Live data from Hacker News

Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

glipho.com

11–20 of 52 posts

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#11
post #4

Well, what features do people here think are worth the upgrade? I for one like the new privacy settings. Passbook could be really interesting, but I think it'll be well over a year, before people in my country consider taking advantage of it.

Oddly enough, the one thing that I really love is a much greater willingness to hop off of a weak WiFi network and onto cellular data. With iOS 5, my iPhone would stay on my home network long after I'd moved out of range, often forcing me to manually disable WiFi in order to e.g. get driving directions or listen to music in my car. With iOS 6, this problem is basically gone. It will struggle with WiFi for a few seconds, then give up and disconnect.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#12
post #7

I did, and I'm glad. The maps thing is unfortunate, but I'm sure it will get better. In the mean time you can still use maps.google.com and I'm sure Google will release their own app some day. Bits of the system feel faster, but I can say that Music got a massive speed improvement. I have a playlist of over 5k songs that I like to listen to shuffled. On iOS 5.1, opening that playlist for the first time would take two…

> the maps thing is unfortunate, but I'm sure it will get better

Based on what? The problem in the first place is that this is an insanely hard problem that is in the centre of Google's core competencies (data gathering, search, data munching; all on a ridiculously massive scale). Apple makes hardware and an operating system and some apps for it. Where in that set of core competencies does it indicate they have what it takes to tackle this and yield the quality google has (who have poured a rather large fortune into it (they bought the satellites for google maps so they could reshoot to avoid clouds), the have paid for high tech trucks to run down every road in an increasingly large collection of cities. And then massive human QA teams)

This isn't what apple does and it was massive hubris on their part to think they could tackle this and come anywhere near the level of google maps, or their usual standard of excellence. I remain extremely dubious that there is any "quick" fix to their problem. It's not like the screwed up an algorithm and this is a bug, this is a massive problem that they've barely started to tackle.

If Apple does realize what it's going to take to compete at this and doubles down on it, it's still going to take a year or two for them to catch up. And that's an if. So Apple Maps/iOS5 combo is a write off. Probably iOS6 too. You want good mapping the next few years, stick with google. Maybe after that Apple will have something worth looking at, just as likely maybe not.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#13
tl;dr: iOS6 makes YouTube disappear, no solution for iPad yet

I updated my 3rd gen iPad to iOS6 immediately when the update came out since I wanted to check out if the increase in JavaScript performance is noticeable (it is).

However, here's why I regret updating: I've been using the iPad as a second screen on my desk to watch YouTube. After the update, I find that the YouTube icon is missing from its usual place on the home screen. After a quick app store and Google search I find out the truth: Not only there isn't an official iPad-optimized YouTube app anymore, but also that it has the disappointing release date of "in the coming months" [1].

I know the actual reason for the missing YouTube app has something to do with the licensing deals between Google and Apple, but as a generally happy Apple customer my perception is that this "update" makes my life harder.

[1] http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2012/09/introducing-new-y...

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#14
post #9

I'm guessing the Google Maps app will be out in a month or two. Apple probably won't approve it right away, as a good quality Maps app would really make Google look like the hero, swooping in to save us from Apple's lesser service. Once the response to iOS6 has blown over it'll turn up in the App Store, lots of people will download it, and things will be more or less back to normal (apart from the bruising to Apple's…

Apple already rejected Google Maps in the past in the form of Latitude.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#15
post #13

tl;dr: iOS6 makes YouTube disappear, no solution for iPad yet I updated my 3rd gen iPad to iOS6 immediately when the update came out since I wanted to check out if the increase in JavaScript performance is noticeable (it is). However, here's why I regret updating: I've been using the iPad as a second screen on my desk to watch YouTube. After the update, I find that the YouTube icon is missing from its usual place on…

Why don't you use the web version? Works like a charm for me (better than the app ever did), no performance or stability issues, more functionality than the app had, better load times and more choice about video formats. I see no reason for an app, the web version is excellent.

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#16
post #14
post #9

I'm guessing the Google Maps app will be out in a month or two. Apple probably won't approve it right away, as a good quality Maps app would really make Google look like the hero, swooping in to save us from Apple's lesser service. Once the response to iOS6 has blown over it'll turn up in the App Store, lots of people will download it, and things will be more or less back to normal (apart from the bruising to Apple's…

Apple already rejected Google Maps in the past in the form of Latitude.

Latitude is available for iOS, so that means we should not fear they will reject maps... Right?

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#17
post #14
post #9

I'm guessing the Google Maps app will be out in a month or two. Apple probably won't approve it right away, as a good quality Maps app would really make Google look like the hero, swooping in to save us from Apple's lesser service. Once the response to iOS6 has blown over it'll turn up in the App Store, lots of people will download it, and things will be more or less back to normal (apart from the bruising to Apple's…

Apple already rejected Google Maps in the past in the form of Latitude.

Latitude is already available for iOS. http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/google-latitude/id306586497?m...

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#18
post #9

I'm guessing the Google Maps app will be out in a month or two. Apple probably won't approve it right away, as a good quality Maps app would really make Google look like the hero, swooping in to save us from Apple's lesser service. Once the response to iOS6 has blown over it'll turn up in the App Store, lots of people will download it, and things will be more or less back to normal (apart from the bruising to Apple's…

I was under the impression that any app apple bundled with iOS was supposed to have monopoly and that a similar one wouldn't be approved. Has that changed?

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#19
post #13

tl;dr: iOS6 makes YouTube disappear, no solution for iPad yet I updated my 3rd gen iPad to iOS6 immediately when the update came out since I wanted to check out if the increase in JavaScript performance is noticeable (it is). However, here's why I regret updating: I've been using the iPad as a second screen on my desk to watch YouTube. After the update, I find that the YouTube icon is missing from its usual place on…

Try Jasmine YouTube Client for iOS 6. I'm beginning to think this is better than the previous client.

http://itunes.apple.com/in/app/id554937050?mt=8

Re: Should I download iOS6 for my iPhone4?

#20
post #6

My iPhone 4 feels faster (no benchmarks, maybe it's just the reboot) with iOS6, and I like the shared photo streams. Battery life seems to be largely the same.

Yeah, my 4 feels snappier, but I'm having a hard time working out if it's largely a psychological thing.
Post reply on HN