Live data from Hacker News

U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

theatlantic.com

981–990 of 1001 posts

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#981
post #865

How is trump staff using signal for classified military actions different from Clinton use of private email account ? Back then he said she should be put in jail but now he is downplaying it. How can Americans take this guy seriously is beyond my mind.

For whatever reason norms/laws just don’t apply to Trump. He’s above the law; it’s baffling.

It's not baffling. He just thinks that laws don't apply to him.

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#982
post #865

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For whatever reason norms/laws just don’t apply to Trump. He’s above the law; it’s baffling.

It's not baffling. He just thinks that laws don't apply to him.

To be fair the Supreme Court just gave him an out to all but the most heinous crimes conducted as "official acts". He can do almost anything he wants and not worry about going to prison, and he can pardon all of his underlings.

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#983
post #629

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which do you think is more likely to be under foreign control and why? Bearing in mind that iPhones are made in China.

stock iPhones run 100% Apple software, afaik. from drivers to the shell it's one company. the hardware is one series of models by one company. each Android vendor has a completely random fork of AOSP with who knows what kernel patches, out-of-tree drivers, unremovable apps and customizations. you're trusting an enchilada of your mobile carrier, Google, Samsung/OnePlus/whoever, plus all their vendors. Android can be h…

> stock iPhones run 100% Apple software, afaik. from drivers to the shell it's one company. the hardware is one series of models by one company.

> each Android vendor has a completely random fork of AOSP with who knows what kernel patches, out-of-tree drivers, unremovable apps and customizations. you're trusting an enchilada of your mobile carrier, Google, Samsung/OnePlus/whoever, plus all their vendors.

That cuts both ways though. Any exploit for iPhone works on a lot of high value targets. An exploit for one android phone may well not apply to another. If we're talking about state actors, well, probably both are compromised, but the iPhone would be the priority IMO.

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#984
post #717

I'm an external individual to the US, but I must admit that some of the sentiments being expressed here in this thread and elsewhere about the lack of accountability deeply concern me, it reminds me of many things I saw growing up and still see today in south asia. Independent of anything else, I do see the overton window shifting in the US, the most subtle of which are norms and expectations around acts of corruptio…

I'm already feeling like entrepreneurship is out the window.

It's a combination of AI being owned from these mega corporations and corruption at the highest level that I'm losing sight of what is the purpose building my startup business in an authoritarian landscape.

Trump illegally promoting Elon's corporation with a yard sale, kissing his feet for donating millions to his campaign thanks to citizens united, allowing him to ransack the federal government as an unelected official, to making vandalism a domestic terrorist act for people fed up when him,and now putting Elon in charge of investigating Signalgate.

People need to stand up now before they cannot.

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#985
post #947
post #937

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> There’s a vulnerability in Signal where you can set up linked devices that replicate your signal messages. You mean the desktop linking feature? If that's considered a vulnerability, then so is being able to chat with someone after getting their public key unverified from an overseas server, the primary mode in which everyone uses it (including the people in this chat, evidently, since no out-of-band key exchange w…

If you're part of the US government, with access to the most sensitive information which will put people's lives at risk if compromised, then yes this is a vulnerability because "russian GRU agent nicks your phone and scans your signal QR code" is a real threat.

Bringing in a phone with decryption keys for this conversation is a risk, then, not just Signal's featureset...

I agree it could be hardening to allow users/organizations to disable this feature, and also other features such as automatic media decoding and other mechanisms that are trade-offs between security and usability, but simply does not meet the definition of a vulnerability (nobody will assign this a CVE number to track the bug and "resolve" it)

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#987
post #758

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you honestly think that (a) Trump's Justice Department would prosecute any of these offenses, and (b) even if so, that Trump wouldn't just pardon anyone involved?

The corruption is now, total and absolute. A complete Nero Court like the decadent days of the end of the Roman Empire. "Trump’s crypto empire set to expand with new stablecoin and investment fund offerings" - https://apnews.com/article/trump-crypto-world-liberty-truth-... "...Witkoff and his father, Trump’s special diplomatic envoy Steve Witkoff, helped launch World Liberty Financial with Trump and his sons last yea…

Just a nitpick: Nero was nowhere close to "the end of the Roman Empire".

Re: U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat

#988

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The real test will be the midterms.

is it though? the senate has been ~50-50 for a decade straight and every 2 years this same algorithm fueled coping mechanism resurfaces for some partisan recovery (newsflash - the other side believes the same thing, no matter which side you're reading this from), and there is zero - and diminishing - data to lean upon for anything different to happen except every demographic in this country drifting right for a 53 se…

Ehhh, I meant there's a non zero chance you guys aren't getting free elections, with plausible deniability of course. He tried before, maybe Trump achieves it this time.
Post reply on HN