Live data from Hacker News

Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

es.wired.com

91–100 of 190 posts

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#91

You people are too good at critical thinking to read "an investment of 500 million euros between 2025 and 2027" and not instantly write this off as empty grandstanding. How much does—or did, recently—the United States federal government invest in scientists in the USA? Is it ~$70 billion a year? [0] Europe can achieve America's (past) results when Europe starts talking with money. Science migration has historically g…

This is not EU R&D budget. This is a small delta, extra funding specifically for attracting US scientists who are looking to move. Comparing this to the total expenditure by the US federal government seems...odd. I asked ChatGPT: "Combining both EU-level and national R&D expenditures, the total R&D spending across the EU in 2023 was approximately €505 billion." But that appears to be total, both government and indust…

> I asked ChatGPT

irony alert

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#92
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ok, so did you verify the 500 billion? If so, then that's really the relevant part for me. But then I trust you, not Chatgpt.

Where did you take the 500 billion figure from?

It's from the chatgpt quote my comment was an comment to: "[...] in 2023 was approximately €505 billion"

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#93
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where did you take the 500 billion figure from?

It's from the chatgpt quote my comment was an comment to: "[...] in 2023 was approximately €505 billion"

Thanks.

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#94

500 million for attracting the best academia is why Europe is a has-been and will continue to remain a has-been. The actual number should have been 50 billion, but Europe would rather spend that on consultants, policythinkers and thoughtleaders.

Actually most of Europe is spending it on subsidies for retirees and other people that prefer not to earn (or at least declare) any income.

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#95
post #41
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think that's perhaps -- perhaps! -- true of US citizens who live in the US and have seen their research funding evaporate. I'm not a scientist, but if my job prospects in the US started getting really grim, I would still have a hard time leaving my home to work elsewhere. But I'd probably at least consider it. But non-citizens, especially those who are being pushed to self-deport (or worse)...? I feel like somethin…

Hello, the self deport is for illegal aliens. There is no concern for who is in the USA with a valid visa to do science. In fact, the longest scientists and highly qualified people from Europe had to wait for a green card was under the Obama administration.

So much funding is being paused and cut though, who's to say if your field of study will still have federal funding in 1,2,4 years? This lack of funding stability is making US academia way less appealing.

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is not EU R&D budget. This is a small delta, extra funding specifically for attracting US scientists who are looking to move. Comparing this to the total expenditure by the US federal government seems...odd. I asked ChatGPT: "Combining both EU-level and national R&D expenditures, the total R&D spending across the EU in 2023 was approximately €505 billion." But that appears to be total, both government and indust…

I think that the US strongly outperforms the EU by that metric too, https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20246/cross-national-compariso... ( "Cross-National Comparisons of R&D Performance" (2024)) In the NSF's specific definition, the US greatly outspends the EU even normalizing by GDP—3.46% of GDP in the USA, against 2.16% in the EU-27. (Notably, China also recently surpassed the EU, at 2.43%).

[deleted]

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#97

You people are too good at critical thinking to read "an investment of 500 million euros between 2025 and 2027" and not instantly write this off as empty grandstanding. How much does—or did, recently—the United States federal government invest in scientists in the USA? Is it ~$70 billion a year? [0] Europe can achieve America's (past) results when Europe starts talking with money. Science migration has historically g…

This is not EU R&D budget. This is a small delta, extra funding specifically for attracting US scientists who are looking to move. Comparing this to the total expenditure by the US federal government seems...odd. I asked ChatGPT: "Combining both EU-level and national R&D expenditures, the total R&D spending across the EU in 2023 was approximately €505 billion." But that appears to be total, both government and indust…

For the love of everything, CHATGPT IS NOT A PRIMARY SOURCE. Always assume every fact it spits out is made up.

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#98

You people are too good at critical thinking to read "an investment of 500 million euros between 2025 and 2027" and not instantly write this off as empty grandstanding. How much does—or did, recently—the United States federal government invest in scientists in the USA? Is it ~$70 billion a year? [0] Europe can achieve America's (past) results when Europe starts talking with money. Science migration has historically g…

This is not EU R&D budget. This is a small delta, extra funding specifically for attracting US scientists who are looking to move. Comparing this to the total expenditure by the US federal government seems...odd. I asked ChatGPT: "Combining both EU-level and national R&D expenditures, the total R&D spending across the EU in 2023 was approximately €505 billion." But that appears to be total, both government and indust…

> I asked ChatGPT:

Funny I asked it about your info and it says it has discrepancies. :-))

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#99
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's about money and everything else too. US is a really nice country to live in for high skilled individuals. An immigrant nation who speaks the international language, a fast growing economy, especially in cutting edge tech, with overall taxes lower than Europe and even the housing market crisis is not at bad as what you will encounter in many European cities. And its huge so for a lot of emigrants looking for a ne…

Don't most people in Denmark - and pretty much all Nordic countries - speak English?

People of working age, pretty much yes. Elderly people might not.

Re: Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US

#100
post #22

Europe does every thing except the only needed thing, paying up. Not just for this, same for finding startups, helping Ukraine or Palestine.

- Europe has spent more on Ukraine than the US. - Europe has, sadly, also been the main sender of aid to, effectively, Hamas. I wish they would stop.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN