Live data from Hacker News

Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

browsercraft.cheerpj.com

101–107 of 107 posts

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#101
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The longevity of Minecraft blows my mind. I was always aware of its existence but never looked into it. Now my kid is getting into it. So many generations of kids! It's incredible really. That said, it has been a little sad digging into the current state of Java vs Bedrock, Bedrock iPad vs Bedrock Switch. The platform ubiquity is wonderful and the tradeoffs are what they are. But if folks were able to create a touch-…

The children yearn for the mines, apparently.

Also, Minecraft is like a gateway drug into Factorio. Dangerous stuff!

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#102
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The fact I'm playing this at 20 FPS on Firefox with a RX 7600 Vanilla Minecraft is known for being awful for FPS even outside of a browser. There's a reason most people use a whole slate of performance mods just to get actual decent performance. (I've got a Ryzen 7 with a 3080 and it would frequently hover between 40-50fps even with graphics turned down. Install the performance mods and I can get >120fps with fancy…

A longstanding performance effecting bug was fixed in the recently released 1.21.5 and the difference is night and day at least for vanilla clients. This one: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC/issues/MC-170134 I now never see below 60 fps when for all my years of playing this bug would bring down my FPS to the teens or 0 all the time no matter what hardware.

> A longstanding performance effecting bug was fixed in the recently released 1.21.5

Good to know that they're finally considering performance fixes but obviously involves moving to 1.21.5 and until there's mods to disable the bits I don't like, I'll be sticking with 1.20+mods.

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#103
post #6

Huh, is Minecraft Java edition free now? I haven't played in a long time but I thought when you download the regular client you only get to play after signing in with an account that purchased the game, how is this thing just starting the game directly?

You could always play Minecraft without an account. But you can't join most servers that enable authentication checks

Ah cool I didn't know, I thought the download of the actual full client was gated behind a login since even third party launchers seemed to require you to log in to play, good to know!

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#104
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Start with suing the minecraft wiki then I guess Also you should probably advice mojang to put some authentication on their download URLs, which have been publicly documented for more than a decade by now. There is no login prompt. This project is over a year old. You are just misinterpreting the situation. This is like threatening to sue Mozilla because you can use Firefox to click on a download button, or Microsoft…

... no, it is not like that, and I can't help you.

Good thing no one is asking you for "help". You're the one threatening FUD without anyone asking for it. Go bother someone else with your nonsense, lol.

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#105
post #49

There's also Eaglercraft, which achieves the same result, but it has functioning multiplayer, and runs up to version 1.8.9, though you'll need a beefy computer.

This looks amazing! Both Eaglercraft and Browsercraft (though Eaglercraft seems to be further along) — the closest realization to the dream I've had for years of running a fully-featured Minecraft in the browser. Quite promising, I can only wonder where these projects will end up as they develop further, wishing for the best...!

Why is this so exciting to me? I started playing Minecraft back in the Java modding days, which really picked up steam around 1.2.5 and, by my estimations, peaked around 1.7.10. There was a veritable cornucopia of mods widely available, to enhance the game in a plethora of ways. I modded my game so hard I undoubtedly ran more third-party code than first-party/Mojang. Minecraft was a platform for creative expression, freeform and unconstrained. The golden age of Minecraft modding!

But it wasn't all unicorns and rainbows. There was a dark side of modding: the ease of use, or lack thereof in getting mods setup. Modpacks helped, but you still had to run untrusted code, and you still had to have a compatible PC. This is what (nearly) killed Minecraft for me. I wanted to play with my friend, but his PC had Windows upgraded and lost Java or OpenGL compatibility, and he eventually dropped his desktop and switched to tablets, phones, and consoles. My highly curated developed modded technical world became inaccessible.

Contrast this unfortunate situation with the browser: with "load and go" functionality as Douglas Crockford calls it, you can just visit a website and play, provided sufficient specs. What if we could play modded Minecraft (preferably 1.7.10), with all the mods to our hearts content, right in the browser, accessible to anyone?! And anyone could develop and distribute their own mods without concern, being safely executed within the browser sandbox.

I don't know how close Eaglercraft is to this utopia, but I find the possibility very enticing.

Re: Browsercraft: Java Minecraft in the browser

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a very funny story behind MinecraftForFree.com which is what most people used back then. Notch (the creator of minecraft) was angry someone was posting his game online for free. He emailed the owner, Dylan, of the site threatening legal action. Instead of going down a legal route, Dylan challenged him play a game of quake3 to settle the dispute. If notch won, Dylan would take the site down. If Dylan won, notc…

> If Dylan won, notch would would leave him alone and let him keep hosting the site. Small correction, Dylan always planned to take the site down. They were playing for Minecraft capes[0] for him and his two teammates. The original livestream of the match is still up on Twitch also.[1] [0] Cosmetics that used to be very rare and only given out by devs or at MineCon [1] https://twitch.tv/videos/38469359

Thank you for the correction! The story is basically minecraft folklore, so the details get exaggerated.
Post reply on HN