Live data from Hacker News

OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

github.com

41–50 of 200 posts

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#42
post #22
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> I'm sick of open source purism. > Open source purism - especially for non-viral MIT and BSD licenses - is how Google and Microsoft and Amazon stole from the commons and turned it against us. So why don't you advocate for Free Software which has always worked in the interest of the commons and provided the GPL as a way to combat this, instead of something else that isn't free and restricts the freedom of users more…

Because before your know it your very much open source company called Prusa will end up being competed with by subsidized stuff from the east based on your own work.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#43
post #31

Lawn mowing seems like such a useless thing. I mean domestic lawns themselves, especially in a crisis of biodiversity loss, are such a waste of possibility. I had to stop the video when I saw the mower was going for a patch of clovers, thus reducing plant diversity to a single boring, useless species

„biodiversity“ as in „just let the place rot and get covered by weeds until trees and over stuff planted by you collapse due to the massive-and-aggressiveness of pests and pesty weeds.

a lot of folks don't understand permaculture when they first dive into it and end up in a bad situation. cultivating a pleasing ecosystem is both complicated a lot of work to get right, but eventually it can mostly take care of itself. sadly, traditional gardening doesn't really teach you how to maintain plants in concert or how to passively repel pests. it can be pretty rewarding to learn though if you don't mind getting into the science of it.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#44
post #7

Here's what robotic mowers blades look like to understand how they work - https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/676d76e61268a4... We just got a Sunseeker X7 to do ~4 acres of grassed area but probably ~2 acres will be garden beds and roads etc The hardware is there, it's all software now. People talk about updates and the robot improved amazingly, comments like - "these scuffs are from pre-update" These are E…

Please don't run them at night to protect animals like hedgehogs and others that are active at night.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#45

I have been dreaming of small solar robots that quietly trim the grass all day. Static blades pulled across the grass in short bursts. RC orchestration guided by security cameras.

You cannot just trim grass all day unless you want a terrible lawn. You need to cut at the right hours.

I’m not sure what your criteria is, but mine is to keep the grass alive and provide root structure for my soil.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#46
post #13
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's simply not open source. It doesn't meet the definition. It's co-opting the term to call it open source. This has been debated and settled. What people mean by open source or free software has a well agreed upon definition, and this isn't it.

Open source has been turned against us and used to build hyperscalers that effectively control modern computing. Pure open source is also not a sustainable business model. You have to be open core or non-commercial, otherwise anyone and everyone can steal your lunch. You're asking for the right to compete when they've given you every other single right there is. That's just not nice.

> Open source has been turned against us and used to build hyperscalers that effectively control modern computing.

> Pure open source is also not a sustainable business model. You have to be open core or non-commercial, otherwise anyone and everyone can steal your lunch.

Maybe, but beside the point. The point is "don't call whatever you're doing open source if it isn't open source (per the generally accepted definition which you can read e.g. at https://opensourcedefinition.org/ )". No moral judgement here whether open source is morally superior or not, or whether open source is for suckers because the hyperscalers will co-opt it, or whatever. If you don't want to do open source, then don't, but don't go and call it open source.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#47
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I'm sick of open source purism. > Open source purism - especially for non-viral MIT and BSD licenses - is how Google and Microsoft and Amazon stole from the commons and turned it against us. So why don't you advocate for Free Software which has always worked in the interest of the commons and provided the GPL as a way to combat this, instead of something else that isn't free and restricts the freedom of users more…

Because before your know it your very much open source company called Prusa will end up being competed with by subsidized stuff from the east based on your own work.

I don't belive in "open source", I believe in free software.

So what? They make something better, so I take what they did and improve my product.

It's not my problem if someone from the Big Red East does something with my work as long as they share it too.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#49
post #7

Here's what robotic mowers blades look like to understand how they work - https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/676d76e61268a4... We just got a Sunseeker X7 to do ~4 acres of grassed area but probably ~2 acres will be garden beds and roads etc The hardware is there, it's all software now. People talk about updates and the robot improved amazingly, comments like - "these scuffs are from pre-update" These are E…

My father just picked up a Husqvarna 430x to do his yard, and it's a pretty great piece of equipment. It runs basically around the clock and handles his acre on a hillside with relative ease... It finds a couple of the garden beds a bit tricky to navigate, but that'll be a software issue that likely improves as time goes on.

Re: OpenMower – An open source lawn mower

#50
post #8

Two discussions about Larry Ellison battling it out for 14th and 15th place: 14. An IRC-Enabled Lawn Mower (idlerpg.net) 15. OpenMower – An Open Source Lawn Mower (github.com/clemenselflein)

You wouldn't anthropomorphize a lawn mower would you?

Unexpected bcantrill.
Post reply on HN