Live data from Hacker News

Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

waymo.com

351–360 of 397 posts

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#351

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This Mark Rober video has been debunked several times: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TzZhIsGFL6g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7cxTO8g47_k

That is not a debunking... That's someone running a similar experiment and getting a different result. That would debunk the claim that Teslas can never detect a painted wall. It does not debunk the claim that Teslas will sometimes fail to detect a painted wall. And in a safety-critical system, the distinction is not mere pedantry.

I mean he didn't even use FSD.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#352

no thanks. I like the fact that I drive MY car. I don't want a sass service dictating where I can and can't go or how fast i can get there.

> or how fast i can get there.

I sure do, because it sounds like you aren't driving at safe speeds, and I'd like you to not hit me with your car please.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#353

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, we should also realize that they've been super wildly successful at getting people to move towards clean energy vehicles. Prius is the world's highest selling Hybrid car, and it's been that for more than a decade now. This means Toyota has helped cut down emissions from consumer automobiles by a significant degree. It's not the 1000 EVs out of the 100k vehicles that matter, but rather the 10k hybrid vehicle…

Up until recently (~2022/23) Toyota had cumulatively sold more hybrids than all EVs sold by all manufacturers combined, globally. They arguably have the best hybrid drivetrain on the market, and it's gotten to the point where even the Camry (2025 onwards) are exclusively offered as hybrids now.

That sounds more impressive than it is actual savings from hybrids is vastly less than EV’s and the ramp up has been extremely quick.

Combined mileage from many hybrid power trains is only ~10% better, and the technology inherently adds significant costs/complexity.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#354
post #353

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Up until recently (~2022/23) Toyota had cumulatively sold more hybrids than all EVs sold by all manufacturers combined, globally. They arguably have the best hybrid drivetrain on the market, and it's gotten to the point where even the Camry (2025 onwards) are exclusively offered as hybrids now.

That sounds more impressive than it is actual savings from hybrids is vastly less than EV’s and the ramp up has been extremely quick. Combined mileage from many hybrid power trains is only ~10% better, and the technology inherently adds significant costs/complexity.

They were not getting 45 mpg without hybrid…

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#355
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is their beef with full-EV? First it was hydrogen fuel cells and now limitation to hybrid. Seems odd at best.

I suspect it's that they build excellent ICE vehicles, and were quick to go to hybrids but missed the rise of EVs. Everything we're seeing is a rearguard action to protect their ICE business.

Funny enough they produced an electric Rav 4 as far back as 1997! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_RAV4_EV

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#356

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having a nuclear disaster only decade ago with a flurry of other plants that couldn't pass the safety test when re-checked creates a pretty tough situation. Right now there's a plant that is stopped by the gov from getting back into production for safety issues, with the elec company trying to appeal for the nth time, and it sure doesn't help the overall image. "This time it will be fine" is kinda hard to stomach for…

They have no other sustainable energy sources a d frankly I trust japanese engineering minds they can fix their nuclear designs

It's always been surprising to me that they don't have more geothermal power generation. Seems liked they should be well-positioned for that.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#357
post #353

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That sounds more impressive than it is actual savings from hybrids is vastly less than EV’s and the ramp up has been extremely quick. Combined mileage from many hybrid power trains is only ~10% better, and the technology inherently adds significant costs/complexity.

They were not getting 45 mpg without hybrid…

There isn’t a non hybrid version of the Prius with all its weight and aerodynamic features.

But there’s ~45 MPG all gas cars that have been built. Currently the best option is 39MPG combined, but that car’s aerodynamics aren’t great because hybrids can push that a little further for people who really want maximum MPG.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#358

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Adaptive cruise control could do that too. How impressive it is depends on where you live.

Do you even drive? Or have you tried using any of the features discussed above. I think I’m going insane seeing people comparing cruise control (lol) to FSD. One is a line follower, the other is a teenage driver with a fresh license. They’re not the same.

Oh please, just because it can do (bad, sometimes horribly dangerous) turns doesn't mean that 99.9% of the time it's not just a glorified cruise control with lane centering.

I owned a Model 3 with FSD. I own a Mach-E with BlueCruise. They're equivalent for the majority of drives I've done.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#359
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except there’s FSD videos everywhere on X with every minor release, demonstrating the progress.

There's now a thing called "FSD", yes. But it's not FSD as in Full Self-Driving, as in L4. It's still an L3, the driver still needs to be at the wheel and paying attention. "Full Self Driving" implies L4. What Waymo has, with no one at the wheel, is L4.

FSD is Level 2. The driver must, at all times, be supervising the car. L3 implies that the car, in exceptionally ideal and limited circumstances, takes over full control unsupervised.

Even if you were to take Mobileye's definitions, it would still be equivalent to other companies at best (hands off, eyes on).

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#360
post #267

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re driving. Why you can’t watch a movie like you can on a Mercedes L3 car.

The ODD for drive pilot is so limited, I don’t think it’s really comparable. I have very little faith that their approach will scale to anything more than a traffic jam pilot gimmick. It’s fair to argue that FSD is limited as well but I believe their approach is much more scalable.

FSD is not approved to work on any street. Drive Pilot is approved for highway speeds in EU. Limitations is what the government allows.
Post reply on HN