...Today TED is an insatiable kingpin of international meme laundering... I liked this article a lot, even though I don't have as much experience with the TED community as the author does. Applying a acerbic wit and cynical eye to what we do as technical people is sorely needed. And the author has a point: at some point the language gets so conceptual and fuzzy that it becomes more of a performance than a knowledge-s…
The Naked and the TED
21–30 of 37 posts
Re: The Naked and the TED
#22...Today TED is an insatiable kingpin of international meme laundering... I liked this article a lot, even though I don't have as much experience with the TED community as the author does. Applying a acerbic wit and cynical eye to what we do as technical people is sorely needed. And the author has a point: at some point the language gets so conceptual and fuzzy that it becomes more of a performance than a knowledge-s…
Relevant essay: http://lesswrong.com/lw/2pv/intellectual_hipsters_and_metaco...
Re: The Naked and the TED
#23Re: The Naked and the TED
#24Likewise, when a publication focused on politics analyzes problems, the solutions are always political, never technological. If you follow the author's logic, most of the issues presented in TED talks could be solved with laws.
I'm quite cynical about the somewhat simplistic solutions offered by some TED speakers, but I don't see laws and political debate solving most of the problems TED discusses.
Re: The Naked and the TED
#25Sour sour sour grapes. The thing about TED is, wild-eyed though it may be, it's not a political agenda. It's (trying to be) beyond that, about technology and science and understanding, and while the result is often pretty technocratic it is actually often reflecting the benefits of self-organisation through tech. Stuff like Wikipedia, for example, is perfect TED-fodder because it shows demonstrable ways of doing thin…
Is there some alternate Wikipedia out there that's not a bureaucratic, inefficient, often self-destructive mess? If I drew anything from Wikipedia, I'd draw the conclusion that this sort of 'non-political' technological organization becomes intensely political, with most decisions made through behind-the-scenes rules-related politicking by the people with the most time to burn. Horrifying, because the people with the…
You have a brutally dry sense of humor.
Re: The Naked and the TED
#26The money swirling around it doesn't help, in this regard.
Re: The Naked and the TED
#27The author almost but not quite describes "the singularity" as a kind of secular pseudo-intellectual rapture. Nailed it.
Re: The Naked and the TED
#28Sour sour sour grapes. The thing about TED is, wild-eyed though it may be, it's not a political agenda. It's (trying to be) beyond that, about technology and science and understanding, and while the result is often pretty technocratic it is actually often reflecting the benefits of self-organisation through tech. Stuff like Wikipedia, for example, is perfect TED-fodder because it shows demonstrable ways of doing thin…
Re: The Naked and the TED
#29Earlier quoted context omitted.
Is there some alternate Wikipedia out there that's not a bureaucratic, inefficient, often self-destructive mess? If I drew anything from Wikipedia, I'd draw the conclusion that this sort of 'non-political' technological organization becomes intensely political, with most decisions made through behind-the-scenes rules-related politicking by the people with the most time to burn. Horrifying, because the people with the…
I can't imagine the distopia that'd result if things like zoning laws or environmental regulations were decided by the same process. You have a brutally dry sense of humor.
Re: The Naked and the TED
#30Sour sour sour grapes. The thing about TED is, wild-eyed though it may be, it's not a political agenda. It's (trying to be) beyond that, about technology and science and understanding, and while the result is often pretty technocratic it is actually often reflecting the benefits of self-organisation through tech. Stuff like Wikipedia, for example, is perfect TED-fodder because it shows demonstrable ways of doing thin…
Is there some alternate Wikipedia out there that's not a bureaucratic, inefficient, often self-destructive mess? If I drew anything from Wikipedia, I'd draw the conclusion that this sort of 'non-political' technological organization becomes intensely political, with most decisions made through behind-the-scenes rules-related politicking by the people with the most time to burn. Horrifying, because the people with the…