Live data from Hacker News

Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

spacenews.com

121–130 of 799 posts

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is no myth. Both Trump and Elon have generational talent in their respective domains. This is the kind of talent that’s so unique, it creates its own domain that didn’t exist before, and that no one will be able to replicate after. But they’re both unstable, and have many other negative features. One can have an extraordinary talent in starting generational companies, and have a social media addiction (among po…

> Both Trump and Elon have generational talent in their respective domains That's an interesting way of saying they were born into a wealthy family

I was also born into a wealthy family but I haven't created multiple billion dollar companies.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#122
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have absolutely no sympathy for Musk but the president--any president--shouldnt be able to do this.

The biggest self-indictment in that post by POTUS was "I was always surprised Biden didn't do it!" I am not surprised that Biden didn't cancel all SpaceX contracts for political reasons, neither are most rational people.

Trump doesn't believe that smart people with power can have ethics or morality because he doesn't have them himself.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#123
post #73

It's wild that a president can say, "I don't like Elon anymore, so out of retaliation, I'm canceling all his government contracts," and ~40% of the country doesn't see that as corruption in any way, shape, or form. Government contracts should not be based on whether or not the president likes the CEO, and the CEO says enough good things about the president. If you can cancel contacts not based on merit, then it shoul…

6 of the people who think all this is completely fine are Supreme Court justices. All of this is enabled by the completely illegitimate Supreme Court decision that made the president a god-king by inventing out of thin air the concept of "presidential immunity". Not only is the scope of "official duties" so broad to make prosseuction next to impossible but the majority went out of its way to say you can't even examin…

It was not out of thin air. There's a reason why the impeachment process is in the Constitution -- and why it's perfectly normal for countries to have Parliamental Immunity and processes quite similar to the US impeachment for government ministers.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#124

It's wild that a president can say, "I don't like Elon anymore, so out of retaliation, I'm canceling all his government contracts," and ~40% of the country doesn't see that as corruption in any way, shape, or form. Government contracts should not be based on whether or not the president likes the CEO, and the CEO says enough good things about the president. If you can cancel contacts not based on merit, then it shoul…

On the positive side, Trump is so unstable that he'll trash your business one day and then the next day he'll reverse course. So, "if people kiss your ass enough, they get contract" does not seem to be a long-term viable strategy. (Exhibit A: Musk.) I'm 90% sure it will lead to America's ruin, but it might not quite be the same path that led the USSR to ruin. Hey, at least it looks more entertaining! :/

> Hey, at least it looks more entertaining! :/

The revolution wouldn't have been televised but the polycrisis will be live streamed.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Usually this comes towards the end of a dictatorship. It doesn't seem that way to me, e.g. Putin arrested Khodorkovsky (the richest man in Russia) in 2003. The way I see it, the politician needs the oligarch's money to gain political power, but then he has actual state power, including guns and the judicial system. At that point the oligarch has no purpose -- after all, the politician can just make new ones -- so i…

> If Elon thought he was buying the presidency in exchange for favors, he wasn't thinking things through. This is the funniest part to me, in the context of THIS president. The guy that demands fully loyalty but gives none? I can't imagine being the richest guy in the world, and embarrassing myself to such a degree all for.. what? He paid maybe $300M to help elect the guy, wore all the stupid hates, lavished orange m…

Everyone who consorts with Trump ends up covered in shit.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#126
post #73

It's wild that a president can say, "I don't like Elon anymore, so out of retaliation, I'm canceling all his government contracts," and ~40% of the country doesn't see that as corruption in any way, shape, or form. Government contracts should not be based on whether or not the president likes the CEO, and the CEO says enough good things about the president. If you can cancel contacts not based on merit, then it shoul…

6 of the people who think all this is completely fine are Supreme Court justices. All of this is enabled by the completely illegitimate Supreme Court decision that made the president a god-king by inventing out of thin air the concept of "presidential immunity". Not only is the scope of "official duties" so broad to make prosseuction next to impossible but the majority went out of its way to say you can't even examin…

This contract dispute has nothing to do with Presidential immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts. Cancelling SpaceX contracts for political reasons would be wrong but not criminal.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#127
post #78
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. It's also wild that someone who was a major contributor to the election campaign and a major advisor to the president now declares "well, the president is a pedophile" and nobody bats an eye either. I mean, Musk supporters now have to believe Musk knowingly supported a pedophile but only turned against him after he had a falling out for unrelated reasons? In the eyes of his supporters, what does this say abou…

Musk is a known pedophile-accusation-maker and affiliated with the Epstein child rape organization through his Kung-Fu lessons with Ghislaine Maxwell. Prior supporters will be less reactive for the first reason and more likely to perceive the situations as unfounded petty accusations for the latter (the dissonance of both Trump and Musk being connected to child rape is resolved this way).

Trump/Epstein connections have been reported on for years with photos and videos so anyone who cares probably was already on the anti-Trump side.

While Musk has a bigger megaphone than most media, he also has a credibility issue - and now especially for the Trump-true-believer crowd that is likely the only group whose bubble would be so shielded that they'd see it as news.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#128

It's wild that a president can say, "I don't like Elon anymore, so out of retaliation, I'm canceling all his government contracts," and ~40% of the country doesn't see that as corruption in any way, shape, or form. Government contracts should not be based on whether or not the president likes the CEO, and the CEO says enough good things about the president. If you can cancel contacts not based on merit, then it shoul…

On the positive side, Trump is so unstable that he'll trash your business one day and then the next day he'll reverse course. So, "if people kiss your ass enough, they get contract" does not seem to be a long-term viable strategy. (Exhibit A: Musk.) I'm 90% sure it will lead to America's ruin, but it might not quite be the same path that led the USSR to ruin. Hey, at least it looks more entertaining! :/

> he'll trash your business one day and then the next day he'll reverse course

TACO, as the saying goes.

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#129
post #78
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. It's also wild that someone who was a major contributor to the election campaign and a major advisor to the president now declares "well, the president is a pedophile" and nobody bats an eye either. I mean, Musk supporters now have to believe Musk knowingly supported a pedophile but only turned against him after he had a falling out for unrelated reasons? In the eyes of his supporters, what does this say abou…

Musk is a known pedophile-accusation-maker and affiliated with the Epstein child rape organization through his Kung-Fu lessons with Ghislaine Maxwell. Prior supporters will be less reactive for the first reason and more likely to perceive the situations as unfounded petty accusations for the latter (the dissonance of both Trump and Musk being connected to child rape is resolved this way).

Not only that but Musk was able to successfully argue in court that he's such a well known liar that a reasonable person wouldn't take his accusations of pedophillia seriously

Re: Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts

#130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The biggest self-indictment in that post by POTUS was "I was always surprised Biden didn't do it!" I am not surprised that Biden didn't cancel all SpaceX contracts for political reasons, neither are most rational people.

Trump doesn't believe that smart people with power can have ethics or morality because he doesn't have them himself.

It's not ethics or morality, it's just "not being a child." A president not personally retaliating against a critic doesn't need to have anything to do with ethics, it's just requires a post-middle-school mentality of "I may not be happy with this person but I [my country] can still benefit from things they do."
Post reply on HN