Live data from Hacker News

Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

kensegall.com

141–150 of 519 posts

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They don't put MacOS on iPad because they want MacOS to slowly die and make App Store the only way to install software. This has nothing to do with cannibalizing Mac.

You might be right, but if MacOS dies, how will Apple develop for iOS etc?

And app developers too. Maybe sister comment about something cloud. Can fleece devs for more money too, bonus!

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#142
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah for me it has been degrading ever since the Settings app became an upsell app. I'm sorry I came here to change a setting not dismiss a notification on your latest failed service thing that requires 20,- a month.

It’s the push for services. It’s the product ladder with artificial limitations like low fps screens or small storage to push you a bit more. It’s bugs piling up because Marketing needs the next buzzword released. It’s the aesthetics optimized for a screenshot rather than real usability. It’s the feeling that their top talent is not able to deliver anymore, like their camera’s processing or AI features.

> It’s the product ladder with artificial limitations like low fps screens

This one really pisses me off as someone who just had to upgrade their 2018 iPad Pro. The air would've been great, if it had a 120hz screen. I really don't need any other "pro" feature but I refused to tolerate 60hz in 2025 when every other device I own including my big desktop monitor is 120hz or more. But no, I have to spend an extra $500 for a higher refresh rate. I didn't even want the pro, I want a 120hz air so I can get the colors I want.

Nonetheless, because my screen was broken and I needed a new iPad, I forked over the money for the pro. Conveniently, they use two different magic keyboards so now that I'm "locked in" to the pro ecosystem, I'm forever stuck buying iPad pros unless I also want to have to buy a new magic keyboard that works with the Air line if they ever release a 120hz air.

Apple can easily differentiate the air from the pro in numerous other ways besides refresh rate, and yet they still continue to ship 60hz screens.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#143
post #48
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Of course we don’t know. But regarding this specific example, bear in mind that Apple is in vastly better shape as a business than it was in 1999. So if that argument didn’t work on him then, it doesn’t seem implausible that it wouldn’t work now.

Or the opposite. The Apple might and/or its execs might think that they are in such a dominant position that purposefully lowering UX to extract a few extra pennies from their users won't cause any short term harm. While back in the 90s the brand/reputational damage might have destroyed them.

Back in the 90s, Apple had zero brand or reputation. It had a few die-hard Mac fans and a bunch of inherited deals with public school district purchasing departments from when the Apple II dominated. They licensed Mac OS to clone manufacturers like Microsoft did with Windows. They were essentially already destroyed and waiting for the eviction notice.

Jobs, with Mac OS X and the iMac, absolutely created the unassailable perception of quality and user experience Apple is known for today. The term "reality distortion field" was used a lot in relation to how much Jobs sold Apple and the Mac in keynotes.

So it's completely fair to use his well-known positions against the company's current practices.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#144

I ran a reverse image search on the image of Steve Jobs, and couldn't come up with anything, so it does appear that it might be AI generated, which I don't approve of.

It isn't obvious to you that it's AI? You had to look it up? Please get more familiar with actual photographs, maybe skim a few AI free photo sites or, oh, I don't know, buy a few coffee table photo books and develop some discernment, because that one is about as obvious a fake photo as a stick figure would be. It's truly gross.

Right? I only generated a single AI picture of myself and it had that exact shading seen in this picture. Extremely obvious.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#145
post #124

The very first thing I saw from Apple that, IMO, Jobs would have vehemently stopped was the two-toned back on the iPhone 5. That said, the iOS 26 release is abysmal. The only redeeming thing for me has been the enhancements to Stage Manager, everything else with the UI/UX is such a mess that every day it seems like I'm discovering something new in the realm of awful design. And this isn't limited to minor nitpicks, t…

I have no doubt that the team behind Liquid Glass had the same noble motivations as the team behind Microsoft's Metro Design Language in 2010. In a crowded market, making a completely innovative visual identity is often the only option. One hopes that the result is that the words "forward-looking" and "trend-setting" and "loyalty-inspiring" and "inimitable" begin to apply. And if they pull it off, more power to them!…

> I do think that Jobs would have signed off on the motivation behind Liquid Glass. I do not think he would have signed off on Liquid Glass itself.

Agree. Jobs took big swings like Liquid Glass but, perhaps the most important part that’s missing in present Apple, he was obsessive about ensuring the swings were executed to a high standard. He was hands on in this pursuit.

It’s actually weird to me that a company so large, so well compensated, so profitable, so prolific, etc can’t seem to care enough about the details without a Jobs-esque foot on their neck type leader to be afraid of.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#147
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Modern iPhones don't come with a music player. They come with a music store > Modern iPhones don't come with an e-book app. They come with a book store As a Windows person I see these as features, not criticisms. Windows not having good builtin versions of these or other apps is either a cause or effect of there being a robust ecosystem of third-party choices, both open-source and commercial. My frustration with Ap…

Microsoft used to have one of the best media players around! Windows used to have built in streaming support from device to device. You could load up music on your personal PC and play it on your home theater through your Xbox360! Windows Media Player was huge, only eclipsed by Winamp at the time. Eventually MS released the Zune app, which was also awesome but lacked many of the WMP features. (But it looked amazing!)…

Microsoft had so many opportunities that they just failed to execute. How did they miss on everything?

Home servers

Media streaming

Smartphones

Touchscreens

Tablets

They even had media production with MSNBC.

All of this was available from Microsoft in the XP era. How did they fail at literally all of it? There has to be a lesson.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#148
post #75

> From that point on, Steve would go on to spend lavishly on things that improved the experience, and he would reject—often brutally—any idea that diluted or harmed the experience. ...I’ll go out on a limb and say that uninvited advertising is not normally equated with a better customer experience. YES!!! SOO much of the Apple user experience has degraded due to this. I can't listen to my own music that I bought on t…

>> Modern iPhones don't come with a music player. They come with a music store, that you happen to be able to put your own music into. But it's not structured to help you play your music, it's structured to sell you what they want to sell you.

I would have argued against this in the past. But in iOS 26 they introduced the ability to 'pin' 6 favourite playlists or albums to the top of your library. Really useful. If you don't have a subscription (to Apple Music or iTunes Match) you don't get the feature. There is zero reason to do this other than to milk people for more money when they've already spent over $1k on the device and likely spent hundreds purchasing the music from iTunes Store.

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#149
post #75

> From that point on, Steve would go on to spend lavishly on things that improved the experience, and he would reject—often brutally—any idea that diluted or harmed the experience. ...I’ll go out on a limb and say that uninvited advertising is not normally equated with a better customer experience. YES!!! SOO much of the Apple user experience has degraded due to this. I can't listen to my own music that I bought on t…

An iPhone is a vending machine in your pocket.

(owned and operated by Apple, and __you__ paid for it.)

Re: Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line

#150
What's with this uncanny AI Steve Jobs photo? I hope blog writers have red lines too.

The sentiment of this article seems to be praising Jobs as a protector of user experience. And the author doesn't have the decency to use his real face?

Post reply on HN