Live data from Hacker News

Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

servethehome.com

141–150 of 415 posts

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#141

I have some sympathy for this. With the disasters of the WD 'Green' series and the recent revelations on how used disks were being sold for new. Synology doesn't want to be lumped with other companies problems. They really have to sell it by minimising the price differential and reducing the lead time.

And SMR sold as NAS drives mostly.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have a plan on what you’re going to move to? I’ve used (and still use) UnRaid before but switched to Synology for my data a while back due to both the plug-and-play nature of their systems (it’s been rock solid for me) and easily accessible hard drive trays. I’ve built 3 UnRaid servers and while I like the software, hardware was always an issue for me. I’d love a 12-bay-style Synology hardware device that I co…

I haven't used them personally so I can't vouch for them, but UGREEN's NAS line is the same form factor as a Synology unit, but it lets you run any OS. I'd probably put straight Debian on mine and handle it all manually as I do now. I wouldn't be surprised if you could put Unraid on it.

Pretty sure Asustor also allows installing any other Linux you want.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#143
post #4

Storing encrypted blobs in S3 is my new strategy for bulk media storage. You'll never beat the QoS and resilience of the cloud storage product with something at home. I have completely lost patience with maintaining local hardware like this. If no one has a clue what is inside your blobs, they might as well not exist from their perspective. This feels like smuggling cargo on a federation starship, which is way cooler…

> You'll never beat the QoS and resilience of the cloud storage product with something at home.

You can’t be serious.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#144
post #112
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>You’re really best off not trying to lump together your Plex server and your NAS on the same box. Why not? If you are not going to do transcoding, Plex should sit fine on a NAS.

Basically an archaic idea that a NAS has to be only good at one thing which is just file sharing. It's hard to actually buy a computer that bad these days, although Synology still makes it easy lol.

Tbh another archaic idea is that you need to transcode.

All you need is one of those sticks that plug into the hdmi of your tv and can run vlc. I use a chromecast. Vlc can play mkvs directly off samba shares. Done.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#146

I currently run 2 Synology NAS's in my setup. I am very satisfied with their performance, but nevertheless I will be phasing them out because their offerings are not evolving in line with customer satisfaction but with profit maximization through segmentation and vertical lock-in.

Do you have a plan on what you’re going to move to? I’ve used (and still use) UnRaid before but switched to Synology for my data a while back due to both the plug-and-play nature of their systems (it’s been rock solid for me) and easily accessible hard drive trays. I’ve built 3 UnRaid servers and while I like the software, hardware was always an issue for me. I’d love a 12-bay-style Synology hardware device that I co…

I've been mostly happy with a Terrmaster DAS attached to a mini PC running UnRaid. The bays are hotswappable and overall it's been solid.

I say "mostly" happy because I almost returned it. The USB connection between mini PC and Terramaster would be fine for a few days and then during intense operations like parity checks would disconnect and look like parity error/disk failure, except the disks were fine. Eventually realised the DAS uses power from the USB port as well as the adapter plug and the mini PC wasn't supplying enough power. Since attaching a powered USB hub it's been perfect.

Explanation of symptoms and solution, in case anyone is considering one or has the same problem: https://forum.terra-master.com/en/viewtopic.php?t=5830

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#147
post #137
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just keep in mind that Intel is keeping the total PCIe bandwidth out of those CPUs very constrained on purpose.

The best solution in my opinion is to buy 5y old, used, server motherboards and CPUs (like AMD Epyc 3 right now). They are fairly cheap, it is durable products designed to work 24/7, and it comes with a huge number of PCIe lanes and extensibility. Same with enterprise SSDs for home usage, which is usually very little write. A used enterprise SSDs with a ton of endurance and very little writes is probably the best ban…

Power consumption is at a completely different level, though. The N100 gives you pretty good performance with very low power draw.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#148
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Basically an archaic idea that a NAS has to be only good at one thing which is just file sharing. It's hard to actually buy a computer that bad these days, although Synology still makes it easy lol.

Tbh another archaic idea is that you need to transcode. All you need is one of those sticks that plug into the hdmi of your tv and can run vlc. I use a chromecast. Vlc can play mkvs directly off samba shares. Done.

TBH the only reason anyone talks about transcoding is Synology's absolute dog-shit hardware options make it a problem. Most Intel CPUs and most AMD CPUs and many ARM CPUs and all the discrete GPUs are absolutely fine with munging video and audio codecs. They're just not well-represented in Synology's lineup.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#149

Good. Will stop collègues from buying that crap. Managing an aging fleet of those is a PITA. Why bother with a crippled Linux, if a full-blown, real OS is available on better hardware anyway.

Full blown OS is a valid option, but installing and maintaining a full blown OS with the equivalent of their ecosystem apps is more complex and time consuming. Some will consider that a PITA and that audience likely isn't bothered by a crippled Linux.

Re: Synology Lost the Plot with Hard Drive Locking Move

#150
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

20TB isn't all that much anymore, especially if you do anything like filming, streaming, photography, etc. Even a handful of HQ TV shows can reach several TB rather quickly.

Additionally, 20TB is only going to run you $300-400 for a consumer drive.

It's wild consumer drives are so much more expensive than enterprise Exos drives with better performance, reliability and warranty
Post reply on HN