Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Gifts

facebook.com

21–30 of 119 posts

Re: Facebook Gifts

#21
post #15

Facebook as payment system? I still don't have enough confidence on how secure their system is. Also, sharing home address with them is not a smart move.

It sounds like they should let you update your privacy settings to automatically reject gifts if you dont want to share your address... Something like "sorry, this person is not accepting Facebook Gifts".

Re: Facebook Gifts

#23
"Now you can do something more meaningful" (than a hey, happy birthday call or message). It disappoints me when I hear wording like this, there is nothing more meaningful about paying money for a present that took you two clicks and is probably already part of a pre-selected group of items from their profile/history, than thinking of something to write on their wall in two clicks.

All power to Facebook to make it work though: maybe if they can monetize themselves through means like this they'll pay more attention to privacy issues as they will have less incentive to make everything public for advertising/selling data.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#24
"It's Mary's birthday in 3 days - send her a birthday cupcake?"

I would probably click "yes" if it's Not for every FB 'friend', but there's a 'sufficiently close' threshold where, yes, I'd click that button. Even better if it's day-of fulfillment. And I bet I'm not alone.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#25
post #6

Oooh, now that's the way to get real names + addresses out of people. Neat. It also involves social pressure -- now not giving away your address will mean rejecting a gift.

Not to mention those among us who may have been less than truthful about their birthdates.

I swear, I really was born on 1/1/1970. I'm a epoch baby! Ok, maybe not.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#26

I'm friends with a few people on Facebook who I'd consider to be very popular. 1000+ friends with many guys vying after their attention. Every time they post a picture of themselves it will be hit with 50 likes (mostly from males) in the first hour. I bet these people will be swimming in gifts once it's released.

So the skills one learns pretending to be a female elf in World Of Warcraft will soon let you get real swag.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#27

"It's Mary's birthday in 3 days - send her a birthday cupcake?" I would probably click "yes" if it's Not for every FB 'friend', but there's a 'sufficiently close' threshold where, yes, I'd click that button. Even better if it's day-of fulfillment. And I bet I'm not alone.

Now, instead of just a flood of empty messages on your birthday, you'll get a flood of empty calories, too.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#28

All depends on the quality of the gifts. If they're chintzy, good luck. But if it's quality stuff, cool. It's got to be of a higher level than Zynga was for apps. Facebook would be served best by controlling gift quality with an iron fist. I'm a little skeptical they'll do that, but maybe. This is very cool, though "Friends ... can swap for a different size, flavor or style before the gift ships." Still. Quality. Qua…

As a selected vendor, I must say they do seem focused on quality. I'm clearly biased but the impression I got from the buyer is they're being very picky.

Another thing that will be tricky is separating signal and noise. If I'm buying a birthday gift for my punk rock friend, they shouldn't bother showing me cupcakes and chocolate boxes. Seems like a no-brainer to show me gift options based on his likes.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#29
post #23

"Now you can do something more meaningful" (than a hey, happy birthday call or message). It disappoints me when I hear wording like this, there is nothing more meaningful about paying money for a present that took you two clicks and is probably already part of a pre-selected group of items from their profile/history, than thinking of something to write on their wall in two clicks. All power to Facebook to make it wor…

I'd rather get a message from someone than a cupcake with no personal message any day of the week. When I was a child and I cared more about material objects that the people around me and whether or not they care for me, I would have picked the cupcake. But I don't use Facebook either, so I guess this whole Gift's thing doesn't really apply to me.

Re: Facebook Gifts

#30
post #9

This seems like the entirely wrong thing to optimize. There are so many other opportunities for Facebook to monetize: - group buying around deals, or group buying in general - "Pay by Facebook" Facebook Connect based payment system - Facebook Presence based loyalty programs among many other easier things than gifts. Gifting does not seem like low hanging fruit.

This is fundamentally social and something that pretty much only Facebook can do. I know that there are a lot of companies trying to compete in the loyalty, group buying, and payment platforms.

Yes, but Facebook has a billion users and the ability to make the right relationships with literally every card processor. And, group buying is inherently social. I don't see why these aren't at the top of Facebook's list for things to try.
Post reply on HN