Live data from Hacker News

Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

dezeen.com

91–100 of 273 posts

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#91

Reminds me of this from 1986 (The Dead Kennedys), talking about the co-option of the Punk counter-culture by the mainstream: Punk's not dead; it just deserves to die.

Urban Struggle by The Vandals sort of brings up buying your way into a subculture.

Cake really nailed it with Rock-'n'-roll Lifestyle tho.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#92
post #51

I am a sci-fi nerd and I also found Neuromancer incredibly boring, but that's probably because it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine. I'm not a fan if present-ish day sci-fi though, reality is depressing enough as it is.

> I'm not a fan if present-ish day sci-fi though, reality is depressing enough as it is. I subscribe to the Asimov's sci-fi short story magazine (I highly recommend it!) and yeah, I have to skip every story that starts with "the world was devastated by climate change 20-50 years ago, here's how we're surviving now above the flooded remains of our world." I just can't take it.

Stephen Baxter's Flood is worse. In it, the sea starts rising and it turns out that it's not climate change causing it. Massive amounts of water stored in the upper mantle somehow start being released, so there's no stopping it. The book ends with some of the survivors on rafts in the Himalayas watching Everest disappear beneath the waves.

Scariest shit I've ever read, worse than any horror novel. Thankfully it's just a dumb story and the science of it is really dubious.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not just commodification. If you were a punk in the 80s with a green mohawk, you might find it cute to put one on your kid in the 2000s. I have long hair, my son has long hair. This isn't a commodification of a culture, it's me, like every parent ever, using my culture to inform how I raise my kids. What am I going to do? Not dress and present my kid how I want to and how I identify?

You are going to let him choose his own hairstyle.

Toddlers don't have that level of agency.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#94

Steve Albini captured this perfectly in an essay to The Baffler called "Commodify your Dissent". I highly recommend it, as it described the commodification of subculture that started in the 80's and really swallowed everything in the 1990's (in the USA at least); Here's the book: https://store.thebaffler.com/products/commodify-your-dissent One of his examples is that music and clothing companies realized there was a…

Albini was a real treasure.

Leading up to and during the Covid pandemic he recorded a large number of videos on recording craft and techniques for free viewing.

Died young, but of course…

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#95

I am a sci-fi nerd and I also found Neuromancer incredibly boring, but that's probably because it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine. I'm not a fan if present-ish day sci-fi though, reality is depressing enough as it is.

I felt the same way about Hyperion by Dan Simmons. Went in not knowing or caring when it was written and some themes felt played out, but realizing it was 1989 cast it in a totally different light for me. Weird how that works.

I read it (the full 4 book series) as a teen prior to 2000. Very different experience! One of my favorite reads of all time.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#96
post #72

Capitalism absorbs everything. Just look at the anarchism symbol. It has been turned into a fashion element for edgy teenagers. Even a brand. https://www.acupuncture1993.com/

All that's being "ruined" is people's ability to pretend that building identity through access to exclusive cultural groups and hard-to-get consumer items represents some kind rarified social achievement. Commodifying it punctures their illusion of specialness and makes it clear that they don't value their culture in itself, they value how it sets them apart from putatively lesser people. If capitalism ruins that for them, then good.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#97

Steve Albini captured this perfectly in an essay to The Baffler called "Commodify your Dissent". I highly recommend it, as it described the commodification of subculture that started in the 80's and really swallowed everything in the 1990's (in the USA at least); Here's the book: https://store.thebaffler.com/products/commodify-your-dissent One of his examples is that music and clothing companies realized there was a…

It's not just commodification. If you were a punk in the 80s with a green mohawk, you might find it cute to put one on your kid in the 2000s. I have long hair, my son has long hair. This isn't a commodification of a culture, it's me, like every parent ever, using my culture to inform how I raise my kids. What am I going to do? Not dress and present my kid how I want to and how I identify?

Well, how did you as a teen decide to do tall green hair?

I actually agree with your point, but there's a really solid devil's advocate side to take against it, too.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#98

Steve Albini captured this perfectly in an essay to The Baffler called "Commodify your Dissent". I highly recommend it, as it described the commodification of subculture that started in the 80's and really swallowed everything in the 1990's (in the USA at least); Here's the book: https://store.thebaffler.com/products/commodify-your-dissent One of his examples is that music and clothing companies realized there was a…

It's not just commodification. If you were a punk in the 80s with a green mohawk, you might find it cute to put one on your kid in the 2000s. I have long hair, my son has long hair. This isn't a commodification of a culture, it's me, like every parent ever, using my culture to inform how I raise my kids. What am I going to do? Not dress and present my kid how I want to and how I identify?

Depends why you were/are punk and what it means to you. Is it a fashion statement, a music genre, a lifestyle, a political faction, etc..

No one agrees, of course. In any case, for me, it's not something I'd force on my kid. Sort of goes against the spirit.

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#99

I am a sci-fi nerd and I also found Neuromancer incredibly boring, but that's probably because it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine. I'm not a fan if present-ish day sci-fi though, reality is depressing enough as it is.

+1 on my contra list for the book, which I have not read yet because the lingo annoybored me after two or three pages. > it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine So you've read works that build on Necromancer earlier. Care to share some of those books/authors and concepts?

Bruce Sterling?

Re: Anything threatening to be a subculture is commodified before it can walk (2014)

#100

I am a sci-fi nerd and I also found Neuromancer incredibly boring, but that's probably because it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine. I'm not a fan if present-ish day sci-fi though, reality is depressing enough as it is.

I am a sci-fi nerd and I also found Neuromancer incredibly boring, I'm curious... if you're willing to say, when did you first read Neuromancer? And had you read a lot of other cyberpunk themed media beforehand? but that's probably because it introduced so many concepts that others went on to refine. Yeah, if you'd already been exposed to a lot of the core ideas / themes from other more contemporary works, I can see…

I got it for Christmas, so just last month actually! I think it's possible it's just too late now, apart from a historical perspective. The concepts have become obvious and the prose is... not for me.

In terms of influence I suppose I'm mostly thinking of movies and shows such as the Matrix, but I also read so many short stories involving VR and techno-dystopias it's hard to pinpoint. Snowcrash is certainly up there (yes I tried to read Snowcrash first, having done no research, and liked it even less). Having played every Shadowrun game doesn't help (the universe is in a lot of ways "just" fantasy Neuromancer).

All that being said, Neuromancer doesn't read like a cheap copy either. More like I've been riding bicycles all my life and someone presented me with a penny farthing. I appreciate the innovation, it's just not particularly mind-blowing anymore.

Post reply on HN