes? I'd never got a comment with so many as this one… Is being younger than 45 not allowed in here?

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#785

In one of the Indian movies, there is a rather funny line that goes like this "tu jiss school se padh kar aaya hai mein uss school ka headmaster hoon". It would translate like this "The school from which you studied and came? I am the principal of that school". Looks like Google is about to show who the true principal is

Probably all of the ML foundation like transformers which OpenAI used to create its chatbot was originally developed at Google.

The people who wrote that paper left Google though.

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#786

What will it do to Jony Ive’s legacy if his OpenAI device is no more successful than Snapchat’s foray into hardware? If OpenAI becomes an also-ran by the time the hardware is released, this seems like a real possibility no matter how well-designed it is.

Did he come up with the butterfly keyboard as well?

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#787
post #780

The real code red here is less that Google just one-upped OpenAI but that they demonstrated there’s no moat to be had here. Absent a major breakthrough all the major providers are just going to keep leapfrogging each other in the most expensive race to the bottom of all time. Good for tech, but a horrible business and financial picture for these companies.

It drives me a bit crazy when people say OpenAI has no moat. Yes, companies like Google can catch up and overtake them, but a moat is merely making it hard and expensive. 99.999.. perc of companies can't dream of competing with OpenAI.

As history in tech shows you don’t need everyone copying you to be in big trouble, just one or two well positioned players. Typically that has been a big established player just adding your “special sauce product” as a feature to an existing well established product. Thats exactly what’s playing out now and why OpenAI is starting to panic as thy know how that movie typically ends.

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#788

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And this is relevant how? That interview is 1.5 hours, not something you just casually drop a link to and say "here, listen to this to even understand what point I was trying to make"

Sorry, this was meant to be a reply to this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46127942 I was trying to make the point that SemiAnalysis is semi-famous.

The video is interesting showing microsoft's latest data center and Nadella talking about them. I prefered the youtube version https://youtu.be/8-boBsWcr5A

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#789
post #733

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Inference is profitable for openai as far as I can tell. They dont need to jack up prices much, what they really need is users who are paying/consuming ads. Theyre burning money on free tier users and data center expansion so they can serve more users.

This assumes your model is static and never needs to be improved or updated. Inference is cheap because the final model, despite its size, is ridiculously less resource intensive to use than it is to produce. ChatGPT in its latest form isn't bad by any means, but it is falling behind. And that requires significant overhead, both to train and to iterate on model architecture. It is often a variable cost as well.

As long as revenue rises faster than training costs and inference remains profitable I dont think this is an issue. Eventually theyll be able to profitably amortize training across all the users.

Re: OpenAI declares 'code red' as Google catches up in AI race

#790

OpenAI is basically just Netscape at this point. An innovative product with no means of significant revenue generation. One one side it's up against large competitors with an already established user base and product line that can simply bundle their AI offerings into those products. Google will do just what Microsoft did with Internet Explorer and bundle Gemini in for 'Free' with their already other profitable produ…

Literally got an email this morning from Google, to say my Google One plan now 'includes AI benefits' - including

"More access to Gemini 3 Pro, our most capable model More access to Deep Research in the Gemini app Video generation with limited access to Veo 3.1 Fast in the Gemini app More access to image generation with Nano Banana Pro Additional AI credits for video generation in Flow and Whisk Access Gemini directly in Google apps like Gmail and Docs" [Thanks but no thanks]

Post reply on HN