Live data from Hacker News

Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

glipho.com

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#41
post #6

My iPhone 4 feels faster (no benchmarks, maybe it's just the reboot) with iOS6, and I like the shared photo streams. Battery life seems to be largely the same.

Yeah, my 4 feels snappier, but I'm having a hard time working out if it's largely a psychological thing.

I don't believe it is completely psychological. The big area on iOS 5 where I saw lag was the keyboard. A lot of times it would lag a few keys behind and then catch up in a burst. iOS 6 seems to have fixed that, or at least I haven't seen it do that yet.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#42
post #15
post #13

tl;dr: iOS6 makes YouTube disappear, no solution for iPad yet I updated my 3rd gen iPad to iOS6 immediately when the update came out since I wanted to check out if the increase in JavaScript performance is noticeable (it is). However, here's why I regret updating: I've been using the iPad as a second screen on my desk to watch YouTube. After the update, I find that the YouTube icon is missing from its usual place on…

Why don't you use the web version? Works like a charm for me (better than the app ever did), no performance or stability issues, more functionality than the app had, better load times and more choice about video formats. I see no reason for an app, the web version is excellent.

The huge drawback for me is that the web version doesn't even go fullscreen. Seems kind of like pointless design decision.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#43
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why don't you use the web version? Works like a charm for me (better than the app ever did), no performance or stability issues, more functionality than the app had, better load times and more choice about video formats. I see no reason for an app, the web version is excellent.

The huge drawback for me is that the web version doesn't even go fullscreen. Seems kind of like pointless design decision.

Haha! I hadn’t even noticed that. I’m not sure that’s a problem, though. It’s not like I watch movies on YouTube and 16:9 videos use all available space on the screen, so that extra chrome is pretty irrelevant (so irrelevant that I didn’t even notice it).

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#44
The problem for me with the Maps app isn't that it isn't accurate for the few things I tried (turn-by-turn for navigating to/from work & my daughter's preschool), it's for the other things that I might try in the future.

It's an issue of trust. What problems might I run into in the future, when I am in a position where I cannot fall-back on the Safari version of Google Maps? Low/no signal conditions where I am trying to navigate unknown areas are times when I can't have something that is good enough, most of the time. That's why I downgraded to 5.1.1. Google Maps hasn't let me down yet, and there's no reason why I need to upgrade to iOS 6. The new features are only nice-to-haves.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#45
If you live in NYC, hold off. The integration between apple maps and third-party transit apps is anything but seamless. The new Apple map doesn't show the names of the train lines so you can't pan around the map and see "oh, there's the nearest 4/5 stop". Launching a transit app takes too many taps and you have to exit and relaunch maps to get back to it - no longer is it convenient to switch between views of "how long would this take via transit" and "how long would this take in a cab".

On the flip side, there's one GOOD feature in nyc rarely remarked on: Having switched to vector-based maps means you can now pretty reliably pan and zoom the map even when you have no signal because you're in the subway.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#46
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why don't you use the web version? Works like a charm for me (better than the app ever did), no performance or stability issues, more functionality than the app had, better load times and more choice about video formats. I see no reason for an app, the web version is excellent.

The huge drawback for me is that the web version doesn't even go fullscreen. Seems kind of like pointless design decision.

What URL are you using on what device?

On my iPod touch http://YouTube.com redirects to http://m.YouTube.com goes full screen.

It also features a link to a YouTube app 'free in the App Store" :-)

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#47
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the maps thing is unfortunate, but I'm sure it will get better Based on what? The problem in the first place is that this is an insanely hard problem that is in the centre of Google's core competencies (data gathering, search, data munching; all on a ridiculously massive scale). Apple makes hardware and an operating system and some apps for it. Where in that set of core competencies does it indicate they have what…

I think it will get better for two reasons: 1) It's been a black eye for Apple and users are complaining 2) Apple has a lot of money to throw at the problem

Of course it will get better.

The real question is whether it will get better enough, fast enough.

There's certainly a limit to how much Apple will throw (they're not going to empty out their nest-egg to fix this), and throwing money at a problem doesn't always work so well.

In particular, public-transit and in general any "non-car" data is something their maps simply don't seem to even start addressing. This isn't entirely surprising as their data provider, tomtom, is a car-nav company, but it's a huge hole, and one Apple seems to have completely missed.

One of the reasons Google's public-transit directions took so many years to get good is because teasing the necessary data out of the many different regional agencies/companies that have it is a pain-staking and slow process.

The very poor coverage in many countries is presumably because Apple's existing data providers do not have good coverage of them, so Apple probably needs to contract with region-specific providers, integrate their data (which may not be simple) with the Apple maps infrastructure etc.

All of this is doable, but it takes time, maybe years. They really needed to do a lot of this, or at least a convincing chunk of it, before the big release, not "sometime in the future."

Certainly Apple has reasons to make their own maps, but by releasing such core functionality in a form that's very clearly not ready for prime time, they've damaged their (extremely valuable) reputation as "the company that does things right."

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#48
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The huge drawback for me is that the web version doesn't even go fullscreen. Seems kind of like pointless design decision.

What URL are you using on what device? On my iPod touch http://YouTube.com redirects to http://m.YouTube.com goes full screen. It also features a link to a YouTube app 'free in the App Store" :-)

Mobile YouTube on iPad.
Post reply on HN