Live data from Hacker News

Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

qwenlm.github.io

111–120 of 303 posts

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#111
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

32B don't fully fit 16GB of VRAM. Still fine for higher quality answers, worth the extra wait in some cases.

Would a 40GB A6000 fully accommodate a 32B model? I assume an fp16 quantization is still necessary?

You don't need 16-bit quantization. The difference in accuracy from 8-bit in most models is less than 5%.

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#114
Has anyone successfully run a quantized version of any of the Qwen2.5-VL series of models?

I've run the smallest model in non-quantized format, but when I've tried to run a AWQ version of one of the bigger models I've struggled to find a combination of libraries that works right - even though it should fit on my GPU.

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#115
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At FP16 you‘d need 64GB just for the weights, and it‘d be 2x as slow as a Q8 version, likely with little improvement. You‘ll also need space for attention and context etc, so 80-100GB (or even more) VRAM would be better. Many people „just“ use 4x consumer GPUs like the 3090 (24GB each) which scales well. They’d probably buy a mining rig, EPYC CPU, Mainboard with sufficient PCIe lanes, PCIe risers, 1600W PSU (might ne…

I haven't found a good case/risers/etc I really like. Most the miner stuff wasn't made for PCIe 16x.

Is that a problem? According to this, the GPUs don’t communicate that much once the weights are loaded: https://github.com/turboderp/exllama/discussions/16#discussi...

> So at FP16 precision that's a grand total of 16 kB you're transmitting over the PCIe bus, once per token. If you multiply by, say, 20 tokens per second, then you're still only using like 0.1% of your PCIe bandwidth.

Intra GPU memory bandwidth is very important, but I‘ve seen lots of people use just a x4 lane and they didn’t complain much.

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are there any good sources that I can read up on estimiating what would be hardware specs required for 7B, 13B, 32B .. etc size If I need to run them locally? I am grad student on budget but I want to host one locally and trying to build a PC that could run one of these models.

"B" just means "billion". A 7B model has 7 billion parameters. Most models are trained in fp16, so each parameter takes two bytes at full precision. Therefore, 7B = 14GB of memory. You can easily quantize models to 8 bits per parameter with very little quality loss, so then 7B = 7GB of memory. With more quality loss (making the model dumber), you can quantize to 4 bits per parameter, so 7B = 3.5GB of memory. There ar…

So, in essence, all AMD does to launch a successful GPU in inference space is to load it with ram?

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#117
post #65

Silly question: how can OpenAI, Claude and all, have a valuation so large considering all the open source models? Not saying they will disappear or be tiny (closed models), but why so so so valuable?

The average user won't self-host a model.

...yet

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#118
post #93
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At FP16 you‘d need 64GB just for the weights, and it‘d be 2x as slow as a Q8 version, likely with little improvement. You‘ll also need space for attention and context etc, so 80-100GB (or even more) VRAM would be better. Many people „just“ use 4x consumer GPUs like the 3090 (24GB each) which scales well. They’d probably buy a mining rig, EPYC CPU, Mainboard with sufficient PCIe lanes, PCIe risers, 1600W PSU (might ne…

would it be better for energy efficiency and overall performance to use workstation cards like A5000 or A4000? Those can be found on eBay.

Looks like the A4000 has low memory bandwidth (50% of a 4090?) which is the limiting factor for inference usually. But they are efficient - if you can get them for cheap, probably a good entry setup? If you like running models that need a lot of VRAM, you‘ll likely run out of PCIe slots before you are done upgrading.

Re: Qwen2.5-VL-32B: Smarter and Lighter

#119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

good grief! people are okay with it when OpenAI and Google do it, but as soon as open source providers do it, people get defensive about it...

I trust big companies far more with my data than small ones. Big companies have so much data they won't be having a human look at mine specifically. Some small place probably has the engineer looking at my logs as user #4. Also, big companies have security teams whose job is securing the data, and it won't be going over some unencrypted link to cloudflare because OP was too lazy to set up Https certs.

Equifax.
Post reply on HN